Im not really sure there was that many atheist societies if im honest , i cant think of any that spring to mind other than Russia, and they only practiced state based Atheism, it was never illegal.. even so they would have to go a long way to beating the Crusades and the Inquisition alone. Russia cant be really be used as an example as they have had some genuine lunatics in charge based on the way voting is so corrupt in those countries. You cant put all that on atheism when the country is ruled by a dictatorship. Especially the one most remember in Stalin. That guy was just a dick. But he had corrupt power so was untouchable.
Humans are flawed, in every walk of life. We do make the choices, but at what point is the old get out still used ? in effect you can be Joseph Stalin himself, killed million's, But if he gave the old death bed confession, he allowed in to heaven. That is complete and utter bollox really
It really can be used, this wasn’t just a society that just happened to not be religious, they implemented atheism as an actual policy and it was major part of societal change.
It also was illegal and many Christians were persecuted.
This is from the Wikipedia page:
From 1932 to 1937 Joseph Stalindeclared the 'five-year plans of atheism' and the LMG was charged with completely eliminating all religiousexpression in the country. Many of these same methods and terror tactics were also imposed against others that the regime considered to be its ideological enemies.
If we’re accounting the number killed during the rule of the USSR was a minimum of 15m, directly from the government, although historians believe it could be much much higher, the Spanish Inquisition was between 3,000 and 5,000 executed and the Crusades is relatively unknown due to the obvious, but it’s likely not anywhere near 15m, maybe 10% of that based on Google sources and counting only civilians it’s like 1% of the USSR’s persecution of their own people.
Now, does that mean atheism should get the blame for the USSR? No.
It also doesn’t mean Christianity should get the blame for an individual Pope ordering wars a thousand years ago.
You’ve also got state atheism in Mao’s China:
The People's Republic of China, proclaimed in 1949 under the leadership of Mao Zedong, established a policy of state atheism. Initially, the new government did not suppress religious practice, but, like its dynastic ancestors, viewed popular religious movements, especially in the countryside, as possibly seditious.
And you’ve got Pol Pot too:
The Khmer Rouge actively persecuted Buddhists during their reign from 1975 to 1979. ... 25,000 Buddhist monks were massacred by the regime, which was officially an atheist state. The persecution was undertaken because Pol Pot believed that Buddhism was "a decadent affectation".
Millions killed in both of these too, all within the same century.
Again, this isn’t to attack atheism generally speaking and atheists, as no one on this forum is being led to these things purely from not believing in God, I should know as a former atheist, I didn’t want to kill anyone.
I am merely pointing out that atheism has lead some societies to atrocities, as religious belief has.
So let’s judge each other on our actions as individuals and in more specific groups today, rather than throwing the crusades at modern day Anglicans as a stick to beat their beliefs with.