It’s all situational.If he’s worth £80m what is Hakami worth? Madness this and lots of folk on here thinking it’s a cheap deal….
Dumfries isn't fit to lace hakimi's boots, he's eye catching going forward but a liability defensively.I’m not sure about that at present. For me Dumfries is better, albeit older. Could sign him for a few years and wait for Rico and other academy products to come through. Paying £80m for Liveramento isn’t a great use of cash imo.
£40m according to Graeme Bailey.
They paid that so they ain’t selling him for that
Dumfries isn't fit to lace hakimi's boots, he's eye catching going forward but a liability defensively
Where did I say he was better than Hakami? I was saying he was a cheaper option.Dumfries isn't fit to lace hakimi's boots, he's eye catching going forward but a liability defensively.
That has got to be 40 and Jack which has been touted as well.£40m according to Graeme Bailey.
No mention of Jack on the tweet.That has got to be 40 and Jack which has been touted as well.
They paid 32+8 for him.
If you had to ask inter fans. He’s actually not as good as you think he is. Those few games he had this season notable the Barca matches were just that. The few times where he looked world class. He’s not silky or technically gifted but he’s still good. Then again it wouldn’t help the HG issue we haveI’m not sure about that at present. For me Dumfries is better, albeit older. Could sign him for a few years and wait for Rico and other academy products to come through. Paying £80m for Liveramento isn’t a great use of cash imo.
My point is that he would be a lot cheaper and is a better player at this point….Ok let’s pay £80m for Tino and then start crying on the next thread about ticket prices..If you had to ask inter fans. He’s actually not as good as you think he is. Those few games he had this season notable the Barca matches were just that. The few times where he looked world class. He’s not silky or technically gifted but he’s still good. Then again it wouldn’t help the HG issue we have
I've genuinely never seen him proven right about anything£40m according to Graeme Bailey.
Are we after an attacking right full back though?Vanderson 23 from Monaco.
Attacking fullback. Will probably cost more than the €11m Monaco paid Gremio.
Not the finished article but would be a reasonable price and a decent age to develop.
Who knows what pep wants to do…Are we after an attacking right full back though?
Livramento is as close as a HG clone you are going to get for Walker currently, quick and can run all day.
I would think that Ait-Nouri is going to be the one bombing forward and the right back will be looking to help shut the counter attacks down.
I don’t mean in this tweet but 40 and Jack has been touted in another tweet…No mention of Jack on the tweet.
Vanderson shows buying from the Brazilian league isn’t a bad thing.Vanderson 23 from Monaco.
Attacking fullback. Will probably cost more than the €11m Monaco paid Gremio.
Not the finished article but would be a reasonable price and a decent age to develop.
Don’t think money is the issue, the issue is whether Newcastle will sell at a price we are prepared to pay. What that is I haven’t the faintest idea, could be £50 mill could be £70 mill. Only the club know and if we can’t get him we will move on or stick with what we have if we can’t get a better homegrown. Don’t think sales will make the decision, at least not financially only squad numbers wise.Who knows what pep wants to do…
Wirtz didn’t happen so we went to cherki.
Tino might not happen so we may have no choice to go down the list.
I think this move will depend on how much money we can bring in this summer with sales.
Stacked on the wings but short at fullback.
£80m seems a lot for a player who was bought for £32 couple seasons ago.
Play khusanov better defender if that's the case and faster.Are we after an attacking right full back though?
Livramento is as close as a HG clone you are going to get for Walker currently, quick and can run all day.
I would think that Ait-Nouri is going to be the one bombing forward and the right back will be looking to help shut the counter attacks down.
I think the point of the comparisons are obvious..I’m not sure what the point of this comparison is - or the choice of comparators you’ve made - beyond the fact they’re all right backs, obviously.
You’re comparing Livramento with Hakimi, who is the best right back in the world at the moment.
He would command a colossal fee this summer - way beyond the figures being talked about for Livramento - even if PSG could be convinced to sell him, which they won’t.
I would expect any RB playing the game to look less talented next to him right now.
He’s 26, and has just reached his peak.
Aina is 28, and has had a great spell at Forest. That said, he’ll be 29 in a couple of months, and is likely to start losing some of his capacity over the next few years.
He’d be a stop gap who could do a job for a couple of seasons, nothing more.
Nunes is an interesting comparison, but he isn’t a right back - which is why we’re in the market for a replacement.
These players are either at their peak already, or in the case of Aina probably looking at the start of their decline.
Livramento is 22, and hasn’t even made an appearance for his National team yet.
He’s all potential, and we’d be buying him not because of what he is now - but what we believe he can be with the right training.
He’s not Hakimi yet, and he may never be.
But he’s the only one in your list who I wouldn’t expect to see performing at their best just yet.
So it’s a bit of a pointless comparison.
Compare him to other 22 year old homegrown RBs (which are the factors that make him uniquely attractive to us), and I’d imagine he’ll be show up best out there.
And that’s the evaluation we’re making here - not whether he’s as good as Hakimi right now.
Is he homegrown?Freiburg right back Killian Sildillia linked today
Cambiasso was a left back link. People just hypothesized he could play on either side.Well the only other real link was Cambiaso in January and id rather have Livramento based of ability alone.