Chippy_boy
Well-Known Member
Reading Corbyn's opening sentence in his Your Party letter, he tries the usual trick of trying to con everyone how rich we are, and what a travesty it is therefore that we have 4.5m children, because that's more emotive than adults - living in poverty.
Well let's debunk this for a moment. What do the following countries have in common?
Singapore
Luxembourg
Ireland
Macao SAR
Qatar
Norway
Brunei Darussalam
Guyana
United States
Denmark
Switzerland
Netherlands
Iceland
Austria
Hong Kong SAR
Sweden
Germany
Belgium
Finland
France
Canada
Australia
Japan
New Zealand
Italy
Israel
Spain
Any idea? They are ALL better off than we are. In raw GDP terms we may be 6th but that's because we are a relatively populous country. But when to look at GDP per capita, we are 18th. Worse, goods and services are in the UK more expensive than elsewhere. So when you consider what the average person in the UK can actually afford, we are 28th. 28th not 6th.
(And we don't have 4.5m children living in poverty. Poverty is NOT earning less than a 60% a median. Or else someone on £1m a year in Monaco is living in poverty. And the numbers living in poverty DECREASE if median earnings decline... Which is plainly nonsense. The numbers in actual real poverty, like shortage of food or clothing, is between 1m and 2m. Still way too many but not as sensational an argument as claiming it's 4.5m)
Well let's debunk this for a moment. What do the following countries have in common?
Singapore
Luxembourg
Ireland
Macao SAR
Qatar
Norway
Brunei Darussalam
Guyana
United States
Denmark
Switzerland
Netherlands
Iceland
Austria
Hong Kong SAR
Sweden
Germany
Belgium
Finland
France
Canada
Australia
Japan
New Zealand
Italy
Israel
Spain
Any idea? They are ALL better off than we are. In raw GDP terms we may be 6th but that's because we are a relatively populous country. But when to look at GDP per capita, we are 18th. Worse, goods and services are in the UK more expensive than elsewhere. So when you consider what the average person in the UK can actually afford, we are 28th. 28th not 6th.
(And we don't have 4.5m children living in poverty. Poverty is NOT earning less than a 60% a median. Or else someone on £1m a year in Monaco is living in poverty. And the numbers living in poverty DECREASE if median earnings decline... Which is plainly nonsense. The numbers in actual real poverty, like shortage of food or clothing, is between 1m and 2m. Still way too many but not as sensational an argument as claiming it's 4.5m)
