Andrea Cambiaso

That's not quite correct, 25 players can be in the squad UEFA A list, currently 26 are listed overall with 5 on the B list.
So 21 currently on the A list above which includes Walker & Esbrand who have now departed - that leaves 19 filled places (one of whom is Rodri) of which 14 are on the permitted on the A list to which I have added Marmoush to make 15.
  • STEFAN ORTEGA MORENO 18
  • EDERSON MORAES 31
  • RÚBEN DIAS 3
  • JOŠKO GVARDIOL 24
  • MANUEL AKANJI25
  • RODRIGO HERNANDEZ 16
  • MATEO KOVAČIĆ 8
  • KEVIN DE BRUYNE 17
  • İLKAY GÜNDOĞAN 19
  • BERNARDO SILVA 20
  • MATHEUS NUNES 27
  • JÉRÉMY DOKU 11
  • SAVINHO 26
  • OMAR MARMOUSH 7
  • ERLING HAALAND 9
  • VACANCY - GONZALEZ or REIS?
  • VACANCY -CAMBIASO or KHUSANOV?
(Next season Bobb (replacing Esbrand) will join Foden & McAtee in the club trained over-21 element, the association trained one is full with Stones, Grealish, Ake & Carson but this does not affect the above.)
Thanks couldn't be bothered doing that myself, was thinking more next season are you missing Echeverri though, presuming he stays .
 
We won't be getting any more this window, mark my words. Meanwhile, it has been reported that Cambiaso has expressed no desire whatsoever to leave Juventus.
Good. Dont think he is that good personally. And would rather get a better RB like Livramento or Vanderson anyway.
 
Thanks couldn't be bothered doing that myself, was thinking more next season are you missing Echeverri though, presuming he stays .
Oh no! He's going to be an option too when he's finished at the U-20 the but currently only 19 like Lewis (who I also forgot) and remains on the B list next season. Happy to be bothered though.
Good. Dont think he is that good personally. And would rather get a better RB like Livramento or Vanderson anyway.
never rated that rag
9781842260173-uk.jpg
 
If we get Gonzalez, and Cambiaso this window, I think for incoming the summer will be fairly quiet probably an AM and possibly a keepr. Be fairly busy outgoings though.
I think we'll definitely go for a top-class De Bruyne replacement in the summer, especially since a lot of players will be leaving. I expect Grealish and Gündogan to go for sure, so I believe we'll sign minimum two elite attacking midfielders, which will be very expensive. That's why it's good that we're doing it this way - signing the other players now in winter so we can fully focus on them in the summer.
 
The only one I disagree with is Doku -i think he has shown he is good enough - he gives us something different and has real quality - he can finish he can beat his man and he can assist...he is young and still developing but I think he is a top quality squad player that doesnt always need to start but you always get 100% from and has a great attitude and bags of ability

Walker -gone - it was a good decision for all parties
Gundo - not sure he should have come back but hindsight is a wonderful thing - but he now needs to go or risk tarnishing his legacy.
Kova - a good solid signing - maybe another year but if we can get replacements then agree he can go
Ederson - seems to be an attitude thing with him....he can still perform at the highest level I have no doubt BUT mentally he looks like he is elsewhere...it will be because he wants to leave but if he had a change of attitude Id happily see him stay - otherwise yes he needs to go
KDB - if he signs an extension its sentiment driving this - he will be top earner - keeping him stops us progressing at this point and we wont be able to bring in his replacement....I personally think KDB should be let go at the end of the season - he leaves a legend and probably the best midfielder to ever grace the prem league and goes to earn generational wealth in Saudi.....win win for all concerned.

Ake and Stones- both fantastic performers - but both have always been injury prone.....such a shame with Stones especially as you can see he fits that number 6 role really well - its an unknown on these two as its all down to fitness
The issue with Doku is not ability, he has that in droves but I am not sure he is the brightest in terms of football intelligence. I get the feeling Pep has huge doubts about him other than games against lesser sides.

I would love to keep Ederson and to replace him with his skill set is almost impossible but the offer from Saudi has clearly affected him and with I am not sure any of us have the right to say he would be wrong to go and earn 300/400k a week and go into semi retirement, he has already won the lot.

KDB has to go for me, leave with the crown wanting more and we have seen from Gundogan romantic decisions simply don't work
 
Oh no! He's going to be an option too when he's finished at the U-20 the but currently only 19 like Lewis (who I also forgot) and remains on the B list next season. Happy to be bothered though.

Echeverri will not be eligible for the B list this or next season. You need to be 21 or under AND have been registered with the club for 2 years to qualify for the B list. Echeverri would have to be registered on the A list if registered at all.
 
The issue with Doku is not ability, he has that in droves but I am not sure he is the brightest in terms of football intelligence. I get the feeling Pep has huge doubts about him other than games against lesser sides.

I would love to keep Ederson and to replace him with his skill set is almost impossible but the offer from Saudi has clearly affected him and with I am not sure any of us have the right to say he would be wrong to go and earn 300/400k a week and go into semi retirement, he has already won the lot.

KDB has to go for me, leave with the crown wanting more and we have seen from Gundogan romantic decisions simply don't work
Agree on Ederson KDB an Gundo

I think Doku does have it intelligence wise - he adapted pretty damn quick to what Pep wants (look at him compared to Mahrez who took ages to get regular game time) and he has shown through his play - he has scored and assisted way more that Grealish for example who (for reasons I just dont agree with is lauded by many on here - yes he holds width, yes he helps control posession but that is literally about it other than buying fouls here and there) and he is learning the positonal play and defensive side of the game....difference is he takes risks and chances so he is going to give the ball away - that for me aint about his intelligence - its about his style of play - I guess theonly thing would be picking his time to take someone on or not - which for me he is doing as he is taking people on less and it must be for that reason.
 
Agree on Ederson KDB an Gundo

I think Doku does have it intelligence wise - he adapted pretty damn quick to what Pep wants (look at him compared to Mahrez who took ages to get regular game time) and he has shown through his play - he has scored and assisted way more that Grealish for example who (for reasons I just dont agree with is lauded by many on here - yes he holds width, yes he helps control posession but that is literally about it other than buying fouls here and there) and he is learning the positonal play and defensive side of the game....difference is he takes risks and chances so he is going to give the ball away - that for me aint about his intelligence - its about his style of play - I guess theonly thing would be picking his time to take someone on or not - which for me he is doing as he is taking people on less and it must be for that reason.
The one major flaw holding Doku back is his defensive side. He's nearly as crap as Martin Petrov in that respect, BUT it's something that can be coached into him.

Aside from that, he's a brilliant player for his age, & I reckon with concerted defensive coaching (eg: defending from the front & tracking players when being attacked), he'll become a key player for City for seasons to come.

With Doku, Savvy, Bobb & now Moose, we're building something special in attack. The player who just doesn't fit in there is Grealish. If Pep can't find a central berth for him when we're this desperate, it doesn't look good for Jack in the short-term, never mind the long-term.
 
The one major flaw holding Doku back is his defensive side. He's nearly as crap as Martin Petrov in that respect, BUT it's something that can be coached into him.

Aside from that, he's a brilliant player for his age, & I reckon with concerted defensive coaching (eg: defending from the front & tracking players when being attacked), he'll become a key player for City for seasons to come.

With Doku, Savvy, Bobb & now Moose, we're building something special in attack. The player who just doesn't fit in there is Grealish. If Pep can't find a central berth for him when we're this desperate, it doesn't look good for Jack in the short-term, never mind the long-term.
Agreed - when closing down he doesnt make his runs at the right angle to cut off the obvious outball(s). He also as you say doesnt track his runner but Im seeeing him try to do this as opposed to not doing it at all when he first arrived.
 
Agreed - when closing down he doesnt make his runs at the right angle to cut off the obvious outball(s). He also as you say doesnt track his runner but Im seeeing him try to do this as opposed to not doing it at all when he first arrived.
In his last few appearances, he's definitely trying harder to defend, but he still has a way to go. If he could defend the left side as well as Grealish, Jack would be done at City.

Right now, it seems Jack is only being used to shore up the defensive left side, to help see games out. That's not what we bought him for, hence the question marks over his long-term future with City.
 
The one major flaw holding Doku back is his defensive side. He's nearly as crap as Martin Petrov in that respect, BUT it's something that can be coached into him.

Aside from that, he's a brilliant player for his age, & I reckon with concerted defensive coaching (eg: defending from the front & tracking players when being attacked), he'll become a key player for City for seasons to come.

With Doku, Savvy, Bobb & now Moose, we're building something special in attack. The player who just doesn't fit in there is Grealish. If Pep can't find a central berth for him when we're this desperate, it doesn't look good for Jack in the short-term, never mind the long-term.
He's just never on the pitch to apply it. If he's never gonna be available he can go imo.
 
He's just never on the pitch to apply it. If he's never gonna be available he can go imo.
I'm seriously gutted about Jack. I stuck up for him when many others were pissed we'd spent £100m to get him. He repaid my faith during our treble season & then promptly threw it back in my face with his end of treble season antics.

As I feared then, Grealish has never been consistently close to being the same player for us again. He doesn't fit in with the profile of wide player we have, so if Pep can't utilise him centrally, of what use is he to us?

It's sad, but totally self inflicted by Jack imo.
 
I'm seriously gutted about Jack. I stuck up for him when many others were pissed we'd spent £100m to get him. He repaid my faith during our treble season & then promptly threw it back in my face with his end of treble season antics.

As I feared then, Grealish has never been consistently close to being the same player for us again. He doesn't fit in with the profile of wide player we have, so if Pep can't utilise him centrally, of what use is he to us?

It's sad, but totally self inflicted by Jack imo.
i meant Doku's fitness, but Jack too.
 
"it has been reported that Cambiaso has expressed no desire whatsoever to leave Juventus."

Bullshit, he clearly wants the move or we would have moved on, this is very much game on.

You just have to see who posted it
 
i meant Doku's fitness, but Jack too.
I became aware of Doku's injury history when we were in for him, but we've bought several players with dubious injury records & managed to overcome them.

I recall Doku speaking about this when he first arrived, & also voices at City saying they believed it was something caused by his explosive nature that his body would adapt to.
 
Last edited:
I became aware of Doku's injury history when we were in for him, but we've bought several players with dubious injury records & managed to overcome them.

I recall Doku speaking about this when he first arrived, & also voices at City saying they believed it was something caused by his explosive nature that he'd his body would adapt to.
I thought he might but doesnt look like it. Glass Cannon for relegation fodder right now, the kids can do that.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top