More often than not I would agree with you.
I just think we need to freshen it up a touch, can't keep playing the likes of Fernandinho and De Bruyne constantly - although Fern, wrongly did have a bit of a rest Wednesday evening.
Also, I think we look a little unbalanced with all three of Gundogan, Silva and De Bruyne in midfield at the moment.
I'm not sure how much we played within in ourselves against Monchengladbach, it's possible we held back a little with this early kick-off in mind, and therefore we might go with what you suggest.
Currently, I am just not certain the best eleven on paper so to speak offers us the best balance.
Undoubtedly though, once it clicks someone is in for a good old hiding.