Kalvin Phillips | Joins City on a 6-year deal

Status
Not open for further replies.
Scouting Philips on the off chance you may get a cut-price run at him, allowing for a cushion of bodies in midfield, if gundo decides to walk and still bag a De Jong etc is no brainer for me. Due diligence to at least see what the offer/need is, very much doubt he's first on the list.
 
Scouting Philips on the off chance you may get a cut-price run at him, allowing for a cushion of bodies in midfield, if gundo decides to walk and still bag a De Jong etc is no brainer for me. Due diligence to at least see what the offer/need is, very much doubt he's first on the list.
Zinchenko could do a job there and he has a similar skill set and attitude to Phillips.
 
I quite like the idea of this. Would very much remind me of the Ake signing, he’s clearly never get in our best 11 (injuries aside) but I think he’d be more than able and would allow us to rotate Rodri better than we’ve been able to this season. With Fern leaving we absolutely need to bring someone in and At 25m it would be a no brainier for me.
 
I quite like the idea of this. Would very much remind me of the Ake signing, he’s clearly never get in our best 11 (injuries aside) but I think he’d be more than able and would allow us to rotate Rodri better than we’ve been able to this season. With Fern leaving we absolutely need to bring someone in and At 25m it would be a no brainier for me.
The Ake link wasn't too bad to be honest. With that you could see what he could add.
 
I quite like the idea of this. Would very much remind me of the Ake signing, he’s clearly never get in our best 11 (injuries aside) but I think he’d be more than able and would allow us to rotate Rodri better than we’ve been able to this season. With Fern leaving we absolutely need to bring someone in and At 25m it would be a no brainier for me.
Ake has been very much a backup player. Playing as a 6 is a different kettle of fish altogether
 
Put it this way, if Pep and the board think he is a good addition then who am I to argue, I suspect Pep sees things in players that others don't.

It does make me think about how the dippers always seem to find players who look average but excel in a system.
 
Put it this way, if Pep and the board think he is a good addition then who am I to argue, I suspect Pep sees things in players that others don't.

It does make me think about how the dippers always seem to find players who look average but excel in a system.
More down to the moneyball system and plenty of turd polishing and hacking our scouting database. Saying that they don't get ripped off too often so it is not though Leeds are (yet) asking for really silly money.
 
I am detecting a high level of snobbery with the Philips transfer speculation. If the price is only £25m then it’s a shrewd piece of business. He might not have a fancy foreign sounding name but knows the league and is a tenacious player who is very much needed in a squad like ours. Ake was looked down on and apart from injuries has been a revelation. He may not be a wow name but we have Haaland for that. The squad needs more ZIn’s and Ake’s to help with the match load.

Having thought about it, he would be a good fit for this city team. The low fee makes it almost risk free. Add in league experience and that’s what you call an astute signing. Trained under a coach that pep admires.

Now all we need is Leeds to get relegated.
 
I am detecting a high level of snobbery with the Philips transfer speculation. If the price is only £25m then it’s a shrewd piece of business. He might not have a fancy foreign sounding name but knows the league and is a tenacious player who is very much needed in a squad like ours. Ake was looked down on and apart from injuries has been a revelation. He may not be a wow name but we have Haaland for that. The squad needs more ZIn’s and Ake’s to help with the match load.

Having thought about it, he would be a good fit for this city team. The low fee makes it almost risk free. Add in league experience and that’s what you call an astute signing. Trained under a coach that pep admires.

Now all we need is Leeds to get relegated.
It’s not risk free when he’s taking up squad space and will mean we don’t get someone actually, you know, good. Oh, he knows the league? Let me start listing players from the same position who didn’t and beyond excelled in the league… starting with our own club…
 
I am not a complete snob but we can do a lot better as a squad option; even if it is a cheap option. This reminds me of us during the earlier part of the takeover where it was necessary to sign them types of players at the time; but we had outgrown them as we had progressed.
 
It’s not risk free when he’s taking up squad space and will mean we don’t get someone actually, you know, good. Oh, he knows the league? Let me start listing players from the same position who didn’t and beyond excelled in the league… starting with our own club…
Nearly risk free when you consider the low payment and his experience of playing in a bielsa team. Not every player needs to be the next hot name banded about on Twitter. I like him and he would do a job similar to Nigel. He reminds me of a Jack Russell snapping away and breaking up play. I would have taken that in Madrid.
 
Nearly risk free when you consider the low payment and his experience of playing in a bielsa team. Not every player needs to be the next hot name banded about on Twitter. I like him and he would do a job similar to Nigel. He reminds me of a Jack Russell snapping away and breaking up play. I would have taken that in Madrid.
We’re gonna have to disagree on this one. I could take some even more unknown and cheaper names than him with more quality or potential and younger.

I also don’t believe these links… so we’ll see hehe
 
It’s not risk free when he’s taking up squad space and will mean we don’t get someone actually, you know, good. Oh, he knows the league? Let me start listing players from the same position who didn’t and beyond excelled in the league… starting with our own club…
We have plenty of squad space for English players… Try again.
 
We have plenty of squad space for English players… Try again.
I don’t think you understand my point. Pep works with a limited amount of players. You bring one, that’s one less that will come. If you told me Phillips wouldn’t stop more from coming, then I wouldn’t oppose.
I wasn’t talking about homegrown players
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top