Aguero injured

[domalino]

I know that. Regardless, he was still treated by Cugat. That's what this is about.

Seems like you would have mentioned it given how desperate you were to prove me wrong. Anyway if thats what this is about, let's hear why you think he has had improper treatment from Cugat?

And it better be good given you are basing this on absolutely fucking zero knowledge about medicine, knee surgery, De Bruyne or Cugat, but because Sané played a decent game against Schalke.

 

[ws01]

Lol - classic Domalino.

De Bruyne's not the only - THIS HAS HAPPENED TO MANY OF OUR PLAYERS NOW.

 

[Phil1]

I know that. Regardless, he was still treated by Cugat. That's what this is about.

Edit: No, mate. You're the only twat here who's never, ever able to admit when he's wrong. Ever.

Claiming that one of the most distinguished surgeons in his field is somehow inept doesn't sound like firm ground to call others out for being wrong.

 

[domalino]

Umm....... De Bruyne had three separate setbacks after his surgery in the 18/19 season.

How about this for getting facts wrong. He didnt even have surgery after the injury in august 2018. So we're both twats.

I know that. Regardless, he was still treated by Cugat. That's what this is about.

You know he didn't have surgery, but you still claimed he had 3 seperate setbacks after his surgery? He didn't have any surgery in 18/19.

What was that about admitting when you're wrong?

Now please, back to explaining why you know better than the club, and Barcelona, Madrid etc. about which surgeons are best.

 

[ws01]

Claiming that one of the most distinguished surgeons in his field is somehow inept doesn't sound like firm ground to call others out for being wrong.

Except the grounds for being called wrong were that he wasn't injured 7 months after getting over the injury which De Bruyne saw Cugat for, it was two weeks. And then he had another two after that.

 

[ws01]

You know he didn't have surgery, but you still claimed he had 3 seperate setbacks after his surgery? He didn't have any surgery in 18/19.

What was that about admitting when you're wrong?

Happy to admit that mistake for saying surgery. It wasn't surgery, but he did time with Cugat to treat the injury.

Taking the strawman and debating semantics won't get you over this one matey. The issue is Cugat treating our players when injured.

 

[Colin Bells Boots]

Funny isn't it. The one guy who doesn't see Cugrort is the one who's having no issues.

Pure coincidence, I'm sure.

So you are suggesting that the owner would be prepared to let his massive financial investment in players who are fundamental to success, be operated on by a surgeon who is not capable of performing properly ?

An interesting if highly illogical thought imo, but I am obviously unsure of your medical background .

 

[domalino]

Happy to admit that mistake for saying surgery. It wasn't surgery, but he did time with Cugat to treat the injury.

Taking the strawman and debating semantics won't get you over this one matey. The issue is Cugat treating our players when injured.

I'm not the one avoiding the direct questions asking you to back up your claim you know better than everyone else when it comes to picking knee surgeons.

Please, share with us your great orthopedic knowledge. Show us the light, we can get a crowd sourced campaign to try and stop the club doing so much damage to our players by choosing second rate doctors.

 

[ws01]

So you are suggesting that the owner would be prepared to let his massive financial investment in players who are fundamental to success, be operated on by a surgeon who is not capable of performing properly ?

An interesting if highly illogical thought imo, but I am obviously unsure of your medical background .

The owner, chairman, whoever is in charge, would've acquiesced to Pep's demands. The same demands he's had at his other clubs, the same demands which saw him get in a shit fight with Bayern and their hierarchy.

Interestingly enough, the same thing happened there, most notably with Thiago when he came back too quickly against the wishes of Bayern's own doctors after Cugat treated him. I don't need a bloody medical degree to be able to join some pretty clear dots - unfortunately though, that seems to be beyond a few here.

 

[ws01]

I'm not the one avoiding the direct questions asking you to back up your claim you know better than everyone else when it comes to picking knee surgeons.

Please, share with us your great orthopedic knowledge. Show us the light, we can get a crowd sourced campaign to try and stop the club doing so much damage to our players by choosing second rate doctors.

Give up mate. You came into another thread swinging without the facts, and you were wrong - get over it.

 

[domalino]

Give up mate. You came into another thread swinging without the facts, and you were wrong - get over it.

Give us the facts! Please. That's all anyone is asking!

Give us the facts you have at hand that let you know the club is using a bad surgeon and jeopardising the careers of our players.

We all know you'd never just turn up and start spewing bollocks about the club's medical professionals based solely on a former player making it through 90 minutes, because that would be fucking stupid beyond belief.

 

[ws01]

Give us the facts! Please. That's all anyone is asking!

Give us the facts you have at hand that let you know the club is using a bad surgeon and jeopardising the careers of our players.

Sure

No he didn't, stop spewing bullshit. Picking up a muscle injury after 7 months out is pretty common and nothing at all to do with the surgery and not at all a set back. If you waited more than 90 minutes to decide Sané's surgery was the best thing you'd ever seen, you might see him pick up a muscle injury along the way too.

18/19	Hamstring Injury	Apr 21, 2019	May 8, 2019	17 days	3
18/19	Thigh Problems	Mar 2, 2019	Mar 29, 2019	27 days	4
18/19	Muscular problems	Dec 27, 2018	Jan 2, 2019	6 days	1
18/19	Ligament Injury	Nov 1, 2018	Dec 14, 2018	43 days	11
18/19	Torn knee ligament	Aug 15, 2018	Oct 17, 2018	63 days	10

Kevin De Bruyne - Injury history

This is the injury history of Kevin De Bruyne from SSC Neapel. On this page injuries as well as suspensions.

www.transfermarkt.com

There you go :)

 

[Phil1]

Give up mate. You came into another thread swinging without the facts, and you were wrong - get over it.

You're saying with a degree of certainty that the surgeon ourselves and other top clubs use is useless? And it's us who can't connect the dots?

 

[domalino]

Sure

Kevin De Bruyne - Injury history

This is the injury history of Kevin De Bruyne from SSC Neapel. On this page injuries as well as suspensions.

www.transfermarkt.com

There you go :)

I'm going to keep replying until you come up with an answer to the very basic question.


Give us the reasons and facts you have at hand that let you know the club is using a bad surgeon and jeopardising the careers of our players.

 

[Colin Bells Boots]

The owner, chairman, whoever is in charge, would've acquiesced to Pep's demands. The same demands he's had at his other clubs, the same demands which saw him get in a shit fight with Bayern and their hierarchy.

Interestingly enough, the same thing happened there, most notably with Thiago when he came back too quickly against the wishes of Bayern's own doctors after Cugat treated him. I don't need a bloody medical degree to be able to join some pretty clear dots - unfortunately though, that seems to be beyond a few here.

So it's Pep's fault then.

Fucking knownowts like you are a curse on BM with their " expert " opinions on things they know the sum total of fuck all about .

 

[ws01]

I'm going to keep replying until you come up with an answer to the very basic question.


Give us the reasons and facts you have at hand that let you know the club is using a bad surgeon and jeopardising the careers of our players.

Sure - De Bruyne, Mendy, Laporte, and now Aguero. I may have forgotten a player/s.

You keep asking questions, I keep giving you the answers. It's up to you when you want to admit you're swinging at clean air here.

 

[domalino]

Sure

18/19	Hamstring Injury	Apr 21, 2019	May 8, 2019	17 days	3
18/19	Thigh Problems	Mar 2, 2019	Mar 29, 2019	27 days	4
18/19	Muscular problems	Dec 27, 2018	Jan 2, 2019	6 days	1
18/19	Ligament Injury	Nov 1, 2018	Dec 14, 2018	43 days	11
18/19	Torn knee ligament	Aug 15, 2018	Oct 17, 2018	63 days	10

Kevin De Bruyne - Injury history

This is the injury history of Kevin De Bruyne from SSC Neapel. On this page injuries as well as suspensions.

www.transfermarkt.com

There you go :)

By the way, you really should have abandoned this "Look at De Bruyne's injuries in 18/19" strategy when we establised he didn't have surgery under Dr. Cugat.

Because now you're blaming him for the outcome of patients he didn't treat, which is even more stupid than thinking you know who should operate on our players.

 

[bluecityste]

Give us the facts! Please. That's all anyone is asking!

Give us the facts you have at hand that let you know the club is using a bad surgeon and jeopardising the careers of our players.

I doubt he can as it is more than likely subjective, as our medical staff will obviously have all the qualifications under the sun. But from an outsiders viewpoint and comparing us to most other top clubs i think it is undeniable that we have an awful injury record and i don't think that you or anyone else can really argue too much with that.

The question is why? Surely it can't be down to just 'bad luck' as it has been going on for years.

I doubt he or anyone else can provide specific proof regarding the medical staff as it is more than likely subjective, as our medical staff will obviously have all the qualifications under the sun but something in our set-up must be 'poor' for this to be such an issue.

In my personal opinion it is probably a mix between an unknown medical issue (either in our assessment of players or treatment) and the fact that Pep tends to play the same core of players in almost every game, no matter how poor the opposition or which competition.

Whatever the reason, this will really impact us this year.

 

[ws01]

So it's Pep's fault then.

Fucking knownowts like you are a curse on BM with their " expert " opinions on things they know the sum total of fuck all about .

'Pep is an infallible God' d**k riders like you are worse, unfortunately.

 

[domalino]

Sure - De Bruyne, Mendy, Laporte, and now Aguero. I may have forgotten a player/s.

You keep asking questions, I keep giving you the answers. It's up to you when you want to admit you're swinging at clean air here.

The only one swinging at air is the fucking clown who thinks he knows better than everybody involved at City (and every top club in Spain) who should do their knee surgeries, and has nothing to back it up except the injuries of a player who didn't have surgery.

Laporte had surgery and has looked fine since. Aguero has a meniscus injury and we don't know how he's doing yet. KDB didn't have surgery. Gundogan had a surgery and has been playing 50 games a season since.

So really the only player who had a bad outcome was Mendy, who did his right ACL, and has had issues in the opposite knee since.