Benjamin Mendy

Status
Not open for further replies.
You're the one flapping. It's a reasonable question whether we're in for two left backs and or right backs, because often a club will register an interest in two players in case one falls through for whatever reason.

It's not actually a reasonable question though.

What you're saying is "ignore all the evidence that we're getting 2 LB's (ITKs, Journalists, not having a LB etc.) and tell me where the evidence is?"

You ask why everyone thinks we're getting 2, I tell you, and then you say, "yeah but ignore that because it doesn't suit my crisis about only getting one".
 
It's incredibly clear cut.

1) We have no left backs. Kolarov is not a LB option any more.

2) Mendy is injury prone, can't be our only LB.

3) EVERYONE SAYS WE'RE GETTING 4.

Is this the daily flap? Nothing going on today so we've got to flap about getting 1 LB or 2?

2 of Kolarov's last 3 starts ( the Derby and Zaba's farewell game) were at left back, of course he's still a left back option.
 
2 of Kolarov's last 3 starts ( the Derby and Zaba's farewell game) were at left back, of course he's still a left back option.

He played 28 games at CB and 12 at LB last season. He played LB 3 times in 2017

Pep refused to play him at LB even when Clichy was giving away goals on a weekly basis. He's not a LB option any more than Fernandinho is a RB option. Use in case of emergencies, that's all.
 
It's not actually a reasonable question though.

What you're saying is "ignore all the evidence that we're getting 2 LB's (ITKs, Journalists, not having a LB etc.) and tell me where the evidence is?"

You ask why everyone thinks we're getting 2, I tell you, and then you say, "yeah but ignore that because it doesn't suit my crisis about only getting one".

People are taking the suggestion that Bertrand could arrive without Mendy as though people are saying we're only going for one LB full stop. What if the plan is Mendy OR Bertrand plus one other? It just seems odd that people are shooting other posters down in this thread with quite high level of certainty. It doesn't take an ITK to say we're getting 4 full backs, it's plain common sense. I just think it's really weird how many people are quick to post things like "how many times do you need telling we're getting Bertrand AND Mendy." It's not a completely absurd suggestion that Bertrand could be our main LB signing this summer. I'd like Mendy myself but I'm not too worried by the idea of Bertrand plus one other in a summer where all our other deficiencies are also (hopefully) addressed. Hopefully it'll be both but it'd be nice to be able look at other possibilities without being accused of flapping!
 
If the rumor we think £40M is too much for a LB, we have no chance a Sandro.
Personally would love our first choice full backs to be as close to "world class" as we can. Sandro is a much more reliable quality purchase, although I accept more money. IMO Mendy has question marks about his injury record, character, intelligence and attitude. I think we are in danger of picking a player for brawn when IMO footballing ability is more important.
 
He played 28 games at CB and 12 at LB last season. He played LB 3 times in 2017

Pep refused to play him at LB even when Clichy was giving away goals on a weekly basis. He's not a LB option any more than Fernandinho is a RB option. Use in case of emergencies, that's all.

4. You missed out Huddersfield in the cup. ;)

Who knows what will happen but it's not inconceivable that we'll sign 1 left back and Kolarov will be his backup.
 
Mendy will sign soon he has been very active on social media his entire vacation en before when he was with France now his last instagram story was him arriving at a airport he flew to from Dubai that was a few days ago after that he stopped posting.
 
4. You missed out Huddersfield in the cup. ;)

Who knows what will happen but it's not inconceivable that we'll sign 1 left back and Kolarov will be his backup.

I agree that it's not inconceivable that Kolarov could be back up left-back again this season. I don't think it's an absolute given that we'll sign four full backs this window, but hope we do get both Mendy and Bertrand. Hopefully Guardiola saw enough of Kolarov as a full back last season not to play him there again unless in an emergency.
 
I agree that it's not inconceivable that Kolarov could be back up left-back again this season. I don't think it's an absolute given that we'll sign four full backs this window, but hope we do get both Mendy and Bertrand. Hopefully Guardiola saw enough of Kolarov as a full back last season not to play him there again unless in an emergency.

Please stop.
 
Mendy will sign soon he has been very active on social media his entire vacation en before when he was with France now his last instagram story was him arriving at a airport he flew to from Dubai that was a few days ago after that he stopped posting.
I was just thinking this, as soon as he started following Ederson as well.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.