Best City 11 since the takeover

[citymad]

Hart
Walker
Kompany
Stones
Gvardiol
Fernandinho
Rodri
Toure
David Silva
De Bruyne
Aguero

Great team that but a bit narrow. Missing a winger possibly Sane or Mahrez. Oh and I'd have Ederson. Joe wasnt great with his passes.

 

[citymad]

1.) Eddie
2.) Walker
3.) Gvardiol
4.) Vinny
5.) Dias
6.) Rodders
7.) Yaya
8.) Kev
10.) Merlin
11.) Sergio
9.) Haaland

This Team decimates all opposition

Can't argue with that.

 

[bennyboy]

Great team that but a bit narrow. Missing a winger possibly Sane or Mahrez. Oh and I'd have Ederson. Joe wasnt great with his passes.

Apart from passing Joe was a better keeper in every other department
I would also have Mahrez or Sterling before Sane.
Left back was a toss up between Kolarov and Gvardiol

 

[supercity88]

Best, but not sure how the fuck they would be positioned:

Eddie, Walker, Stones, Dias, Ake, Rodders, Yaya, De Bruyne, Silva, Tevez, Aguero.

Favourite:

Eddie, Walker, Stones, Kompany, Ake, Rodders, Ferny, Sane, Silva, Bernie, Aguero.

 

[flook]

Josep Guardiola

Ederson ..... or Hart

Walker ....... or Zabba
Kompany
Stones ...... or Gvardiol
Ake ........ or Kolarov

Rodri ...... or Fernandinho
De Bruyne
D. Silva ..... or B Silva

Mahrez ..... or Sterling
Aguero ..... or Haaland
Sane ...... or Tevez

ffs this is impossible

 

[flook]

Apart from passing Joe was a better keeper in every other department
I would also have Mahrez or Sterling before Sane.
Left back was a toss up between Kolarov and Gvardiol

So much depends on manager, with Pep it has to be Ederson, with Mancini or Pellegrini it's gonna be Joe Hart.

I have to disagree about your winger choice, Sane had incredible ability, just didn't have the work ethic and/or mentality to make the most of it, but when he performed he was unplayable

 

[Craig]

Best, but not sure how the fuck they would be positioned:

Eddie, Walker, Stones, Dias, Ake, Rodders, Yaya, De Bruyne, Silva, Tevez, Aguero.

Favourite:

Eddie, Walker, Stones, Kompany, Ake, Rodders, Ferny, Sane, Silva, Bernie, Aguero.

Best players probably apart from Kompany. Prime Vinnie is first choice centre back by a distance. Even after months out he’d step back in and be our best defender. Get the argument for Stones if you want a footballer in there. All Dias strengths Kompany had but with more of everything.

 

[johnnytapia]

Serge. On his own.

 

[Craig]

Yeah, i tried to pick peak everyone. I see lots of Aguero and while i personally like him more, year 1 Erling is unmatched. Same with peak Joe Hart. Unreal.

My toughest choice was who to partner Kompany, peak Stones or peak Dias. I think both were better than peak Laporte. But i can see how opinions may differ. Peak Cancelo was easily best LB for me. And the 5 midfielder are unmatched in terms of talent and peak for me. The Statue Legends is how i see them.

Im shocked how few have Dihno on their list. It used to be cause for abuse here if you thought anyone was better than Dihno. :) Time and perspective have changed opinions it seems.

I think Haaland is unmatched for goals and probably will be for goals per game every season he plays. As an actual player though all round, with plenty of goals to go with their play i don’t think he ever gets close to Tevez or Aguero

 

[Gray]

Hart

Walker
Stones
Kompany
Kolarov

De Bruyne
Fernandinho
Yaya Toure
David Silva

Aguero
Tevez

That is some team, maybe Ederson in goal though?

 

[citytill1die84]

Ederson

Walker Kompany Stones Gvardiol

Rodri

D. Silva KDB

Sterling Aguero Sane

 

[Lavinda Past]

That is some team, maybe Ederson in goal though?

Nope.

 

[bobbyowenquiff]

Think I’d have peak Sterling in over Sane.

I’d have stones in over Dias

Not sure on Gvardiol at left back either. I don’t really rate him in that position, saying that not a great deal of competition,

Bernado gets in but not on this seasons form.

Clichy for left back

 

[supercity88]

Best players probably apart from Kompany. Prime Vinnie is first choice centre back by a distance. Even after months out he’d step back in and be our best defender. Get the argument for Stones if you want a footballer in there. All Dias strengths Kompany had but with more of everything.

Yeah should be in ahead of Dias.

 

[Mr Ed (The Stables)]

Peak Yaya has to be in surely, he was absolutely unplayable at times.

 

[Cheadle_hulmeBlue]

This side was unbelievable. I actually think it’s underrated and ina few years we’ll realise how special it was

 

[TonyM]

..............Ederson...........
Walker Kompany Stones....
......Rodri Fernandinho Yaya
............... Silva KDB............
.........Haaland Aguero........

I'd have it lob sided because we never had a WC LB. We had workd class Midfielders though.

Imagine the opposition having to mark Haaland and allowing Aguero space or marking him and having KDB at his best lurking.

No point in pace in the attack btw because we'd be playing against packed defenses. Walker's pace would be critic though.

 

[citymad]

..............Ederson...........
Walker Kompany Stones....
......Rodri Fernandinho Yaya
............... Silva KDB............
.........Haaland Aguero........

I'd have it lob sided because we never had a WC LB. We had workd class Midfielders though.

Imagine the opposition having to mark Haaland and allowing Aguero space or marking him and having KDB at his best lurking.

No point in pace in the attack btw because we'd be playing against packed defenses. Walker's pace would be critic though.

Like Fort Knox that midfield. Not sure we'd need a goalkeeper. Could do with prime Bernie in there buzzing around linking play. Aguero and Haaland up front...just wow!