Exactly this. The debate at the time was all about (rightly) protecting those that had been putting the hard yards in when we were shit but you've now got younger fans doing the same now without any real credit for it.
When do their hard yards outweigh the hard yards an old boy put in 10 years ago but now picks and chooses??
The evidence of a third of away tickets being "whored" was strong enough for a unanimous vote from CM at the time though to remove points but I'd like to know what that evidence was. Always had a level of anxiety that it was the clubs intention to put us on the first step to a ballot
I'm convinced that "points whoring" was always more anecdotal than factual, but it was undeniably a cyclical debate that usually resurfaced (along with the anti OSC posts) whenever the ticket criteria for the Old Trafford was announced
However as I posted earlier the new system has bedded-me-in quite nicely, and thanks to people lobbying against something that I wasn't convinced ever existed, I can now pick and choose,.and still qualify for Bournemouth Liverpool and the Swamp etc
For what it's worth I do believe that the current system is not fit for purpose and should be replaced by something far more relevant.
I'll be 61 in August and whilst I still travel to the vast majority of away games it's utterly ridiculous that loyalty points for attending a preseason friendly at Halifax in 2001 (when many City fans weren't even born) should still be on my account
As you say, the hardcore should still be
recognised and rewarded, but let's keep it to the last 4-5 seasons and have a rolling system for the other tickets.
Similarly, the current ticket situation for European Away games is farcical
Take out Bratislava and the other group games were all a bit "samey"
Regardless of points If you attended at least two from Lisbon, Juventus and PSG then you should be in the first window for next season
The second window should be open sale.