66 | Jahmai Simpson-Pusey - 2024/25

Hes walking justification that they were right to be as patient with Foden as they were, and that you can't just throw a load of kids in and expect them to be world class.

Hes massively out of his depth at the moment, and there's nothing we can do due to injuries and lack of depth. Feel bad for him tbh.
 
Well it is not fair to compare him to Harwood-Bellis. Harwood-Bellis had been cast out long before this young lad came up with age group. Pep preferred Eric Garcia to Harwood Bellis at that time and Harwood Bellis had to find himself a place to play professional football. So...

THB is probably as good now as JSP will be in 4 years time. That’s the difference between them and if you put an 18 year old THB in our side he’d be just as exposed, he made plenty of big mistakes in the championship and Belgium because that’s what 18 year old CBs do.
 
Felt for him last night - it will feel like we have lost every game he has played.

The first goal he might have made a different choice - but they are coached not to hoof the ball, and often play to players who are surrounded by opposition - when it works it creates space as we will have an overload somewhere else. The problem was the aimless backpass by Gvardiol.

The second, I'm not sure he could ever have been in a position to cut out the cross, it was looping over everyone - Lewis and Silva (I think) should have been closer to the crosser and cutting out, Nunes should have tracked the extra man overloading Gvardiol and Emerson should not let the ball passed his front post - if Simpson-Pusey is at any fault it is not dropping back to the goal just in case all those things happened - it is where Ake is so good, he sniffs danger.

The third - he is a little bit too far back to create an offside trap, but the big problem is McAtee and Lewis have tracked back beyond him - and the late runner springs the trap.

There are parts in each of those goals he might have done better - but it is part of a collective failure by the whole defensive unit, and others should not have been letting him be caught in those situations. Hopefully one day he will have learnt from this time - but right now I hope we don't see much of him again for a while.
 
Very hard to judge him so far but he doesn't look ready to me. Looks comfortable with the ball at his feet but doesn't yet have that instinctive defending mindset to see things before they happen.

I find myself once again pointing to the opposition ( a pretty average side btw) who had defenders throwing themselves into blocks and cutting out passes - that is why several of our chances were deflected onto the woodwork or for an easy save - apart from Ruben who does that we seem to be a squad with defenders who are more comfortable in possession but ragged out of it.
 
I'm sorry but... just... what the fuck is Pusey doing here? He can clearly see two Feyenoord lads running towards Gvardiol, who is also off balance, but he decides to just head it to him anyway, and on the bounce? An absolutely terrible decision that completely changed the complexion of the game.

McAtee is right there - he even looks at him but still decides not to play it safely for some reason.

It's actually given me a bit of confidence going into the next few games that the Feyenoord comeback was started by a frankly suicidal individual error, made by someone who won't get near the Anfield pitch. Gvardiol was at fault for the second goal - hopefully Dias can start and give Gvardiol a much needed rest.

View attachment 139065

He made some mistakes. He's a kid and it happens. Ultimately you can still question why Gvardiol didn't hoof it clear himself instead of trying to play it back to Ederson/Akanji. What exactly were they going to do? If the pass from Gvardiol was perfectly weighted he'd still have to volley it or head it clear. It was, like a lot of our goals recently, a collection of poor decision making.
 
Shouldn't be anywhere near the first team squad. He clearly is nowhere near the standard required as of now. I'm not blaming him, it's just the way it is. I guess if it wasn't for all the injuries, he wouldn't be getting game time
 
I'm sorry but... just... what the fuck is Pusey doing here? He can clearly see two Feyenoord lads running towards Gvardiol, who is also off balance, but he decides to just head it to him anyway, and on the bounce? An absolutely terrible decision that completely changed the complexion of the game.

McAtee is right there - he even looks at him but still decides not to play it safely for some reason.

It's actually given me a bit of confidence going into the next few games that the Feyenoord comeback was started by a frankly suicidal individual error, made by someone who won't get near the Anfield pitch. Gvardiol was at fault for the second goal - hopefully Dias can start and give Gvardiol a much needed rest.

View attachment 139065
Injuries have the made situation where we have no choice but to throw him in.
 
I really fear for this lad mentally.
He's not been near a winning team and even appearing at 3-0 up he walks off the pitch, not as a winner again, unfortunately
 
TLDR

There's no defensive structure. Defending remains individual without a clear line or system. Players aren't talking to each other to play an offside trap or help each other out. Players aren't working hard enough to press the ball or to track back when we lose it. That leads to individuals playing the opposition onside, or allowing them to get the ball in the box, or making errors that lead to goals.

The long story.

I would really suggest people go and watch the "highlights" of the game before slagging this kid off.

There are so many issues with our defending. The first could have been avoided. It's a tricky ball in the air and he makes the wrong decision, so does Gvardiol. But it's 3-1 and you're still in the driving seat.

Look at our defending for their second goal. They have three players in the box, we have 6. There's no pressure on the ball so it's easy to get the ball in. There's no defensive line. If Gvardiol steps up their players are offside. There's an overlapping player out of shot, that Nunes hasn't picked up either. It's a shambles.

2nd goal 1.png

And here's the third goal. Lewis playing the runner on side. No confidence or leadership on keeping the defensive line and playing offside. No defensive structure or shape, everyone loaded up on the near side.

3rd goal 1.png

Feyenoord have four players bursting into space and Lewis is now the only player in a position to get back.

3rd goal 2.png

But now look at the next frame. Where the hell is the urgency to get back?

If you look at Bernardo from the 1st image to the 2nd he's barely moved.

Then you look at the final image below, and it shows that when he finally put his foot down he was too late. If a few of our players had have instantly put their foot down and tried to get into position we might have been able to deal with the situation.
3rd goal 4.png
 

Attachments

  • 3rd goal 3.png
    3rd goal 3.png
    777.8 KB · Views: 2

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.