Sorry everyone, work again has been crazy - luckily I start a new job next week though! Fed up of having to work nonsense hours on crap stuff! :)
Funnily enough, we were talking about The Lemonheads at a friends party a few weeks ago and we couldn't quite remember if they were good but the Mrs Robinson cover was awful, or whether the album was duff and the cover quite good. We all agreed that the cover was 'ok' but not a patch on the original and when we put the album on we ended up skipping a lot of the tracks. When I was learning to play the guitar, Paul Simon was a 'god' to me - what a guitarist and songwriter he is so I guess anyone who covered one of his songs had to do it well and differently. To be fair, The Lemonheads did but it just highlighted to me how good the original was.
Rightly, or wrongly, as someone who loved the grunge scene The Lemonheads were seen as 'fake'. They didn't have the authenticity of a Nirvana, Pearl Jam etc. The lead singer seems to want to be a pretty Kurt Cobain (from memory) and it just didn't feel right. So I guess this album was always going to land on tough ears. The Mrs Robinson cover probably made them even less authentic and maybe we saw them as a grunge band for people who didn't like grunge.
I had a listen to the album and to be honest, it's ok. It's not bad by any measure but I still can't help but compare it to the great grunge albums by Nirvana (Nevermind, Blech, In Utero, Incesticide), Pearl Jam (10, Vs), Stone Temple Pilots (Purple), Soundgarden etc etc and it's just not quite as good. However, it's a perfectly listenable album once I shrug off that 'grunge snootiness' I once had! :) the tracks still feel like ones for a party and background music but overall it was better than I remember.
7/10