Bitter Dortmund

Blue Smarties

Well-Known Member
Joined
10 Aug 2008
Messages
27,297
They knew exactly what they were doing with this subtle dig... At least he didn't go to Bayern though, eh?


Gündogan moves to Manchester City

Bundesliga side Borussia Dortmund and Ilkay Gündogan will go their separate ways in future. The midfielder, who is currently suffering from a knee injury, will leave the eight-time German champions in the summer to join Manchester City, who finished fourth in the English Premier League last season, on 1 July 2016.

https://www.facebook.com/BVB/posts/1409188385759804:0
 
Hummels gone, Gundogan gone, Aubameyang linked with leaving.

Just another Bayern Munich feeder club with a chip on their shoulder.
 
no problem with it really. must be a nightmare as a dortmund fan, with all their fantastic support, to see their star players consistently cherrypicked.
 
no problem with it really. must be a nightmare as a dortmund fan, with all their fantastic support, to see their star players consistently cherrypicked.
Agreed. If we lost Merlin, Kun and ginger Kev, we'd be sore as well. Mind you, they don't call us the Bitter Berties for nothing!
 
Yeahhhh they were Europa league quaterfinalists while we were CL semi finalists and they lost to the club that finished 8th in the BPL.
 
Hummels gone, Gundogan gone, Aubameyang linked with leaving.

Just another Bayern Munich feeder club with a chip on their shoulder.

They aren't or weren't a top club. Just a club on the rise. You cannot expect a club to be able to hold all the top players if you aren't one of the clubs on top of the food chain and do not pay the biggest wages or are able to guarantee trophies. And Dortmund just started to be out of the debt again after they had a real great time around the 2000 but that did not go hand in hand with managerial greatness. They need to keep working the way they did the recent years.

It is not just Bayern Munich - Kagawa went to United, Sahin to Real Madrid, Gündogan now to you. The players that left to Bayern would have left to one of the bigger and better paying clubs anyways.

Have I missed the many "sorrys" people offered for the other clubs in Germany that are the "feeder clubs" for Dortmund?

Gladbach just lost Harvard Nordveit to West Ham, Xhaka to Arsenal - and that is probably not the last one they will loose this summer... . And it is not the first season it is like this. They lost Reus to Dortmund, Dante to Bayern, Neustädter to Schalke, Ter Steegen to Barcelona, Kruse to Wolfsburg...
 
They aren't or weren't a top club. Just a club on the rise. You cannot expect a club to be able to hold all the top players if you aren't one of the clubs on top of the food chain and do not pay the biggest wages or are able to guarantee trophies. And Dortmund just started to be out of the debt again after they had a real great time around the 2000 but that did not go hand in hand with managerial greatness. They need to keep working the way they did the recent years.

It is not just Bayern Munich - Kagawa went to United, Sahin to Real Madrid, Gündogan now to you. The players that left to Bayern would have left to one of the bigger and better paying clubs anyways.

Have I missed the many "sorrys" people offered for the other clubs in Germany that are the "feeder clubs" for Dortmund?

Gladbach just lost Harvard Nordveit to West Ham, Xhaka to Arsenal - and that is probably not the last one they will loose this summer... . And it is not the first season it is like this. They lost Reus to Dortmund, Dante to Bayern, Neustädter to Schalke, Ter Steegen to Barcelona, Kruse to Wolfsburg...
They must have been really gutted about Dante.
 
They must have been really gutted about Dante.

Dante has been the best defender in the league in 2011/12 and 2012/13. Not with the high line Pep is playing and not after the Confed Cup when he got a nomination for Brazil and recognised he is a Brazilian football artist...

But you probably understand why I wrote this - there is a lot who want to make a "big bad Bayern" story again. But it is just the way modern football runs. The best players want to go to the big clubs were they win the trophys, earn the best cash and get the highest recognition.

Bayern is not on the end of the food chain either right now and never really was. For Germany probably, yes, but the highest wages get paid elsewhere and the biggest attention worldwide you get if you play in the big clubs in the EPL or at Real or Barcelona.
 
Last edited:
Dante has been the best defender in the league in 2011/12 and 2012/13. Not with the high line Pep is playing and not after the Confed Cup when he got a nomination for Brazil and recognised he is a Brazilian football artist...
Subotic was a far better centre half both years. The best defender in both those years was Lahm, by a country mile, as he has been for the last 12 years.
 
must be soul destroying to be a Dortmund fan. Regularly so close to success and the top, but their management is selling off their core and everything good they managed to create.

Tuchel has one of the hardest jobs in football next season, if he succeeds then he has to be a candidate for us after Pep.
 
Subotic was a far better centre half both years. The best defender in both those years was Lahm, by a country mile, as he has been for the last 12 years.

Subotic - no. But I might be biased as I really do not like him.

Lahm as a right back - yes. For sure. No need to start any discussion about that.

Tuchel has a lot success working with a group of young players. I am not sure that he did not even favour loosing Hummels because they did not really seem to be best friends - and between captain and coach there should always be a good relationship.

But - Tuchel is a tactic nerd like Guardiola is. Both met in a restaurant in Munich during Tuchel's Sabbatical and they most have had a very interesting talk with each others taking all kind of cutlery, napkins, pepper and salt etc. to symbolize players during their imaginary football matchs on the table...

Guardiola seems to have a funny side, too - he seems to have the most fun when he can be like the players and not their coach - with Tuchel I do not know if he has humour at all.
 
Don't see any problem with that statement by Dortmund at all. It doesn't strike me as bitter at all.

They knew he wanted to go, he signed a contract to give them a transfer fee.
 
Subotic was a far better centre half both years. The best defender in both those years was Lahm, by a country mile, as he has been for the last 12 years.
I think that's subjective based on the situations of both sides. Dortmund were certainly on a high, certainly in 2011/12, and Subotic was playing with a higher class of player. Dante with 'Gladbach were a team just coming off the back of the relegation playoff against Bochum the year previous, so the feats that Dante and 'Gladbach achieved (Champions League qualification) could probably be classed as 'better'. Plus, Dante was playing with people like Neustadter, de Camargo and Bobadilla. Close call, mind. The regression of Subotic since has been alarming, that may be because of the development of Sokratis however.
 
must be soul destroying to be a Dortmund fan. Regularly so close to success and the top, but their management is selling off their core and everything good they managed to create.

Tuchel has one of the hardest jobs in football next season, if he succeeds then he has to be a candidate for us after Pep.

To be honest I think thats why they signed Tuchel, he has history with youth players, Dortmund have a lot of very good young players coming through. Ancelotti isn't a very good league manager, Dortmund could win the league next year. I agree though, it must be heartbreaking losing all your best/favourite players.


As for the comment, I could understand it from the fans but from the officials thats quite poor really. For that I hope Guendogan scores the winner against them in the Champions League.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top