Ball-in-Play Time Getting Worse Again

.db.

Well-Known Member
Joined
13 Aug 2024
Messages
6,363
For years we’ve all been bored to death with all the time wasting in the game.

There did seem to be steps forward made with more time being added on at the end of halves and games a few years ago, but that’s ended now with so many fans moaning about it (and maybe the early leavers still leaving on 80minutes so stadiums were empty for over 20 minutes making the product look shit might have had something to do with that!).

There’s a distinct lack of officials enforcing the speeding up of the game. Too few bookings for time wasting, not enough time added on, and teams just seem to be allowed to waste time at will now. We are paying all this money to just watch a load of blokes stood still on some grass for over half an hour of the game.

But this season, especially, it seems to have got even worse with the amount of time it’s taking for teams to take throw-ins, corners and free kicks, and having a lie down for a bit pretending to be injured.

IMG_2818.jpeg

One second short of 2 minutes a game less than last season. Over 3 minutes a game less than two seasons ago.



We used to be well ahead of the rest of the league with BIP stats:

IMG_2820.webp

But this season it’s been very noticeable that teams are taking an age to do anything against us, and yet our games are still third highest in the league for BIP:

IMG_2819.jpeg

I’ve been making a point of looking at the clock when the ball goes out for an throw-ins or corners this season (either at the Etihad or non-City games on tele) and throws can take as long as 45 seconds if they’re near the opposition box and some corners take over a minute. It’s mind-numblingly boring. Some of those teams down the bottom of the list; their games must be proper shit to watch.

Something needs to be done about it!

Other codes of football actively look at ways to speed the game up:
In rugby league there’s a countdown clock at drop-outs and scrums, if time runs out the opposition get the ball. And the ref will call ‘Six-Again’ and restart the tackle count for the set if a defence slows down the ruck too much.
In rugby union the ref will call ‘use it’ at a ruck when the ball is in a position to be played.

Since the countdown clocks and ‘Six-again’ calls came into rugby league, the ball-in-play is at an average of 67% or 63 minutes in an 80 minute match. Some individual matches get well over 70% BIP. It feels like perpetual motion compared to football.
Rugby union BIP has gone up 33% since turning professional in 1995 (although it’s still less than football).
Although you can dismiss gridiron because the ball isn’t even in-play for 6% of the time on the game clock in the NFL (5.79%).

Football targeted the one area that wasn’t even a problem with the 8-second rule for keepers with the ball in their hands. That’s never been an issue with regards to time wasting, that rule coming in was pointless (it has already been 6-seconds in the past!).

It’s the dead-ball situations that need speeding up in football: goal kicks, free kicks, throw-ins and corners, and refs need to start ignoring players having a lie down pretending to be injured.
 
Last edited:
Take the Bournemouth game as an example, there was a player down in the first 20 seconds who after having the last rites performed on him went on to miraculously recover.

Rinsed and repeated throughout the first 45 minutes and the ref only managed to stick 3 minutes on the end.
 
No surprise. Players are the culprits. Wankers. Hence why I don't buy into the bollocks about how tired they are.
 
No surprise. Players are the culprits. Wankers. Hence why I don't buy into the bollocks about how tired they are.
Not sure it’s just the players. It seems a definite tactic at Arsenal to delay corners to try and make the opposition switch off.

Seems weird now that they’ve only clamped down on keepers holding the ball.

Long throws, especially this season, are taking ages out of games.

Perhaps a 30 second limit on corners and throws might improve things marginally.
 
Not sure it’s just the players. It seems a definite tactic at Arsenal to delay corners to try and make the opposition switch off.

Seems weird now that they’ve only clamped down on keepers holding the ball.

Long throws, especially this season, are taking ages out of games.

Perhaps a 30 second limit on corners and throws might improve things marginally.
I'm stunned no team has gone with a tactic of taking corners, free kicks and throw ins more quickly. As soon as the ball goes out all players just fucking wander around like it's a training pitch. You'd think it was all planned so they could get more time to just fucking mince about.

It would be interesting, as soon as the ball went out for a corner, if your players who are properly drilled for a corner were up there straight away and the corner take within 10-15 seconds. You'd definitely catch the opposition out. Same with free kicks.

Football realty is in the dark ages with 'special teams' type stuff
 
Not sure it’s just the players. It seems a definite tactic at Arsenal to delay corners to try and make the opposition switch off.

Seems weird now that they’ve only clamped down on keepers holding the ball.

Long throws, especially this season, are taking ages out of games.

Perhaps a 30 second limit on corners and throws might improve things marginally.
Take it in half that time or see the decision reversed to the opponent.
 
Too many stupid rules and the refs don't help.

Not taking a goal kick from the side the ball went out is the most stupid thing ever introduced, plays right into the hands of time wasters.
Like every measure ever brought in with the good intention to speed up the game, it was immediately seized upon and exploited by coaches, looking to find a way it could be used to cheat.
 
Not sure it’s just the players. It seems a definite tactic at Arsenal to delay corners to try and make the opposition switch off.

Seems weird now that they’ve only clamped down on keepers holding the ball.

Long throws, especially this season, are taking ages out of games.

Perhaps a 30 second limit on corners and throws might improve things marginally.
As mentioned in another thread, IFAB did discuss speeding up re-starts at their latest meeting.

I struggle to see how it can be implemented though. The laws of the game don't just apply to the top tiers of football, with multi ball in use. What about lower down the pyramid when they have to wait for the ball to be returned from the crowd? Or right at the lower end in park football, when a full back leathers the ball 50 yards off the pitch?

The only way I can see it being possible is to set a time limit from when the team is in position to take the re-start. And as already happens now to a certain extent, that will just lead to nobody going over to take the kick/ throw for as long as they can get away with.
 
As mentioned in another thread, IFAB did discuss speeding up re-starts at their latest meeting.

I struggle to see how it can be implemented though. The laws of the game don't just apply to the top tiers of football, with multi ball in use. What about lower down the pyramid when they have to wait for the ball to be returned from the crowd? Or right at the lower end in park football, when a full back leathers the ball 50 yards off the pitch?

The only way I can see it being possible is to set a time limit from when the team is in position to take the re-start. And as already happens now to a certain extent, that will just lead to nobody going over to take the kick/ throw for as long as they can get away with.
I guess it’d have to be down to the referee’s discretion as to when the restart could first take place.
 
Take it in half that time or see the decision reversed to the opponent.
I used 30 seconds as that’s the shortest length of time at the moment for corners.

There needs to be some time for the players to get into position.

I’d be more ruthless on throw ins. The trot over, wipe the ball down etc. needs to stop. 15 seconds maybe?
 
I'm stunned no team has gone with a tactic of taking corners, free kicks and throw ins more quickly. As soon as the ball goes out all players just fucking wander around like it's a training pitch. You'd think it was all planned so they could get more time to just fucking mince about.

It would be interesting, as soon as the ball went out for a corner, if your players who are properly drilled for a corner were up there straight away and the corner take within 10-15 seconds. You'd definitely catch the opposition out. Same with free kicks.

Football realty is in the dark ages with 'special teams' type stuff
Is it, or is it in the space age where interruptions are designed to kill momentum and allow teams time to switch off?

Everything in football these days is geared to get mini advantages over the opposition, whether to score a goal or to stop a better team’s momentum.
 
Not sure it’s just the players. It seems a definite tactic at Arsenal to delay corners to try and make the opposition switch off.

Seems weird now that they’ve only clamped down on keepers holding the ball.

Long throws, especially this season, are taking ages out of games.

Perhaps a 30 second limit on corners and throws might improve things marginally.
The downside to that is that players would take the maximum time allowed to take the throw or corner. Stop the clock whenever there is a stoppage and when the matches are still in play after a couple of hours it will improve and we will get what we pay for.
 
The other thing that needs stopping is keepers going down “injured” for time outs.

Making them leave the pitch for 30 seconds would stop that instantly.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top