Another new Brexit thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ric
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Is it? What's obvious is you can't have a Johnson government without Brexit so it's a weird comment for someone who opposes Brexit so vehemently to come out with. Actually, it's not a weird comment when you consider who posted it. Now with all due respect, as much as you like to "like" his posts on this thread because they square with your own opinions, you were still in primary school when I first came across said poster on another forum so I think I can safely say that I have enough experience of his character down the years to pass judgement whereas you don't. You'll learn though.

With all due respect you can fucking fuck off with your condescending shite, old man.

I’ll like what I want and don’t bring up my age or I’ll do the same.

It was obvious if you followed the conversation in which he said Johnson would make him immediately better off.

The country will go down the shit but the richest will get an instant tax cut, that’s his point.
 
Again, i've not seen anything to suggest that GDM is now a leaver who supports a deal being reached over just remaining in.

It’s not about being a “leaver” now. It’s not some sort of status that you change, like a relationship on Facebook.

He thinks remaining is best but a deal is tolerable.
 
No,I'm supportive of making the best out of the pile of shit we've been put in.

Revoking will piss off approx half the electorate.
Correct, so the only option is to leave the EU, with a deal most preferably, yes?

Cast off your "remainer" tag, join the purpose of leave and start compromising to push forward a leave deal we can all agree upon. A Common Market 2.0., EFTA membership etc.
 
WDB is not a leaver.
You've named 5 others. That is not the majority of remainers, i'm sorry to say.

Do you call yourself a leaver now, then?

Again- it’s not a fucking relationship status.

We all think remain is the best option but will compromise with a reasonable deal.

I’ll never be a leave voter.

It was off the topic of my head and I’ve named 6 regulars who are often in here, I’m not going through the entire forum list for you for fuck sake.
 
Again, i've not seen anything to suggest that GDM is now a leaver who supports a deal being reached over just remaining in.

I think with a lot of people, it's a case of honouring the referendum result and that as we're over 3 years further down the line, remaining in the EU might cause even further divisions. Be interesting if we had a second ref though with remain an option. I think some Remainers who feel exiting with a deal is the least messy way forward may be tempted to revert back to Remain. And that's their right of course
 
It’s not about being a “leaver” now. It’s not some sort of status that you change, like a relationship on Facebook.

He thinks remaining is best but a deal is tolerable.
Then he's a remainer still, if he believes remaining is the best option.

Leaving the EU (with a deal that satisfies all members of the UK union) IS the best option as it will work wonders towards healing the political divisions as a result of people ignoring the opposing sides argument. Remaining pisses off a huge portion of the electorate. No deal Brexit pisses off a huge portion of the electorate. Leaving with a deal satisfies the moderates on both sides.
 
With all due respect you can fucking fuck off with your condescending shite, old man.

I’ll like what I want and don’t bring up my age or I’ll do the same.

It was obvious if you followed the conversation in which he said Johnson would make him immediately better off.

The country will go down the shit but the richest will get an instant tax cut, that’s his point.

Congratulations on completely and utterly missing my point ;)
 
Welcome to the club then.

I’m a leaver that wants and still expects a deal.

Happy days, what have we been arguing about the last 3 years?

What is achievable in that deal. Leave voters often have an issue with reality and think the reason a Customs Union Agreement is being pushed is a sneaky ploy to trap us, when it’s the only way of upholding the GFA.

Put the border in the Irish Sea or the UK has to remain in a Customs Agreement with the EU, it’s that simple.
 
Again- it’s not a fucking relationship status.

We all think remain is the best option but will compromise with a reasonable deal.

I’ll never be a leave voter.

It was off the topic of my head and I’ve named 6 regulars who are often in here, I’m not going through the entire forum list for you for fuck sake.
Then stop saying that leavers are the problem if you STILL feel that remaining is the best option. You're still a remainer refusing to accept we must leave the EU. This isn't a debate of "how" it a debate on "which is best, leaving the EU or remaining in?" You still feel the best option is to remain in, over reaching a deal.
 
Correct, so the only option is to leave the EU, with a deal most preferably, yes?

Cast off your "remainer" tag, join the purpose of leave and start compromising to push forward a leave deal we can all agree upon. A Common Market 2.0., EFTA membership etc.
I'm a firm remainer who thinks leaving is fucking stupid, but I would take a deal. Not because this is what I want but because 1) it will end this shite and we can move on, no deal does not do this 2) it will stop all the leave voters bitching and whining that their 'democratic voice was ignored' if we remain. This doesn't make me a leave voter, it makes me a pragmatist.
 
Congratulations on completely and utterly missing my point ;)

No I got it.

You know him better than me so I shouldn’t agree with him and I was in primary school when you were at the university of Didsbury Dave’s online persona.

Tell me- who were you on here previously?
 
Then stop saying that leavers are the problem if you STILL feel that remaining is the best option. You're still a remainer refusing to accept we must leave the EU. This isn't a debate of "how" it a debate on "which is best, leaving the EU or remaining in?" You still feel the best option is to remain in, over reaching a deal.

* tries really hard not to be rude *

Are you struggling here? Seriously you’re not getting the point and I’m getting annoyed at how stupid this conversation is.

We will feel what we fucking like. We’re not going to change our opinion on EU membership because leave won the vote.

What we are doing is saying “okay, we voted to leave, let’s compromise and accept that leaving with a deal that’s reasonable is an outcome we can accept, as this was what the leave campaign said”.

It’s that straight forward.

Still believing that remaining is better is my fucking right and makes no difference to the compromise in which I’ve reached.
 
I think with a lot of people, it's a case of honouring the referendum result and that as we're over 3 years further down the line, remaining in the EU might cause even further divisions. Be interesting if we had a second ref though with remain an option. I think some Remainers who feel exiting with a deal is the least messy way forward may be tempted to revert back to Remain. And that's their right of course
The "brextremists" and "remoaners" will find their opinions dwarved by the many, many millions of voters who want a conclusion to this saga that sees us leaving the EU (thereby respecting the result) but doing so in a way that does not damage our economy; many options were presented to the UK by the EU on how to achieve this, but May refused because of HER red lines.

We should be given the choice to eliminate, one by one, which of these options the EU themselves state would work, by public vote and decide which one the majority supports. Remaining, in my view, is gone. We had that debate, and it went against them. Rejoining is the only option left for those wishing to stay in the EU.
 
I’m doing exactly what you’re doing. We’re both highlighting those on each side that won’t compromise. I actually defend the right of anyone to say what they want about Brexit, they’re entitled to but it’s not helpful.

Well that’s hardly a progressive exercise but off the top of my head-

Me
Westdidsblu
Len Rum
Bob
Blue Hefner
GDM

Apologies if I’ve missed anyone, feel free to respond stating so.

Have all stated a compromise to leave, I believe, if a reasonable deal is found.

We all agree it’ll be worse than our current agreement but we’ll compromise.

The trouble we have on here is that the argument has shifted from leave and remain to no deal and everything else. The last few months I’ve almost completely just argued against no deal but some on here now see that as an attack on Brexit as an entirety. They now only see no deal as Brexit and a deal can get in the bin.

I'm not adverse to a soft brexit deal in principle. If it was a guaranteed long term solution where we get free market access and an unobtrusive border that works for NI and all the other ports and bussiness that use them then I would sign up. It will never be as good a solution as remaining but I would take that sort of outcome.

However....

My concern is that any such deal will be ripped into from day 1 by the hard brexiteers and as a result it will not be a sustainable outcome. Farrage - the great advocate of the Norway solution will not now accept a Norway solution. And this is the problem the deal will never be hard enough for Farage, the ERG and the right wing press. The leave movement will become the clean break movement.
 
WDB is not a leaver.
You've named 5 others. That is not the majority of remainers, i'm sorry to say.

Do you call yourself a leaver now, then?
Correct, I'm a Remainer but I would accept a deal that doesn't fuck up the economy, respects the GFA and wouldn't instigate a break up of the UK. Haven't seen one proposed yet that meets those criteria, and the government don't seem inclined to consider one.
 
* tries really hard not to be rude *

Are you struggling here? Seriously you’re not getting the point and I’m getting annoyed at how stupid this conversation is.

We will feel what we fucking like. We’re not going to change our opinion on EU membership because leave won the vote.

What we are doing is saying “okay, we voted to leave, let’s compromise and accept that leaving with a deal that’s reasonable is an outcome we can accept, as this was what the leave campaign said”.

It’s that straight forward.
Yeah, which means your position is that you now support leaving the EU. For whatever reasons you wish to justify (myself, it's to heal the toxic political divisions) advocating that leaving with a deal is favourable than remaining (owing to the issues that would create) means you are a "leave supporter", not that you voted to leave or want to leave, you're a leave with a deal advocate.

It's that straight forward.
 
Last edited:
Nope. Sovereignty is a constitutional/legal term of art with a clear and specific meaning. It refers to the state by virtue of which a person or body within a society is supreme and can in the last resort impose its will upon all other persons or bodies within that society. In the UK that full right rests now in Parliament, as it has for over 300 years. Membership of the EU has not resulted in any loss of sovereignty, nor will exiting from the EU result in any increase in sovereignty.
I repeat the last line of my earlier post.
I'm afraid you've made it abundantly clear you are a paradigm case of those you describe in your compelling 'last line':

"Oh, and don’t believe anybody who blathers on about regaining sovereignty. They are spouting shite about things they don’t understand."

All international treaties involve a loss of sovereignty, that is their inevitable consequence. Joining the EU meant a progressive loss of sovereign legal competence and continuing membership of the intended federalised state will ensure the loss of our sovereign democratic processes and independence as a country if and when that primary EU objective is realised.
 
What is achievable in that deal. Leave voters often have an issue with reality and think the reason a Customs Union Agreement is being pushed is a sneaky ploy to trap us, when it’s the only way of upholding the GFA.

Put the border in the Irish Sea or the UK has to remain in a Customs Agreement with the EU, it’s that simple.
So long as it allows the UK to conduct trade deals outside of and adjacent to the EU's rules, fine by me.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top