Caicedo or Benjani?

[15martinpetrov]

Settle an argument between me and a mate:

Who'd you rather have up front in Hamburg, if Bellamy's out, Caicedo or Benjani?

We both think each other is talking total bollocks.

 

[mattyctid]

Benjani for me mate, he played well v Schalke and got a goal too

 

[JonnyQuest]

benjani in a flash i fucking hate that ridiculous **** caicedo

 

[Otamendi's Beard]

Caicedo for me everytime!! Benjani is a headless chicken at least phil can shoot.

 

[Theo555]

I would prefer Benjani but caecido is match fit at the moment so it has to be him

 

[hertsblue]

tough one to call.

Caicedo to give the ball away through poor control and non movement or benjani giving possesion away due to being offside or poor control.

Slightly favour benjani, as his smile is better plus experience

 

[johnmc]

Chad

 

[allblues09]

Caicedo
Benjani can only be bothered when we play Portsmouth, other than that he is quite lazy on the pitch.

 

[Bill]

i would play hughes before big phil.

benny for me.

 

[Grand Master Ram Rod]

Sturridge then Evans then Caicedo then Benjani.