The Album Review Club - *** Christmas Break Playlist (next album 7/1/26) ***

Steely Dan.Reelin' in the Years a brilliant song apart from that I have struggled ever since with them to the point of giving up on them.
Nothing in this for me.A real struggle listening to this for 3 times
Bored out of my mind.A generous 3.
 
I can think of 10 reasons why I didn't listen to the album when it was released in 1977:

- New Boots & Panties / Ian Dury
- Animals - Pink Floyd
- My Aim Is True - Elvis Costello
- Marquee Moon - Televison
- Never Mind The Bollocks - Sex Pistols
- A Farewell To Kings - Rush
- The Clash - The Clash
- News Of The World - Queen
- Going For The One - Yes
- Trans-Europe Express - Kraftwerk

An eclectic mix of distractions. If I had a radar at 14, Aja by Steely Dan definitely sailed right under it! Over the years I have dipped in and out of Steely Dan, the only album I have really listened to has been Can't Buy A Thrill, Reelin In The Years being a standout favourite.

It has been a pleasure to listen to this in its entirety. I have clocked up more than the usual three listens and I keep coming back for more. It's great driving music and its fantastic background to guitar noodling! No surprise there when you have the talent that is Larry Carlton as inspiration! Stand out track for me is Home At Last, although some google research would suggest the main solo is Walter Becker rather than LC - happy for you to correct me Fog if that isn't correct.

I wholeheartedly agree with Mr Belfry that is beautifully precise in its engineering. It is a very immersive experience. Add nearly 50 years to my 14 year old self and I am actually very happy to have finally discovered this album. Despite what some may think, my musical taste has matured and widened. The jazz funk overtones and influences are a joy to behold, to the extent that I have reignited my Brand X and UK back catalogues which has been extremely enjoyable.

Excellent pick Fog - solid 9/10!


Edit: Listening to it while writing this... how good is the guitar on Josie?!!!

PS - Hope retirement is treating you well Fog. Did you ever get anywhere with your Bass guitar quest? As a really awful guitar player that has time to practice in retirement, follow the dream, you won't regret it! If you do regret it, I'll happily take a second hand bass off your hands for a fraction of what its's worth ;)
 
I'm going to respectfully sit this one out. And come back and revisit it when I can better take it in. This is not the week for it, and its lazy smooth vibe is at odds with the pre chirstmas rush and panic. It maybe should be a relaxing antidote, but it is not. If anything it is a bit of a frustrating sideswipe, that even at a mere 39 minutes, feels like it is dragging and taking up precious time.

Observations on two listens. Love the bass. Some good keyboard work. Good production, maybe too professional. Not a fan of the vocalising, I get the soulfulness it is going for, but I get more Bee Gees than soul. Nice bits of jazz sprinkles, could do with more of it. Although of a genre of a time, sounds incredibly timeless, and could well enough be by a band of today (boldly utilising older styles) as one of the 70s.

I'll leave it there, till I can give it more time, in a better mindset.
 
I can think of 10 reasons why I didn't listen to the album when it was released in 1977:

- New Boots & Panties / Ian Dury
- Animals - Pink Floyd
- My Aim Is True - Elvis Costello
- Marquee Moon - Televison
- Never Mind The Bollocks - Sex Pistols
- A Farewell To Kings - Rush
- The Clash - The Clash
- News Of The World - Queen
- Going For The One - Yes
- Trans-Europe Express - Kraftwerk

An eclectic mix of distractions. If I had a radar at 14, Aja by Steely Dan definitely sailed right under it! Over the years I have dipped in and out of Steely Dan, the only album I have really listened to has been Can't Buy A Thrill, Reelin In The Years being a standout favourite.

It has been a pleasure to listen to this in its entirety. I have clocked up more than the usual three listens and I keep coming back for more. It's great driving music and its fantastic background to guitar noodling! No surprise there when you have the talent that is Larry Carlton as inspiration! Stand out track for me is Home At Last, although some google research would suggest the main solo is Walter Becker rather than LC - happy for you to correct me Fog if that isn't correct.

I wholeheartedly agree with Mr Belfry that is beautifully precise in its engineering. It is a very immersive experience. Add nearly 50 years to my 14 year old self and I am actually very happy to have finally discovered this album. Despite what some may think, my musical taste has matured and widened. The jazz funk overtones and influences are a joy to behold, to the extent that I have reignited my Brand X and UK back catalogues which has been extremely enjoyable.

Excellent pick Fog - solid 9/10!


Edit: Listening to it while writing this... how good is the guitar on Josie?!!!

PS - Hope retirement is treating you well Fog. Did you ever get anywhere with your Bass guitar quest? As a really awful guitar player that has time to practice in retirement, follow the dream, you won't regret it! If you do regret it, I'll happily take a second hand bass off your hands for a fraction of what its's worth ;)
Ha! 2026 is my “new things” year. The back half of 2025 has been my “house in order” year. With free time I focused on marriage, learning to cook, golf and reading. I am hoping to get a bass for Xmas but am not optimistic. If I don’t, the music store is a January visit!
 
I love this album. The first thing that grabbed me is just how perfect the production is - it's insanely good. Every sound, note, timbre - whatever has been considered and balanced.

The tracks on it are superb and even if it just had Peg on, it would be worth listening to. Every track is silky smooth and manages to blend jazz and rock into something so melodic. It's so smooth I can't sometimes hear the jazz! Every instrument is funky, jazzy and you can just pick out anyone on these songs and hear a craftsman at work.

It's got to be said but these albums really stand out for their musicianship never mind anything else. You simply would not get this album made today.

10/10
 
Aja – Steely Dan

I can’t say that I’ve heard many Steely Dan tracks in my life. “Rikki Don’t Lose That Number” and “Reelin’ In The Years” are familiar and are solid pop songs. Funnily enough, since hearing it on a soundtrack somewhere, in the last few years, I’ve played “Do It Again” a lot. Now there is a fine song with a hell of a groove and a stupendous instrumental break. Anyway, it was good to listen to a complete Steely Dan album.

Opener “Black Cow” seems to be going for a smooth soul direction (George Benson, Luther Vandross etc.), which is a genre I particularly despise. It does have a few instrumental touches but it’s not enough. Fortunately it’s followed by six tracks of much higher quality.

The title track is better. This is a good listen where you feel like you can get lost in the jazzy instrumental passages. That drumming in the break and once again in the outro sounds like it was played by a jazz master. “Peg” is quite catchy and “I Got The News” features some nice guitar and piano. “Josie” carries a funkiness throughout, and the guitar solos dovetail nicely with the overall vibe of the song.

I enjoyed my listens to Aja. It’s got a laid-back and listenable vibe that I would imagine works well in many situations (working, driving, leaning back in the chair with a rum). There’s a quirky Supertrampness to their sound, and whilst I agree that Steely Dan were certainly one of a kind, I don’t hear the greatness on this album that some do. There are some good instrumental passages, but the general soul-lite sound does become a bit tiresome in between the instrumental bits. It’s better than last week’s ELO offering but the same comment I made then applies – it was released at a time where there were plenty of albums on offer that were much better. Still, it's a cool and easy 7/10.
 
Steely Dan - Aja

Drink your big black cow and get out of here

I was always curious to visit the London Tate Modern as i often commuted past this on my way to work, eventually i thought i'll give it a go, hell, it's free .. Was interesting to see the variety of Art, Lots of abstract, conceptual and some weird funky modern pieces - some of the rooms felt empty and solemn, lacking a buzz, I tried desperately to see the enjoyment in some of the paintings whilst also admiring the work and complexity that went into the fine strokes - - A couple next to me were discussing various brushwork & techniques from a Artist i had never heard of, they liked the 'Impasto and Palette knife used '', I loved their enthusiasm - I took a longer look at the picture but just couldn't see the connection - maybe i just don't enjoy art. Good pick!

5/10
 
I first heard Steely Dan when my mate played me the soundtrack to the film FM (good album, crap film!). Because I loved that song, I went to my local record shop and bought their latest album, which just happened to be Aja. I was in for a bit of a surprise, because although FM was recorded at the same time as Aja, they don't have a lot in common. It took me a while to 'get' it!

What makes this album so great, I think, is because it's not like anything else. Steely Dan were already an outlier compared to most other '70s rock bands, but Aja takes jazz-rock fusion to another level.
It feels like Walter Becker and Donald Fagan made this album purely for their own gratification, embracing the laidback, but still seedy, LA vibe completely.

Great song follows great song and, while I admire the stellar writing, musicianship and production, it's the fact that it all comes together in such a joyful and uplifting fashion that makes it an easy 10 for me!
 
- New Boots & Panties / Ian Dury
- Animals - Pink Floyd
- My Aim Is True - Elvis Costello
- Marquee Moon - Televison
- Never Mind The Bollocks - Sex Pistols
- A Farewell To Kings - Rush
- The Clash - The Clash
- News Of The World - Queen
- Going For The One - Yes
- Trans-Europe Express - Kraftwerk
On this list I see:

2 9/10
2 8/10
2 7/10
2 6/10
1 5/10 (a record beloved by many that I've never really understood)
1 record I don't know

So pretty good stuff there!
 
I decided to spend the week taking a break from cramming for the Album of the Year list to instead cram some Steely Dan, having realised that the only album of theirs I really listen to is Can't Buy a Thrill. I hadn't realised that was their debut album and what a great debut it is.

My brother used to have a few of their other albums but I don't recall taking much notice of them although I did have a couple of singles in Ricki Don't Lose That Number and Haitian Divorce, which I'd always considered a bit of a novelty record but loved it all the same. B side was Sign in Stranger and those three tracks often find their way on to the odd playlist along with tracks from Thrill.

As an aside, it always intrigues me on Can't Buy a Thrill that the format seemed to be top launch into a chorus after one verse of songs, my usual reckoning would be a couple of verses first. Maybe I'm wrong on that.

Anyway, it's been a fairly fruitful week. I can add Pretzel Logic and Royal Scam to can't Buy a Thrill as albums I'll definitely return to. Less so Katy Lied and Countdown to Ecstasy which I found a bit lacking. Interestingly when I look at the chronological order of releases it's good, meh, good, meh, good, Aja...

So would Aja buck the trend. I mentioned early doors that I had previously found it dull and to be fair Foggy agreed with me. But rather like being sat opposite the work dullard at the Christmas meal I did have to engage with it this week. Was my further exploration of Steely Dan albums a sort of excuse to not listen to this or being such a fan of Can't Buy a Thrill an attempt to find some conciliatory words? Fuck knows, I'm not my own psychologist.

Anyway, to the point. I get what people say and think back to @mrbelfry review when he said this album "revealed itself to him". The best albums often do.

This album is ideal for some of the moods and fancies I get. You could argue that in some respects nothing really happens. And being less tuned in to the production and musical mastery than others I can't gush over how perfect it is. But the nothing much that happens happens in a very effective way. I think. Like passing a pleasant evening with friends drinking wine and chatting, just chatting, not homing in on the big issues screwing the world and the potential life threatening illnesses hiding in the corners. In fact when you look back you'd be hard pressed to know what you did talk about. But it was a just right night...

There was a slightly discordant note, or rather a series of notes as the title track moved towards it's climax and frankly was a bit noisy. It reminded me at that point of the terrible incidental music you used to get in 80s movies. But overall, this is smooth and it's rather great now that I have properly let it work it's way in. So, that's four albums of Steely dan that I'll listen to and this, although very different vies with can't Buy a Thrill for the top spot. It's the sort of thing I can see me listening to as I cruise down the M6 to Wembley on a sunny day in May... but obviously will listen to it again before then. A solid 8
 
This is an album that was cool to like when it came out and if you didn't like it you knew nothing about music. Cool, cool, cool.

See how they fuse one genre with another-ish. Marvel at the depth of musical ability on show. Swoon as you suddenly realise that, like with Rush, great technical nous doesn't transform into a great listening experience.

Once again it's an album of 'look at us, we can write and perform better than you so sit back and listen as we grin at each other everytime we do a perfect note'.

I would guess that a lot of grinning went on during the recording. Apart from whoever was singing because that definitely wasn't 'nailed'.

That aside I prefer their earlier stuff if I'm honest. Less polished. More in line with the sort of 70's unpretentious rock that I like.

This is a vanity project. And doesn't appeal.

3/10
 
This is an album that was cool to like when it came out and if you didn't like it you knew nothing about music. Cool, cool, cool.

See how they fuse one genre with another-ish. Marvel at the depth of musical ability on show. Swoon as you suddenly realise that, like with Rush, great technical nous doesn't transform into a great listening experience.

Once again it's an album of 'look at us, we can write and perform better than you so sit back and listen as we grin at each other everytime we do a perfect note'.

I would guess that a lot of grinning went on during the recording. Apart from whoever was singing because that definitely wasn't 'nailed'.

That aside I prefer their earlier stuff if I'm honest. Less polished. More in line with the sort of 70's unpretentious rock that I like.

This is a vanity project. And doesn't appeal.

3/10
You and I are definitely not cool.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top