Man of the Match Summary 2024-25 Season

[Middedon]

Someone (sorry forget who) suggested this and I thought it would be interesting. I'll update the stats for the prior match once we get close to the next match.

Still working on the best way to do this, but updated through AVL game.


The Red bar- How many points the player has received based on on 3 points for 1st, 2 for 2nd, and 1 for 3rd.

The Blue bar - How many times a player has made the top 3.

There have been a lot of recent games where there is only 1 or 2 votes between 3 and 4th place...and in one instance, 3 players split the vote for third place (which was all less than 1%).

Once the season is over, I may try and split this between regular season and competition games, as I think that would be interesting.

 

[Middedon]

Formatting there is not ideal. In the meantime, here is a screen shot.

 

[Middedon]

If anyone has formatting suggestions, please share. I was not terribly successful making this easily viewable.

 

[MadchesterCity]

Someone (sorry forget who) suggested this and I thought it would be interesting. I'll update the stats for the prior match once we get close to the next match. Hopefully this is viewable, if not I'll play around with it.

Date	Opponent		#1	%	#2	%	#3	%
10/20	Wolves	W 2-1	Gvardiol	50	Ederson	25	Stones	12
10/5

 

[Middedon]

I was going to give Wolves another day since people are still responding!

 

[Eccles Blue]

My formatting goes

Every match John Stones number one. Does that help?







Ok I’ll get my coat and scarf. ;-)

 

[Gazza]

If anyone has formatting suggestions, please share. I was not terribly successful making this easily viewable.

From a personal point of view, I'd have the latest fixture at the bottom plus I'd have the date in a DD/MM/YYYY format if only for presentation purposes.
Overall though it's a great idea and I particularly like the second and third MOTM that you've included as some players may seldom get a MOTM but are always up there (Gareth Barry springs to mind).

Maybe you can give points.. say 6 for first, 3 for second and 1 for third so that they can be added up at the end of the season to see it agrees with the chosen POTS.

 

[youngbob]

Love this idea.

 

[foggy1974]

Would it be easier just to have the players name how many they have won & the teams in bracket & then a similar one for runners up underneath

I.e.

Haaland 2
[Bre(A) WHU (H)]

 

[supercity88]

From a personal point of view, I'd have the latest fixture at the bottom plus I'd have the date in a DD/MM/YYYY format if only for presentation purposes.
Overall though it's a great idea and I particularly like the second and third MOTM that you've included as some players may seldom get a MOTM but are always up there (Gareth Barry springs to mind).

Maybe you can give points.. say 6 for first, 3 for second and 1 for third so that they can be added up at the end of the season to see it agrees with the chosen POTS.

Would agree with this. Would also be good to have some sort of points ranking and an overall table just to see who is getting nominated/winning the most. 5pts for MOTM, 3pts for 2nd, 1pt for 3rd or something like that. An interesting context to individual performances rather than just goals and assists!

 

[Gaz (FMwkdsoul)]

Someone (sorry forget who) suggested this and I thought it would be interesting. I'll update the stats for the prior match once we get close to the next match. Hopefully this is viewable, if not I'll play around with it.

Date	Opponent		#1	%	#2	%	#3	%
10/20	Wolves	W 2-1
10/5	Fulham	W 3-2	Kova	39.60	Ederson	38.10	Gvardiol	11.50
10/1	Slovan Bratislava (CL)	W 4-0	Doku	38.80	Lewis	32.00	Foden	16.20
9/28	Newcastle	D 1-1	Gvardiol	53.40	Grealish	33.80	Akanji	6.10
9/24	Watford (EFL)	W 2-1	Grealish	34.90	Lewis	34.60	Nunes	12.50
9/22	Arsenal	D 2-2	Stones	20.40	Savinho	23.60	Gvardiol	17.70
9/18	Inter Milan (CL)	D 0-0	Gvardiol	36.60	Grealish	20.10	Lewis	13.10
9/14	Brentford	W 2-1	Haaland	73.20	Ederson	7.30	de Bruyne	5.80
8/31	West Ham	W 3-1	Haaland	78.00	Kova	6.80	Lewis	5.80
8/24	Ipswich	W 4-1	Lewis	46.70	Haaland	40.70	de Bruyne	4.70
8/18	Chelsea	W 2-0	Kova	57.50	Lewis	27.70	Doku	4.60
8/10	Man Utd (Comm Shield)	W 1-1	Bobb	50.90	Lewis	18.50	Kova	10.70

oh Ta, was me just out of interest didnt think anyone kept track.

 

[Middedon]

From a personal point of view, I'd have the latest fixture at the bottom plus I'd have the date in a DD/MM/YYYY format if only for presentation purposes.
Overall though it's a great idea and I particularly like the second and third MOTM that you've included as some players may seldom get a MOTM but are always up there (Gareth Barry springs to mind).

Maybe you can give points.. say 6 for first, 3 for second and 1 for third so that they can be added up at the end of the season to see it agrees with the chosen POTS.

I also thought it might be interesting to overlay the goal scorers. Perhaps highlight them. Interesting to see how that plays into things. I will work on it this weekend.

I like your idea of the total and thought about doing something like that.

 

[Gazza]

I also thought it might be interesting to overlay the goal scorers. Perhaps highlight them. Interesting to see how that plays into things. I will work on it this weekend.

I like your idea of the total and thought about doing something like that.

Yeah you could add the goal scorers but that information is easily accessible elsewhere - try not to make it so burdensome that it ends up becoming a chore to complete.

 

[Middedon]

Updated the original post through 10/23. Tried a points system for each place. Still a work in progress!

 

[Vienna_70]

@Middedon I think that is brilliant.

I started compiling MotM statistics a couple of seasons ago, but I never carried it through.

Keep it up; I love it.

 

[burning blue soul]

Someone (sorry forget who) suggested this and I thought it would be interesting. I'll update the stats for the prior match once we get close to the next match.

Still working on the best way to do this, but updated through 10/23 game.
View attachment 136305

The chart below is based on 3 points for 1st, 2 for 2nd, and 1 for 3rd.

View attachment 136304

What's going on with Phil and Bernie? Are they under-performing, or are we under-appreciating?

 

[Middedon]

The initial post has been updated through the AVL game.

 

[BlueNomad]

Confirms my feelings that Gvardiol has been POTY for City this season.

 

[Bluefen]

If anyone has formatting suggestions, please share. I was not terribly successful making this easily viewable.

Check out race charts in flourish that would be a great way to show you players accruing point
over a season

If you can post a spreadsheet of which players scored points for each of the matches and the associated dates then i could pull this together pretty quickly and publish a link

 

[Lost in space]

Richard Dunne has been my MOTM for every game this season