Feed-The-Goat said:im 23 and hes still behind gio and benarbia.
the older generation will also probably add bell, lee, summerbee, lake, white, doyle etc to the list.
dont get me wrong. i love tevez and if he has 5 or 6 seasons of this standard then he will be citys best player of all time. well at least one of em.mcfc_die_hard said:davymcfc said:lets see. vaguely remember people saying this about robinho and look how that turned out. certainly the best season that anyone has had for us in a long time. legend for choosing us over the scum. you gotta love him. lets not get too carried away tho.
robinho has the talent but no heart. tevez has the lot and he seems like a city player. he has the desire that the city fans want to see.
davymcfc said:dont get me wrong. i love tevez and if he has 5 or 6 seasons of this standard then he will be citys best player of all time. well at least one of em.mcfc_die_hard said:robinho has the talent but no heart. tevez has the lot and he seems like a city player. he has the desire that the city fans want to see.
mcfc_die_hard said:Feed-The-Goat said:im 23 and hes still behind gio and benarbia.
the older generation will also probably add bell, lee, summerbee, lake, white, doyle etc to the list.
by gio i take it you mean geovanni? if you do mean him then just no
Feed-The-Goat said:mcfc_die_hard said:by gio i take it you mean geovanni? if you do mean him then just no
you know who im talking about, im not falling for that sunshine!
defo. i hope he is here for 5 seasons. more goals against the rags please. legend.mcfc_die_hard said:davymcfc said:dont get me wrong. i love tevez and if he has 5 or 6 seasons of this standard then he will be citys best player of all time. well at least one of em.
yeah i probably put that wrong by saying best ever player. i just mean his talent and his ability and desire. i think if he is here for 5 or 6 seasons then he will be city best ever player
Sorry mate but he`s better than both them players & i am of the older generation.Tevez is one of the best players to ever play for us.Feed-The-Goat said:im 23 and hes still behind gio and benarbia.
the older generation will also probably add bell, lee, summerbee, lake, white, doyle etc to the list.
Ticket For Schalke said:He was an Argentinian Ched Evans up untill the Dippers game.
Goater, Ali b, Berko, Geo even SWP.
Just a giddy excited 17yr old.
ballinio said:Sorry mate but he`s better than both them players & i am of the older generation.Tevez is one of the best players to ever play for us.Feed-The-Goat said:im 23 and hes still behind gio and benarbia.
the older generation will also probably add bell, lee, summerbee, lake, white, doyle etc to the list.
mcfc_die_hard said:Ticket For Schalke said:He was an Argentinian Ched Evans up untill the Dippers game.
Goater, Ali b, Berko, Geo even SWP.
Just a giddy excited 17yr old.
Geo maybe not the rest. have you picked your toys up yet lad hahahaha
Ticket For Schalke said:mcfc_die_hard said:Geo maybe not the rest. have you picked your toys up yet lad hahahaha
Ok your right, Carlos Tevez has done more for the club than those mentioned.
mcfc_die_hard said:Right im only 17 so i never saw Bell and all the other City greats but i was just thinking surely Carlos has to be the best ever City player. Obviously not got the stats just yet but just looking at his performances, he must be the best?
mcfc_die_hard said:Ticket For Schalke said:Ok your right, Carlos Tevez has done more for the club than those mentioned.
haha where in my question did i say has carlos tevez done more for the club than anyone else? no i said is he the best player to play for city. if messi was to play one game for city he would be classed as the greatest player ever to play for city
KenTheLandlord said:mcfc_die_hard said:Right im only 17 so i never saw Bell and all the other City greats but i was just thinking surely Carlos has to be the best ever City player. Obviously not got the stats just yet but just looking at his performances, he must be the best?
As you are 17, i will give you the benefit of the doubt.
To be fair, he wouldn't get in a squad of 25. However, he is playing well and needs to do this for about 5 or 6 years and at least walk off with at least one PL title.
Ticket For Schalke said:mcfc_die_hard said:haha where in my question did i say has carlos tevez done more for the club than anyone else? no i said is he the best player to play for city. if messi was to play one game for city he would be classed as the greatest player ever to play for city
I thought contribution to the club would be included for best player. Because your title is broad and some what misleading.