Are there ANY players we are all happy with?

[Petetheblu]

BERTIE, hasn't put a foot wrong all season.

 

[citymad]

I'm happy with

Given,
Zab,
Ned,
Elano,
Superman
Kompany
De Jong
Robby
Bellers
SWP
Petrov
Boj

On the fence with

Dunne
Bridge


the rest... I'm upset about and can leave.

If we can add a couple of top strikers, a tall centre back, centre midfield general, and 2 full backs we'll be set up for a place in europe next year.

 

[warpig]

If we can add a couple of top strikers, a tall centre back, centre midfield general, and 2 full backs we'll be set up for a place in europe next year.

i think most teams could say that tbf.

 

[Bombo]

let's keep given, hart, zabaletta, Richards, onuoha, kompany, bridge, swp, Johnson, elano, robinho, bojinov, petrov, Ireland, bellamy

Get rid of schmicael, ball, garrido, tbh, benjami, vassell, fernandes, hamann, mills

Jury out on sturridge, Evans, caceido, etuhu and de Jong(yes that's right de Jong) and dunne (for now not past glories)

 

[citymad]

If we can add a couple of top strikers, a tall centre back, centre midfield general, and 2 full backs we'll be set up for a place in europe next year.

i think most teams could say that tbf.

LOL !!!yeh i know what you mean, it does sound a bit obviuos doesn't it ? But hey what the hell i'm still sticking with the suggestions.

 

[mcmanus]

If we can add a couple of top strikers, a tall centre back, centre midfield general, and 2 full backs we'll be set up for a place in europe next year.

i think most teams could say that tbf.

LOL !!!yeh i know what you mean, it does sound a bit obviuos doesn't it ? But hey what the hell i'm still sticking with the suggestions.

And a top class right and left winger ;-)

 

[GJF]

...been reading the posts as per, and its startling how much negativity there is about pretty much every single player on the City team. Is there any player that we can all agree on is good (based on ability, effort, etc..),and we want him to stay next season?

We are all becoming extremely negative.

In the last week there has either been the following threads, or the subject matter has appeared on other threads (bare in mind after thursday people changed there minds about a few players):

1: Given out (or get Hart back in as Given isnt better than Hart)
2: Dunne out
3. Richards out
4. Onohau out
5. Bridge out
6. Robhino out
7. Elano out
8. Sturridge out
9. Caceido out
10. Evans out
11. Bellamy out
12. De Jong out
13. fernandes out

To me this is just ludicrous..I`m all for discussing merits of certain players over others, and there indeed should be a couple of players that should be replaced next season, but it just seems that if a player isnt a world beater for 6 matches straight they should be sold! And thats not really the way forward...

You are a dick head

Thanks for that...I`ll be sure to pass that on.. :)



As for the actual other comments...yes, you actually got the thread, and glad to read everyones comments. Personally I am happy with:

Given
Zabaleta
Onohua
De Jong
Kompany
Elano
Robhino
Bellamy
Caceido
Ireland
SWP
Petrov
Boj
Hart
Sturridge
Bridge
Garrido
Richards
Jo (has proved can play with a stable team at Everton, and now our team is a little more stable should do okay)
Berti! (i have no idea if he is good or not)


I would look really to think about replacing Dunne if his form doesnt improve..but am a bit on the fence with this, and I would get rid of Evans, Vassell, Ball, Hammann.

 

[lastmanback]

I think we should get rid of the whole squad. Get some fresh new faces in we can booo for next season. :-)

 

[bizzbo]

its been a hard few weeks

everyones entitled to their view. im pretty sure most people only feel let down by a couple of players each, but if you add them all together..... ;)

oh and you missed zab from your list... speaking of which

the funniest one i've seen was definately the call for Given to be dropped.


but as you've invited me, my list goes as follows

Gods:
Stevie Ireland
Vinnie Kompany
Shay Given
Petrov

Awating Deification:
Onuoha

Possible deities who will have to show a just a little bit more:
Elano
Sweep
Robinho
Zabaleta
Joe Hart
De Jong

Gods who've maybe lost their way a bit:
Sturridge
Bridge
Dunne

Very good mortals who are possibly misfits:
Bellamy

God in his own mind:
Mark Hughes

The rest, I can safely say, need not concern us beyond our immediate future.