Another new Brexit thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ric
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
The material points have been made by 40 years of membership I'm afraid.
I liked and admired your self-depreciation approach - how many Remainers have you seen do that rather than attack?

I would have expected the more balanced Remainers to view your post in the same way - rather than condone / support the 'troop' members
 
Last edited:
Can we pack in the whole "pack" thing.
It's tedious.
Yes there are,or have been posters,on both sides,either being disrespectful,trolling,or shit stirring.
Would be good - but there is no grouping on the Leave side that hound Remainers

But, there are indeed a few Remain posters that act in the manner of a..... 'group'
 
That's the best a
There’s one “silly pen” and that’s the no deal pen. It’s also the one that many on the leave side are wanting to push for now. The “Norway” Brexit that the likes of Farage originally pushed for was doable, Common Market 2.0 or a Customs Union arrangement was doable and what the leave campaign described Brexit as in 2016.

Now the above isn’t good enough and they’re about to ruin the country over a sick fetish about the UK struggling on. The new tactic by those adamant on no deal is to now blame remain voters and EU. They have no choice but to do this because the general population: those that voted to remain, those that didn’t vote in 2016 and those that voted for a soft Brexit are going to be blaming them when they lose their jobs or food prices sky rocket or they can’t get access to medicine or their business goes under or their house price dies a death.

The fact is that two sides voted, the one side that gained the most votes has seen their wish turn out to be utter shit and a small proportion of that side have double downed and blamed everyone but themselves and the liars they followed.

It’s become cult-like now.
That's the best and most balanced post I've ever seen on these fhreads.
 
You’re the most deluded man in the history of the Internet.

You don’t show respect and I’m sorry but the thing you want is detrimental to the country on a scale not seen outside of war time.

I’m going to tell you that.

Oh - such a devastating insult...

In reality you are only telling me that you are right and I must accept that and that you have no tolerance for me holding my view - there is an appropriate noun for people that act in that manner
 
Last edited:
Our time will come, looks like it's not now thanks to those who think their wishes are more important than those of the electorate. We will probably have to wait until the EU succumbs to its internal contradictions and collapses or, less likely, becomes an entirely different and more democratic creature.
That will happen - it was important for us to take the chance to put some distance between us and the 'vortex' that will be created

We would still suffer, but far worse if we are still members and integrated - and it is likely that we will still be members and integrated
 
Our time will come, looks like it's not now thanks to those who think their wishes are more important than those of the electorate. We will probably have to wait until the EU succumbs to its internal contradictions and collapses or, less likely, becomes an entirely different and more democratic creature.
Great post. I'm not sure leavers think their opinion is more important than the electorate tbh, but why should they just lie down? Part of a healthy democracy is challenging opposing views.
 
I liked and admired your self-depreciation approach - how many Remainers have you seen do that rather than attack?

I would have expected the more balanced Remainers to view your post in the same way - rather than condone / support the 'troop' members
Tbh mate I try not to tar all Remainers with the same brush. There will always be a couple of loons just as there are on our side of the debate. It's when you think you're the only sane one in the loony bin that you have a problem ;-)
 
Yellowhammer is not old.

It was commissioned by Gove, after Pfeffel became PM.
Even if it were a few months old it’s unlikely that many of the risks will have significantly diminished by Halloween. In particular, the model for Northern Ireland will still be unsustainable. The refineries will still probably close. I’m not aware of any steps being taken to prevent EU trawlers illegally fishing in Uk waters etc
 
That Ban is an issue, nobody has made the comprehensive case for remain. The argument that status quo is better than change is a difficult argument to make. People will prefer change especially if the argument resonates with their perceptions.

I actually think leave has made the better argument, I am not saying its the right argument but it is coherent, remain has made no such case, it is just more of the same. This boils down to leadership, who even leads the remain argument? Everybody knows who rightly or wrongly has made the leave argument. Of course the remain argument has been supressed by the power of the mainly leave print media and the leave leaders have almost open access to certain parts of the media.

Remain should be convincing the likes of myself of the righteousness of their cause, but they have failed and failed miserably. They have allowed the argument to drift into the realms of patriotism and nationalism without making the case for internationalism. That is a major failing of remain. They have concentrated on minds rather than hearts.
Well excuse me for thinking that the way to make a rational case for Remaining was by concentrating on minds rather than hearts.
 
Last edited:
That Ban is an issue, nobody has made the comprehensive case for remain. The argument that status quo is better than change is a difficult argument to make. People will prefer change especially if the argument resonates with their perceptions.

I actually think leave has made the better argument, I am not saying its the right argument but it is coherent, remain has made no such case, it is just more of the same. This boils down to leadership, who even leads the remain argument? Everybody knows who rightly or wrongly has made the leave argument. Of course the remain argument has been supressed by the power of the mainly leave print media and the leave leaders have almost open access to certain parts of the media.

Remain should be convincing the likes of myself of the righteousness of their cause, but they have failed and failed miserably. They have allowed the argument to drift into the realms of patriotism and nationalism without making the case for internationalism. That is a major failing of remain. They have concentrated on minds rather than hearts.

I’m sorry Russ you’re a very good poster on this forum and it’s miles better for having you but I disagree entirely with this.

The leave campaign was better in 2016 but only because they had no problem whatsoever in lying to the degree that it wasn’t just overestimating or blurring reality, it was just fabricating rhetoric about not being able to make up our own laws or Turkey joining the EU. Remain was pathetic and that was because it was ran by those two cunts Cameron and Osbourne.

Since then though the case for Remain is incredibly detailed, truthful and comprehensive. Freedom of Movement, being a member of the largest free trading bloc in history, the UK being +4% GDP better off every year due to our membership despite the contributions, being part of a union that can rival the United States and China, peace in Europe as a result, the Good Friday Agreement, liberalism across the whole continent, workers rights, regulations on food and drink that is greater than our other western allies, the UK being a scientific world leader due to EU funding, having the EU act on climate change and other future issues being easier to address... the list goes on and if you want more reasons I’m happy to provide them.

I’ll await a viable argument on why we should continue to leave and what benefits that gives us. I’m open to a single one and I’m yet to hear one.
 
So Corbyn has said and make a statement that he will do everything necessary to prevent a no deal brexit. A no deal brexit must be avoided at all costs they argue.

Ok Jeremy why did you and labour not just vote for mays deal and we would be out now with a deal.

Jeremy oh I didn’t like that deal

Boris , ok I will try and negotiate a new deal with the eu so we can leave it’s a new deal that you might support.

Remainers. Nope you cannot do that you are delusional the eu have categorically said they are not reopening the eu deal . Boris is pissing in the wind if he thinks he is going to get a new deal. But equally we cannot leave under any circumstances with no deal.

So Jezza you are going to do everything possible to stop no deal, but you

Won’t support the existing deal put forward
Believe as do remainers that the eu will not reopen the existing deal
But we can’t leave with no deal

This is how mad the argument has become on the remain side.

1We must stop no deal
2We must vote against mays deal and not support it
3 Strongly support and argue the view that the eu will not renegotiate the existing withdrawal agreement so that’s pointless , as why should they?

In order to get outcome 1 , you cannot argue points 2 and 3 as people do. In order to get the desired outcome of no deal you have to accept , if you believe in leaving with a deal , one of 2 or 3 .
 
Our time will come, looks like it's not now thanks to those who think their wishes are more important than those of the electorate. We will probably have to wait until the EU succumbs to its internal contradictions and collapses or, less likely, becomes an entirely different and more democratic creature.
What now are the wishes of the electorate?
 
Oh - such a devastating insult...

In reality you are only telling me that you are right and I must accept that and that you have no tolerance for me holding my view - there is an appropriate noun for people that act in that manner

I am right but you don’t have to accept it, you can take it or leave it (no pun intended).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top