Bell, Lee and Summerbee statue | Unveiled (pg19)

[ShorehamCitizen]

What is a tomato if not a fruit? A droop?

A fruit in reality, but mistaken for a vegetable

 

[Johnny Mars Bar]

At some point in time the whole stadium will be surrounded by statues.

And that’s just the fans in the east stand.

 

[KS55]

A fruit in reality, but mistaken for a vegetable

Oh, I misunderstood your post. Sorry.

 

[J.G.Blue.]

First time I have seen the statue properly yesterday & I think it is fantastic, well done to all involved.

 

[Gary James]

Yep, even if Law mishit it and it didn't go in, the Rags still would have gone down.

It's one of life's common misconceptions up there with a tomato is a fruit, a Knighthood etc is forever when it actually expires on death of the recipient, Crystal Palace play where the palace itself once was, Holland is the name of the country when in fact it's a region and the Pyramids of Egypt were constructed with slave labour.

Still, it always makes me snigger whenever it's brought up.

Although.... At the time the pitch invasions (there were 2) occurred Utd were not mathematically down. If we think about the drama of the Aguero day or of other promotion/relegation/title winning drama days it's never over until a whistle is blown at a deciding game. Anything can happen in those final few minutes.

I've interviewed players from that day and read contemporary newspapers to pull out the full story and facts, and what happened was that after the second pitch invasion, the ref took the players off the pitch and they waited in the dressing rooms. Once the ref knew that results elsewhere meant Utd were definitely down then he abandoned the match. He waited. Had there been hope then the rest of the game would've been played seems to be the actual view from that day. It was highly unusual for a result to stand when a game was abandoned with minutes left to play and so the ref seemed to take the sensible approach and wait for Utd's relegation verdict to be known before abandoning it. Had there still been hope for Utd then maybe he would have played the remaining minutes?

So, to summarise: For United there was still hope that relegation could be avoided before Law scored even though results elsewhere were going against them. Before the game Utd were not relegated; at the time of Law's goal Utd's hopes faded (but had still not been extinguished) and then after the game Utd were relegated. It may not have been mathematically the goal that relegated Utd but it was the game where Utd's chances ended. Think of all those last game dramas we've had - that's how it would've felt. Hope fading away and realisation dawning that relegation is happening and your former hero is the one who extinguishes all hope.

 

[threespires]

Looking forward to having a proper leisurely look at it when the novelty wears off and there's less of a scrum around it.

 

[TinFoilHat]

Really enjoyed the documentary on them and the making of the statue. Albeit bittersweet as my old man worshipped them all. Would have loved to have watched it with him just to see his reaction.

 

[ancoats]

Manchester City DNA. We will never forget where we come from, NO matter how far we go

 

[goater1985]

My old man (I'm no spring chicken) messaged me saying it's been 46 years to day since King Colin made his his comeback. Apparently was 0-0 at HT then we won 4-0, Tueart hat trick.

 

[Mike N]

My old man (I'm no spring chicken) messaged me saying it's been 46 years to day since King Colin made his his comeback. Apparently was 0-0 at HT then we won 4-0, Tueart hat trick.

Wow that has made me feel old!

I was 12 years old in the Kippax. Apart from a handful of obvious exceptions, it was the greatest ever atmosphere I’ve experienced.

 

[Lovebitesandeveryfing]

I think it becomes a bit silly if we keep doing statues.

Could be a way of filling all those “empty seats at 'ooome”.

 

[cityontheup]

Just bumping this, didn’t want to start a new thread. But with current city great players time with us approaching the end, De Bruyne, Silva, Walker, I was just wondering who will be getting a statue?

 

[mexico1970]

No more statues please, can we have some plaques?

 

[cityontheup]

No more statues please, can we have some plaques?

I’ve said before plaques would be good, A Walk of Fame type thing

 

[mexico1970]

I’ve said before plaques would be good, A Walk of Fame type thing

We could easily do a team a year on the walls of the Etihad.

 

[cityontheup]

We could easily do a team a year on the walls of the Etihad.

Sound good, a wall of fame

 

[Joe Corrigan's Superstitions]

Just bumping this, didn’t want to start a new thread. But with current city great players time with us approaching the end, De Bruyne, Silva, Walker, I was just wondering who will be getting a statue?

I see the criteria as being (in no particular order):
1/ 10+ years' service
2/ c. 400 appearances
3/ Being recognised as one of, if not the best in their position during their era.
4/ Trophies, records or status within the club (Club Captain, record goal scorer etc.)

On that basis, only KDB will qualify and I think he will deserve one in the same style as Sergio, Vinnie and Merlin as he's been just as influential in the same era as those three were.

After that, I don't think there'll be any more until Phil retires. But at the rate Phil's going, he could end up with 600+ appearances and be the most decorated English player ever. So who knows what will be appropriate to recognise his contribution by the time he's finished playing.

Obviously Pep deserves, and will surely get, significant recognition but I could see that being a stand rather than (or as well as) a statue, especially if he extends his contract to complete 10 years.

 

[KS55]

I’ve said before plaques would be good, A Walk of Fame type thing

Yup. Not a fan of statues. Gary James I believe spoke to the club about a walk of fame but nothing transpired.

 

[LangleyBlue1970]

Enough statues. Anymore will look ridiculous, and I include one for KDB there. There is a reason the statues we have are there.

 

[Tourist since 1971]

Absolutely brilliant, shed many a tear watching it. x

I’d missed this. What a fantastic documentary. When they showed the design to Mike, Frannie and Colin’s family, I’d challenge anyone not to be floored.