Are we good enough defensively to win the Champions League

To single out the defence is so wrong. Its not an individual problem, our defence is vulnerable as a by product of the way we play regardless of the players ability, it's the biggest weakness of a Pep team but something he's clearly willing to risk as the rewards are so high as proven by last season's achievements.

Any increase in defensive sturdiness would come at the expense of our dominating attacking displays. Pretty sure Pep himself has said how hard it is for defenders in his team to look good, there's a lot of pressure placed on them to defend 1v1 constantly, one mistake, error or even just letting your man get the better of you once often results in a goal against. I do think he needs to adapt on occasions, any time we play Liverpool being one of them but given his achievements you can't really blame Pep for having complete faith in his methods.

Well said.

But that's the point: can we play our attacking system against ANY side, esp. in CL ko stages?

And: would we be able at all to change to a defensive system within a big match when we are winning?

We have seen yesterday how flat dippers were upfront if the opponent midfield cuts their support lines.
Would David/Bernardo/Dinho +wingers be able to achieve that as well?
 
Thought our back line got exposed a few times last night. I don't think Laporte at LB helped but we seem to be cut open on a regular basis away from home in Europe.
Liverpool and Monaco away both spring to mind

Laporte is not a left back and looked like a fish out of water at times. When fit Mendy is first choice the question is whether him and Sane can play together in the same side. Personally I would like to try a back three with Vinny anchoring a stones and laporte 3 with Walker and Mendy the wing backs. We need to try something different because at times we are too predictable and teams are more and more being able to nullify our attacks by swamping the midfield and catching us on the break.
 
Laporte is not a left back and looked like a fish out of water at times. When fit Mendy is first choice the question is whether him and Sane can play together in the same side. Personally I would like to try a back three with Vinny anchoring a stones and laporte 3 with Walker and Mendy the wing backs. We need to try something different because at times we are too predictable and teams are more and more being able to nullify our attacks by swamping the midfield and catching us on the break.
I think the idea of a back 3 in Europe is one I'd like to see given a chance.
We seemed to dominate once we switched to that on Tuesday night
 
Not a lot of people realise just how exposed we leave our defence if we lose the ball cheap with how far up we play. In peps first season Ota was slated, like him or love him the best defender in the world one against three forwards will look bad.

It’s why it’s SO difficult to replace Fernandinho. He is a cultured thug (when he needs to be). He is cool on the ball, can make a pass, can always make himself available, but will do whatever it takes to stop that attack that is sprung from a turnover with over half the team ahead of the ball.

It’s not news, as many people have said we lose the ball and foul. WE HAVE TO, because we are an all out attacking team once we get into the opposition half. Klopp understands this, which is why his game is all about gaining possession in the opposition half and keeping it away from his shit defenders!
 
Yes,on our day we have a very good defence. No reason why we can’t be European champions.
 
Last edited:
Yesterday was how I'd like to see us setup against big teams in Europe away from home.
At home we can punish pretty much any team, combine that away with a disciplined away performance we could be a real difficult team to beat in the champions League over 2 legs
 
Ideally we should settle on a back 5 and,taking recovery into account,play it as much as possible.

-------------Ederson----------
Walker-Stones-Laporte-Mendy

I suspect would be the majority choice.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.