It's A Shame About Ray - The Lemonheads
I knew I waited too long to say something on this as GornikDaze got to my observation line first...
I loved the title track Rudderless it had lyrics that spoke to me… sorry, what? Oh so that’s not the title track, it was the whole point of the album - rudderless as drifting around going nowhere. Genius!
Weak thin vocals and guitar, monotonous drumming.
I thought the same thing when listening to that song as it approached its ending:
'S like a ship without a rudder (repeat, repeat, repeat...)
It wasn't
all like this, and there were some songs I liked, but more on that later. I think the biggest hurdle for me was wondering why Spotify had these tunes playing at a 1.5x speed, then I realized this was all by design. It's A Shame About that, too.
Lots of that was due to the "pop punk" genre they fit into, and that's a weak spot for me in usual enjoyment. When this came out in '92, I only remember the super fast speed version of "Mrs. Robinson" that I heard, but really didn't inspire me to go listen to more, much less that it wasn't on this album originally anyways.
However, they also fit into the "jangle pop" genre, and there are enough songs here that I liked that fit more into this space. "It's A Shame About Ray", "My Drug Buddy", "The Turnpike Down" and "Hannah & Gabi" being the standouts to me where there actually was a melody, and I felt I could actually breathe during the song, even if the lyrics in MDB didn't speak to me at all. The more punky songs all sounded the same to me as if they were just playing the same song with different lyrics. "Bit Part" was one where the backup vocals from Juliana Hatfield were a nice touch, perhaps more of that would have helped on some of the other tracks?
Back in 1992, there was some albums from bands in that jangle pop category that I rate very high, specifically R.E.M.'s matured masterpiece of
Automatic For The People. And why
haven't I nominated this? Well, because as Coatigan correctly notes, I too am looking for something less obvious and hopefully new for most of you, not offering something I (and you should) love because it is hit-you-over-the-head-obvious and most probably know it well.
In that same jangle pop genre, I was still enjoying Toad's 1991
fear, which I feel is more my speed than this one. Another from this same year as my guilty pleasure that I did have was Gin Blossoms'
New Miserable Experience. I never was a fan of the overplayed "Hey Jealousy" (typically a skip), but my go to was "Found Out About You", which alone exceeds anything I heard or enjoyed here. And I'll also note that It's A Shame About Doug from that band, but that's a story for another day.
The vocals here reminded me also of The Smithereens, a band which I do like a lot, and relistened to a bit along with this album this week. They're less on the punky side, and more of a straightforward alt-rock band. Their vocals are distinct, just like the Lemonheads are. I just found musically with those unique vocals, they go down better, though I felt both bands really benefited from some great bass playing.
Not sure where that leaves me on this. I don't have this feeling that I missed out back then, but I'm not going to slag something off the very tree I enjoy either. I'm at a
6/10 overall, and it was good to sample some other fruit, even if it didn't turn out to be my favourite of what I mostly enjoy. I can also see where LGWIO is going to enjoy this more than me, and glad to get some takeaways on songs here I appreciated too, even if it wasn't more than originally hoped for.