On their day it's probably:
Hart
Zabaleta, Kompany, Gabriel, Clichy
Yaya Toure, Rice, D. Silva
Saka, Aguero, Nasri
But even if you weren't on a City forum, you'd still struggle to convince neutrals that the current Arsenal crop are better than the City side of the early 2010s. Hart, Zabaleta, Kompany, Clichy, Yaya Toure, D. Silva, Aguero, and Nasri all won multiple Premier League titles and proved themselves, while this current Arsenal set are yet to win their first major trophy. Only Saka remains from your FA Cup team from 2020, and he didn't even get on the pitch that day.
There's lots of potential for the likes of Raya, Timber, Saliba, Zubimendi, Martinelli, Odegaard etc. to win a handful of titles and big cups over the next five years. The foundation is there. But people won't favourably compare you to any title-winning side from the past until you match their achievements (even if it's just the once). Rice, for example, is a supremely talented footballer, but we don't know if he can mentally carry a team to a title yet like Yaya did twice.