Ok I've asked Google Gemini Pro using Deepmind capabilities on who is better between Toure, Rice and also Rodri and this is what it has to say;
When you add Rodri to the mix, the conversation shifts from "Who is better?" to "What does your team actually need?"
If Yaya is the Unstoppable Force and Rice is the Endless Engine, then Rodri is the Tactical Architect. In the eyes of many modern coaches, Rodri has actually surpassed the other two in terms of "midfield perfection," mainly because he won the 2024 Ballon d'Or—a feat neither Yaya nor Rice (so far) has achieved.
Why Rodri is currently the "Gold Standard"
While Yaya was more exciting to watch and Rice is more athletic, Rodri is the player who makes a team unbeatable. * The "Invincible" Streak: In 2023 and 2024, Manchester City and Spain almost literally could not lose when Rodri was on the pitch. His presence alone provides a 10-15% boost to a team's win probability.
* The Brain: Unlike Yaya, who would sometimes drift out of defensive positions, or Rice, who relies on his legs to cover ground, Rodri rarely has to sprint. He is always in the right place, making him the world's best at stopping counter-attacks before they even start.
* Clutch Goals: He doesn't score 20 a season like Yaya, but he scores the most important ones (e.g., the only goal in the 2023 UCL Final).
The "Yaya vs. Rodri" Debate
This is the most frequent comparison in Manchester City history.
* Yaya was a better "individual" player. If you were down 1-0 in the 80th minute, you’d want Yaya to just grab the ball and run through everyone.
* Rodri is a better "system" player. If you want to dominate 70% possession and never face a shot on goal, you pick Rodri.
Where Rice Fits In
Rice is currently the middle ground between them. He has more defensive bite than Yaya and more ball-carrying ability than Rodri. However, even Yaya himself has weighed in on this, stating:
"Rodri is good, but Declan Rice is very good... but I’m going to go for Rodri [because he wins trophies]."
The Final Hierarchy (2026 Perspective)
* Rodri (The Peak Achiever): Winning the Ballon d'Or as a "defensive" midfielder in the era of Haaland and Mbappé puts him in a tier of his own. He is the most complete "6" the game has seen since Sergio Busquets.
* Yaya Touré (The Peak Performer): At his absolute best in 2013/14, Yaya was a better attacking force than most strikers. His "ceiling" for individual brilliance remains higher than Rodri's or Rice's.
* Declan Rice (The Modern Workhorse): Rice is the most consistent and durable. He is essentially a "9/10" every single game, whereas Yaya had "off" days. He is still chasing the major silverware that would move him into the top spot.
View attachment 182111