PL charge City for alleged breaches of financial rules

Do we have anything nuclear to go on the Premier League with? Surely if we had, we'd have dropped a couple of subtle hints to the main protagonists prior to this to get them to put the brakes on. It looks to me like the Big 6 aren't worried what City might have.
Don't overlook the fact that the owners of the red-shirted mafia are all from corporate USA, and they are used to getting what they want by hiring political lobbyists to bully and/or bribe Congress to pass the legislation that benefits them.They may well be guilty of over-confidence in this case.
 
Could we not get Lord Pannick to just say the charges are subjective and we are not guilty but maybe if the charges were brought next week against another club then the result maybe different
 
Is it not time for seperate threads on contract law, geopolitical consequences etc so we can all get up to speed on the necesscary arguements to defend ourselves in the wider world :-) :-)
 
No, if you join a club you sign up to obey their rules even if they are anti-competitive.
If you join a club which doesn't allow white men, Chinese lesbians, disabled Blacks?

I assume these 'rules' would only remain until they were legally challenged, because they go against the law of the land.

Isn't that like me declaring my own "Law/Rule" that me & my fellow "Street Racer Club" members can drive at 100mph within the boundaries of Manchester?
 
I was always of the impression you can have whatever you like in a contract, doesn,t mean its lawful and ultimately has to be enforced through the courts.

Assuming weve signed up to a contract with premier league then appears unfair terms and conditions can be challenged between businesses. (That said i,m no lawyer so may well be talking bollocks :-) )

Article below explains possiblities.


As a general rule in English law, courts will strike down contracts, even if freely entered into, if they are unfair or contrary to public policy. See George Eastham and several pop music business cases, for example.
Courts would not, for example, enforce a contact that required someone to break the law, or not enter into a marriage.
 
Woke up this morning and felt a need to write something as a life long Manchester City fan. So much negativity around the club that I love and have watched since 1968.

It has been said in the media world that the truth should never get in the way of a good story. Over the course of my life, 60 years this far, I have seen this to be self evident in many many situations, both sporting and non.

Their job is to sell newspapers, get clicks and stir the pot. It has always been so. It may feel different in this scenario because they are going after our beloved Manchester City but we have been here before and won. .

We know what it feels like to be fucked.To feel like it has all gone tits up.

Halifax in the Cup.
Luton and David Pleat.
Ricky Villa.
Years and years of spankings by the different red shirts. Knowing we were shit and still showing up. We were there, somewhere, having our own experience of being City.

We know what it feels like.

Unlike all of our antagonists, who have dined for a long time at the top table. Who gorged themselves on a cycle of unfettered success. Unchallenged because of the hegemony they created.
They became complacent and stuffed full of themselves and their self important shite. Corrupt and bloated to the core.

They do not know how it feels to lose.

So when we kicked the door down, because it was the only way in, and brought a level of competition they could not live with,they did not have the spine for the fight. None of them. They tried to meet us on the pitch and failed. They tried through UEFA to knock us out and they failed again. So now they resort to the only weapon they have left. Old money. Old power. Friends in high places. The real corruption. Hidden in plain sight.

But they have picked a fight with a club who know how to scrap.We know the pain of losing big and we know how to come back from that.

Dropping 2 divisions.
Dark days and grim gallows humour.That place somewhere in the old ridings where 300,000 of us watched on in the shadows
Then Gillingham. A moment when the future looked so bleak that people walked away from Wembley , muttering "fucking typical City," only to be drawn back by a miracle.
Imagine that we had lost. I did. And I knew we would still be here come the next season.
QPR. Dead and buried. To make matters worse the old enemy winning it all. Again. Not in my lifetime. You think? Another miracle. A big fuck off metaphorical wink from Mario.

Champions.

Only this.

Just the beginning.

This club, players, management and of course us, the supporters, do not ever lie down.This too I have witnessed. Time and time again. We are City.
It is not even about the winning for me. When you have lost so many times you understand the balance of all things more deeply. You know you can always lose and it makes the joy of winning something our red friends will never ever get to experience.

The day Sergio scored was the loudest noise I ever heard in a football ground and I knew why. That banner. That sanctimonious, rub it in our faces spineless bunch of toss perpetrated by the prawn sandwich brigade. The old money. They never saw it coming. Noisy neighbours indeed.

I understood completely and more than ever before what it meant to be a Manchester City fan.
We can lose this current fight and we will still be here. That's what makes us a fucker to fight with. We don't know when we are beaten.

We're Man City.

We'll fight to the end.
couldn't have said that any better, fantastic post mate
 
Well there's fewer than 2,000 KCs to begin with.

25% of those would be senior enough for this?

How many of those have decades of experience in sport? How many have been deputy high court judges? And how many have spent the last 8 years specialising in arbitration and mediation?


This guy was voted into his position overseeing all disciplinary cases by the 20 PL clubs 3 years ago. That means 19 (including City) were voting for someone who supported another team.
I am sure he isn't the only one with the necessary qualifications and they could find one without a season ticket at a "big six" club. Anyway, I take your point that my whinging won't make any difference so I will shut up about it.

:)
 
bu
If it goes to a fair Independent court, I’m confident we’ll get off without anything major. I just don’t trust this Arsenal fan leading the case for the PL and he gets to choose his team.
but if the arsenal fan knows the high court is an option is he really going to give an unfair verdict?? knowing that if the high court rule he has given an unfair verdict he is finished.
 
Is it not time for seperate threads on contract law, geopolitical consequences etc so we can all get up to speed on the necesscary arguements to defend ourselves in the wider world :-) :-)

arbitration-for-dummies and learn tax law in 20 minutes (2022 edition) should be part of the Sportswasher's defenders kit we all got sent by Sheikh Mansour along with the barrel of crude did you not get yours?
 
I rekon if we get found guilty I think the super league will rear its head again and this time I'd probably back it, its amazing that they're charging us for financial breaches there just out to get us and the premier league are so corrupt

The Super League isn't happening. This is simply a play to redress the balance in the Premier League towards those clubs who believe they are the reason for the large TV deals in the first instance.

Each of the English clubs who signed up for the Super League were eventually forced to come back with their tails between their legs and sign an agreement not to try again, with a £300m fine for any such attempt.

So now they want a Super League under the umbrella of the Premier League, where mid to lower teams will vote for the vested interests of keeping United, Arsenal, Chelsea, Spurs and the Murderers in the equation.

City are the fall guy for it. Whether to take us to the wall or render us uncompetitive on and off the pitch for a period of time that provides no threat and tarred forever.

We want an independent regulator.

Even clubs like West Ham and Bournemouth don't want that.

Turkeys will always vote for Christmas, even if means taking their chances the butcher won't put them on the chopping block for a while.
 
Last edited:
Now that formal accusations have been made I would expect no public communications from either side, probably on the advice of the respective lawyers.
That seems sensible. However the red cartel do have their useful idiot foot soldiers in the media. Let's see what 2 hypothetical cunts ( let's call them david and rick) try leaking to the press this time!
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top