Blue Moon Playlist Review Club - Season 2 - Episode 32 - threespires - Could have been a Contender (pg 472)

Not only is it hard to keep up with all of the music threads, its even harder to write something meaningful all of the time. So here are some random notes on this week's playlist from @Black&White&BlueMoon Town

I enjoyed it and the new (to me) tracks that stood out were:-

"Watershed" - Indigo Girls
"Youngblood" - Russian Circles
"The Fight to be Human" - Justin Currie, although I have the suspicion that @Coatigan may have nominated this before. I love the progressive intensity on this song.
"El Doomo" - Ellis

Of those that I already knew:-

"The Garden" is superb, as is a lot of Clockwork Angels - one of Rush's best.
"Iron Sky" - Paolo Nutini - great, evocative song and nice integration of the spoken Chaplain part.
Of course "Racing in the Street" is a classic. That beautiful keyboard part that rises in the coda - that's the kind of thing that is missing in a lot of albums we review on here.

Now some guys they just give up living
And start dying little by little, piece by piece
Some guys come home from work and wash up

And go racin' in the street

But I think he is saying that you can replace "racin' in the street" with "go to a football match/the cinema/the theatre" or "do some DIY" or "start a YouTube Channel" or "read a book" or "travel the world". That's always been my interpretation anyway.

EDIT: Forgot to mention "Requiem, Op 48 etc." - Something a little different bit very pleasant.
 
Last edited:
The Human Condition
Thanks to all adding to the Playlist theme this week, this was indeed truly fun both assembling and hearing this. I’m going to focus on the lyrics that resonated with me the most in the songs.

The Big Winner
"The Fight to Be Human" – Justin Currie
, 8+ minutes of brilliance, this one has stuck with me, enjoyed where this song went from a tick-tock start to the amazing ending. If this was nominated prior, I missed it, so this was new to me. That fool in the mirror has taken my place

My top other new tracks (not yet heard in some or no particular order):
  • “El Doomo” – Ellis, Taking you such a long time to find that this is really me
  • “Iron Sky” – Paolo Nutini, But no one, nobody, can give you the power to rise over love, over hate
  • “The One Who Knows” – Dar Williams, very emotional song, If I had the world to give, I’d give it all to you
  • “Plywood Superman” – Jim White, beautiful melancholy song. But nobody never breaks free of nothing
  • “Cosmic Concerto” – Bill Fay, There’s infinite variation, Life is people
  • “Mercy Now” – Mary Gauthier, My church and my country could use a little mercy now
  • “Deeper Water” – Paul Kelly, the lyrics over time here were very well done, this had it all, happiness and sadness
  • “My Ever Changing Moods” – The Style Council, the past is knowledge, the present our mistake, and the future we always leave too late
  • “Requiem, Op. 48” – peaceful choir led tune
  • “Atmospherics: Listen To The Radio” – Tom Robinson and friends, Find a bar, avoid a fight, show your papers, be polite
  • “Falling and Laughing” – Orange Juice, great bass on this track, only my dreams satisfy the real need of my heart
  • “Youngblood” - Russian Circles, a musical fast pace piece that made me feel like driving even faster past traffic
  • “Nature Boy” – Nat King Cole, The greatest thing you'll ever learn, Is just to love and be loved in return

Top tracks I knew but enjoyed listening to again (in some or no particular order):
  • “The River” – Bruce Springsteen, Is a dream a lie that don’t come true, or is it something worse?
  • “Don’t Let It Bring You Down” – Neil Young, Just find someone who’s turning, and you will come around
  • “Shut Out the Light” – Bruce Springsteen, I’ve got the shakes and I’m gonna be sick
  • “Changes” – David Bowie, They’re quite aware of what they’re going through
  • "The Needle and the Damage Done" – Neil Young, I sing the song because I love the man, I know that some of you don't understand
  • “That Smell” – Lynyrd Skynyrd, Oak tree, you’re in my way
  • “Love and Mercy” – Brian Wilson, A lotta people out there hurtin’ and it really scares me
  • “Human” – The Human League, No one else could ever take your place
  • "Racing in the Street" - Bruce Springsteen, Rob got the quote ;-)
  • "Both Sides Now" - Joni Mitchell, I really don't know life at all
 
Will just leave it open as a general open invite, whenever someone gets an idea or a theme, just go ahead start one on a monday.
 
Last edited:
BM PLC, WK31, Mr Grumpy: WAR.

I was listening to the last track on my playlist as I was reading (discovering) this thread and thought to myself that war would make a good theme.
Then I read the plea for new entrants and the die was cast. I've no pithy intro as to why war was chosen but on reflection, it's a deep mineshaft so should be ripe for the unearthing of some diamonds. This subject also allows me to crowbar some cultural and non-indie music into the sub :)

For format, I have a subscription to YouTube Music unlimited and I'll be posting those links which should be available on YouTube standard. As per the post early on in this thread, if you don't have YTM, then google is your friend.

So onto the tracks:
-------------------------------------------------

1) Frankie Goes to Hollywood: Two Tribes. 12"

Anyone growing up (i.e. early teens) in the 80's, can attest to the cold war USSR-USA tension that was thick in the air. This was time of films such as threads, when the wind blows, & the day after. Bands too, followed suit with songs about Armageddon, the cold war. Cheery stuff.
I picked up this 12" remix of two tribes in the late 80's as it caught my eye in the record shops (remember them?) I started frequenting after buying my new HIFI system with the money from my 1st job. This 12" uses sound clips from the very disturbing (because they are real and actual public service broadcasts!) nuclear war preperation series "Protect and survive". Poor Grandma. Bonus quiz: Who's the voice of President Reagan? (clue: He's a smeg heeeeeeeeeeed)

Trever Horn at his finest.

Listener Notes: Play it LOUD and on decent gear.



Further reading: https://rcrdkeeper.wordpress.com/2021/01/26/review-of-the-two-tribes-single-and-12-extended-mix/
------------------------------------------

2) U2: Sunday Bloody Sunday.

According to the UK government at the time, "the troubles" were just that and not a war. Those involved in that period would beg to differ.
The events of 1972, put down on vinyl in 1983 by a young Irish group just starting out on their own version of world dominance.
Perhaps the finest record they made, everything is absolutely tight and highly tuned with the horrors of the day(s) perfectly narrated to the ignorant world of the time.

This, to me, is how political pop music should be. Nothing finer.



Further reading: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bloody_Sunday_(1972)

-----------------------------------------------------------------------
3: Don Mclean: The Grave.

I bought the LP American Pie for a friend a few years back as a thank you for a favour he did (We used to talk a lot about music). He mentioned the LP a few times and i thought it a nice change from the usual pint/ chocolates/smelly candle* friends sometimes give each other.
I got the best version i could find and it was 2nd hand (now long out of pressing). Before wrapping it up, I gave it a spin to see how it sounded and oh boy, what a gem of an album. It is one of those albums where the title track is probably the worst on it and becomes forgettable the more you play the album. "The Grave" hits home hard. Very hard. I won't expand on it's lyrics or composition, that's for you, the listener to discover but it is not track to be listening on a personal high point...

Notes: A track for listening, not hearing.



-------------------------------------

4) Guns n' Roses: Civil War

Taken from the 1st track of the double album: Use your Illusion II (and originally from Nobody's Child), this track has perhaps the greatest sample intro ever.
Fans of the band argue it is their best track. Hard to argue against that and I think it's them at the peak for sure.

I wasn't a huge fan of GnR, I'm not really a hard rock/metal fan but this just carries across all genres. It's a fantastic, energetic stomper of a track with some superb musicianship and penmanship on show.

Bonus quiz: Name the film from the opening sample.....



What's so civil 'bout war anyway?

-----------------------------------

5) Platoon soundtrack: The Vancouver Symphony Orchestra: Adagio for strings.

I had another (forum controversial) track earmarked for the bookend of this list, but I dunno, this just seemed to be a perfect ending, rather than just another good track. If you are going to source this from anywhere other than the link, please make sure it is the official soundtrack version as it has the haunting dialogue of the films main character which is essential.

Is platoon the finest war film ever made? Some would say yes, some no. Personally, it's up there although I would say that Full metal Jacket would have been mine had they finished filming after the scene in the toilet.....

How ironic, that despite the eons of classical music emanating from across the globe, one of its finest pieces is by a 20th Century Yank :) .

In a series of tracks where the lyrics are the keystones, perhaps perfect that this last track says the most by saying nothing.

I played this to my wife once, on a evening, sat down on my listening couch, lights dimmed, glass of wine, no words. We were both in tears at the end.



--------------------------------------------

Epilogue.

I had intended to add something fun and light hearted in the list of tracks but decided to leave that for next week. War is not fun.
To finish off this post, no finer words than from the Last Post:

They shall grow not old, as we that are left grow old,
Age shall not weary them, nor the years condemn.
At the going down of the sun, and in the morning,
We will remember them.



---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Prologue: Playlist


Spotify playlist: War (BM)
 
Last edited:
And The Band Played Waltzing Matilda is an Eric Bogle songs that's been covered by many artists. There's more famous versions but June Tabor's completely unaccompanied and unvarnished version does the subject matter justice.

And The Band Played Waltzing Matilda - June Tabor
 
Though the original, and my favourite, version of Shipbuilding is Robert Wyatt's I'm sure I've nominated it somewhere before on here. Elvis Costello's subsequent version of the song he co wrote has Chet Baker on it so deserves a run out too

Elvis Costello and the Attractions - Shipbuilding
 
Thanks.

Tried to get a variety of genres in it:

70's Folk,
80's Pop
90's Metal
Trevor Horn.
Classical
Soundtracks.

Ive got quite a few in mind off the bat, and could really curveball this one. But probably won't, will see how it all goes.
 
Wa-Ching!

Send Sally to the sandbox baby, send Johnny into open fire. We're dying for the stone-faced liars. And we're all going straight to hell.

Keeping it simple. I know it is shouty nonsense to some of you, but I love it.

War - Idles
 
BM PLC, WK31, Mr Grumpy: WAR.

I was listening to the last track on my playlist as I was reading (discovering) this thread and thought to myself that war would make a good theme.
Then I read the plea for new entrants and the die was cast. I've no pithy intro as to why war was chosen but on reflection, it's a deep mineshaft so should be ripe for the unearthing of some diamonds. This subject also allows me to crowbar some cultural and non-indie music into the sub :)

For format, I have a subscription to YouTube Music unlimited and I'll be posting those links which should be available on YouTube standard. As per the post early on in this thread, if you don't have YTM, then google is your friend.

So onto the tracks:
-------------------------------------------------

1) Frankie Goes to Hollywood: Two Tribes. 12"

Anyone growing up (i.e. early teens) in the 80's, can attest to the cold war USSR-USA tension that was thick in the air. This was time of films such as threads, when the wind blows, & the day after. Bands too, followed suit with songs about Armageddon, the cold war. Cheery stuff.
I picked up this 12" remix of two tribes in the late 80's as it caught my eye in the record shops (remember them?) I started frequenting after buying my new HIFI system with the money from my 1st job. This 12" uses sound clips from the very disturbing (because they are real and actual public service broadcasts!) nuclear war preperation series "Protect and survive". Poor Grandma. Bonus quiz: Who's the voice of President Reagan? (clue: He's a smeg heeeeeeeeeeed)

Trever Horn at his finest.

Listener Notes: Play it LOUD and on decent gear.



Further reading: https://rcrdkeeper.wordpress.com/2021/01/26/review-of-the-two-tribes-single-and-12-extended-mix/
------------------------------------------

2) U2: Sunday Bloody Sunday.

According to the UK government at the time, "the troubles" were just that and not a war. Those involved in that period would beg to differ.
The events of 1972, put down on vinyl in 1983 by a young Irish group just starting out on their own version of world dominance.
Perhaps the finest record they made, everything is absolutely tight and highly tuned with the horrors of the day(s) perfectly narrated to the ignorant world of the time.

This, to me, is how political pop music should be. Nothing finer.



Further reading: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bloody_Sunday_(1972)

-----------------------------------------------------------------------
3: Don Mclean: The Grave.

I bought the LP American Pie for a friend a few years back as a thank you for a favour he did (We used to talk a lot about music). He mentioned the LP a few times and i thought it a nice change from the usual pint/ chocolates/smelly candle* friends sometimes give each other.
I got the best version i could find and it was 2nd hand (now long out of pressing). Before wrapping it up, I gave it a spin to see how it sounded and oh boy, what a gem of an album. It is one of those albums where the title track is probably the worst on it and becomes forgettable the more you play the album. "The Grave" hits home hard. Very hard. I won't expand on it's lyrics or composition, that's for you, the listener to discover but it is not track to be listening on a personal high point...

Notes: A track for listening, not hearing.



-------------------------------------

4) Guns n' Roses: Civil War

Taken from the 1st track of the double album: Use your Illusion II (and originally from Nobody's Child), this track has perhaps the greatest sample intro ever.
Fans of the band argue it is their best track. Hard to argue against that and I think it's them at the peak for sure.

I wasn't a huge fan of GnR, I'm not really a hard rock/metal fan but this just carries across all genres. It's a fantastic, energetic stomper of a track with some superb musicianship and penmanship on show.

Bonus quiz: Name the film from the opening sample.....



What's so civil 'bout war anyway?

-----------------------------------

5) Platoon soundtrack: The Vancouver Symphony Orchestra: Adagio for strings.

I had another (forum controversial) track earmarked for the bookend of this list, but I dunno, this just seemed to be a perfect ending, rather than just another good track. If you are going to source this from anywhere other than the link, please make sure it is the official soundtrack version as it has the haunting dialogue of the films main character which is essential.

Is platoon the finest war film ever made? Some would say yes, some no. Personally, it's up there although I would say that Full metal Jacket would have been mine had they finished filming after the scene in the toilet.....

How ironic, that despite the eons of classical music emanating from across the globe, one of its finest pieces is by a 20th Century Yank :) .

In a series of tracks where the lyrics are the keystones, perhaps perfect that this last track says the most by saying nothing.

I played this to my wife once, on a evening, sat down on my listening couch, lights dimmed, glass of wine, no words. We were both in tears at the end.



--------------------------------------------

Epilogue.

I had intended to add something fun and light hearted in the list of tracks but decided to leave that for next week. War is not fun.
To finish off this post, no finer words than from the Last Post:

They shall grow not old, as we that are left grow old,
Age shall not weary them, nor the years condemn.
At the going down of the sun, and in the morning,
We will remember them.

Forgot to answer your question yesterday: Cool-Hand Luke.

Never seen the film but I seem to remember reading about it when this album was reviewed on release. Great song by the way.

Today's nomination:-

"Sadr City" - Corb Lund
 
Skipped yesterday, might not be about tomorrow, mood and timing feels apt so I'll go with my second today if that's ok. Generally staying conscious of the rules.
 
A long forgotten (if ever noticed) total footnote of a song, about a footnote of an event. Thought it was damn powerful back in the day, and decades later, it still knows how to lump the throat.

U2 & Pavarotti - Miss Sarajevo

This one inflicts pain gradually, through a gentle slow dig into the ribs, rather than a packing a big gut punch. Give it time to do its thing.
 
Welcome to another new Blue Moon music thread.

The idea for this one was proposed by @Mancitydoogle, and I agreed to set this up and run it along with Mr Doogle and @Coatigan.

Here’s what you need to know:-


The Basics
  • If possible, the original nominator keeps the playlist up to date as the week progresses.
Will do this this evening.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top