Yeah I read through various ranking sources after posting and smacked them into ChatGPT to analyze and consensus puts the MLS 10th. But it noted that leagues ranked 6 to 15 are very close in quality. And the MLS has 30 clubs so ranking this high is quite a testamant to the depth.
This was the concensus rankings in order for anybody curious.
Tier 1: Prem, La LIga, Serie A, Bundesliga, Ligue 1
Tier 2: Championship, Belgian Pro League, Brasil Serie A, Portuguese Liga, MLS, Eredivise, Argentina Primera, Liga MX, Turkish Super Lig.
Back in 2010 MLS ranked closer to 30th. Pretty quick rise. I guess this is largely due to money!
One thing many don’t know about MLS is that it has salary cap rules that are similar to other American leagues like the nba or nfl. This means that talent is distributed very differently compared to most of the leagues mentioned there.
For one, there’s a great disparity in what top EPL (or Bundesliga or La Liga, etc) clubs pay and what teams near the relegation zone pay.
Also, most clubs in Europe, regardless of the league or their standing in the table, will have a salary structure that looks something like:
1-3 star players who make X amount
5-7 proven starters/important players who make maybe 80% of that
6-10 part time starters or important bench players who make another 20% less than that.
After that, you’ll have a few fringe players who might make a good bit less.
Obviously, those numbers are just general estimates, but you get the gist of it.
In MLS, however, the rules are different (and complicated). Each team can have up to 3 designated players. As I said, the rules are complicated, but designated players would usually make at least 1.8 million USD, but there is no limit. After that, most team’s starters would likely make 500-800k USD per year, but most of your bench players will be making 100-300k USD per year.
The higher paying spots also tend to go to attacking players, as goals attract more fans. And ambitious teams will use every loophole they can find to pay players more, but the main salary differentiator between big spenders and less ambitious clubs is in what they’re paying designated players, or DPs.
So, while there are some good players and plenty of decent on the pitch in an mls game, there are also some who really aren’t very good at all. Basically all mls teams are going to be affected more by injuries than clubs in other leagues, and are much less likely to have substitutes who can make a big impact.
I tend to think that the better teams in the championship would outclass mls teams, especially over the course of a season, but that mls teams would match up pretty well with teams in the bottom half of the championship.
It’s not an amazing level, but it is pretty impressive for Sullivan to be doing as well he is as a 16 year-old (he turns 17 on September 28).