Am I the greatest Stone Roses fan on the forum?

[Stoned Rose]

As if this thread is still going 5 years later.

Don’t even remember starting it!.

 

[Johnny Mars Bar]

The most over rated band in the history of music. Bag of old shite, no wonder people need to take a mountain of drugs to listen to them.

 

[Nightmare Walking]

The most over rated band in the history of music. Bag of old shite, no wonder people need to take a mountain of drugs to listen to them.

I'm not the Roses biggest fan. But that first album is a stone cold classic. Plus they were/are extraordinarily gifted musicians.
You can't be that good on an instrument and be a bag of old shite.

 

[Johnny Mars Bar]

I'm not the Roses biggest fan. But that first album is a stone cold classic. Plus they were/are extraordinarily gifted musicians.
You can't be that good on an instrument and be a bag of old shite.

John Squire was a very good musician, in a shit band.

 

[Nightmare Walking]

John Squire was a very good musician, in a shit band.

Reni is the stand out musician in that band and Mani is a fabulous bass player, along with Squite being a gifted guitarist.

You might not like the songs which is a matter of taste. You can also criticise Ian Brown's vocals from a life perspective.
I am interested in why you think they are a shit band, though.

 

[Johnny Mars Bar]

Reni is the stand out musician in that band and Mani is a fabulous bass player, along with Squite being a gifted guitarist.

You might not like the songs which is a matter of taste. You can also criticise Ian Brown's vocals from a life perspective.
I am interested in why you think they are a shit band, though.

Maybe you had to "be there". They are before my time.

I understand the cultural impact they had but listening to their music leaves me cold - I find it dreadfully dreary and all the songs sound the same to me.

Ian Brown...I don't even need to go into that. He is objectively dreadful.

I went to see them at Heaton Park with some old uni mates and went home after about half an hour. One of the most cringeworthy, awful performances from any band I've ever seen. And I've been to some shit gigs in my time. The Wailers who supported were great at least.

 

[Stoned Rose]

The most over rated band in the history of music. Bag of old shite, no wonder people need to take a mountain of drugs to listen to them.

Knickers a bit tight Johnny?

 

[Alan Harper's Tash]

I’d just like to declare myself out. I’m not the biggest fan of theirs.

 

[pace89]

Just to offer a bit of balance I think they were fucking brilliant, even if they were a bit before my time.

 

[City Hobgoblin]

They're not a patch on The Dukes of Stratosphear.