Cavan Sullivan

Youth soccer in the USA is still largely pay for play and there hasn’t been any substantial movement to get away from it. The best athletes will still favor the more traditional American sports and we will be having the same conversation during and after the next World Cup that’s hosted in the USA.
 
I think people are being slightly too dismissive of the MLS here in undermining what Cavan is doing. The MLS is miles clear of where it was 10 years back. It's full of quality players that could play in Europe if they wished. Most of the superstars in the league are obviously past their prime when they join, but majority do not offer NEAR as much quality as Cavan... Messi aside (I still think he's a top 5 player in the world).

I would say its similar to the Championship/Eredivise/Portuguese League/Turkish lig in terms of average quality... and not many 16 year olds stealing the show in these leagues.

I think it's good to see the levels rise in North America, and I think this trend will continue due in large part to the success of the World Cup. Everyone knows North America produces many of the worlds greatest athletes, and I expect many more to start choosing "soccer" as their main sport, and Cavan may pioneer Manchester City as the destination of choice for these kids if all goes well.

For now all we can do is support this young man and wish him the best. Still a long way to go. But I think City will be very pleased with their decision to sign this boy. NA market is massive and Cavan will further bolster City as global powerhouse if he becomes the star America has been waiting and wishing for...

Good luck lad.

Opta have it about the same level as Turkey, the Netherlands, slightly above the Spanish second division.

From what I've seen that's about right. So we should treat him like he's doing this for FC Twente or someone similar.
 
Opta have it about the same level as Turkey, the Netherlands, slightly above the Spanish second division.

From what I've seen that's about right. So we should treat him like he's doing this for FC Twente or someone similar.
Yeah I read through various ranking sources after posting and smacked them into ChatGPT to analyze and consensus puts the MLS 10th. But it noted that leagues ranked 6 to 15 are very close in quality. And the MLS has 30 clubs so ranking this high is quite a testamant to the depth.

This was the concensus rankings in order for anybody curious.

Tier 1: Prem, La LIga, Serie A, Bundesliga, Ligue 1

Tier 2: Championship, Belgian Pro League, Brasil Serie A, Portuguese Liga, MLS, Eredivise, Argentina Primera, Liga MX, Turkish Super Lig.

Back in 2010 MLS ranked closer to 30th. Pretty quick rise. I guess this is largely due to money!
 
Hi Everyone.

This is my first post on the forum. I’m an American, and my favorite team is the USMNT, so I watch a lot of teams that feature top Americans and top American prospects. I’m here as I like seeing what fans of the club teams are saying about the players, and see some questions and comments in here where my input could be useful. Don’t worry though, I’m not here to blindly defend or promote Sullivan.

I will say though that having kept up with him for a few years now, and watched most of his minutes since MLS resumed play after the World Cup that I think he is very much the real deal from an American perspective. Only time will tell if he’s able to establish himself at Man City, though.
 
Youth soccer in the USA is still largely pay for play and there hasn’t been any substantial movement to get away from it. The best athletes will still favor the more traditional American sports and we will be having the same conversation during and after the next World Cup that’s hosted in the USA.
I actually disagree with you here. The last time the USA hosted the world cup (94'), the MLS did not exist... it was created a few years after I believe. Nowadays some MLS clubs have academies that could rival the PL in quality. They have far more revenue than in the past, and the quality of scouting in North America has skyrocketed in the last 10-15 years.

Canada has gone from a nothing footballing country to narrowly being eliminated in the 2024 Copa America Semi-Finals to Argentina, and by Morocco in the World Cup R16 while missing arguably their three most important players in Alphonso Davies, Ismael Kone, and Moise Bombito.

I know plenty of English clubs (and many others) run camps all over Canada and the United States now. Canada alone has produced Davies, Jonathon David, Kone (one of Serie A best midfielders), Promise David (just signed by Brighton), Alistair Johnson (fixture at Celtic and they love him), Bombito (Lille starting CB when fit), Eustaquio (captained Porto), De Fougerolles (young Fulham talent), Liam Millar (scored in Prem last week), and the three Villareal boys Buchanan, Saliba, and Oluwaseyi who are all off to great starts. May not all be household names, but some proper footballers coming out of North America now.

And youth "soccer" is far from pay to play if you're good enough. Academies will snatch you up now. Most scouts will tell you they can tell by 8 or 9 years old if someone could "make it".

And all sports can be compared in terms of cost, with soccer probably one of the cheapest, most accessible options. Of course travel teams and such cost money, but this is true for all sports in NA. The best players will find a way to be in the best positions to succeed, and this era is the first time I'm comfortable saying this.

Hi Everyone.

This is my first post on the forum. I’m an American, and my favorite team is the USMNT, so I watch a lot of teams that feature top Americans and top American prospects. I’m here as I like seeing what fans of the club teams are saying about the players, and see some questions and comments in here where my input could be useful. Don’t worry though, I’m not here to blindly defend or promote Sullivan.

I will say though that having kept up with him for a few years now, and watched most of his minutes since MLS resumed play after the World Cup that I think he is very much the real deal from an American perspective. Only time will tell if he’s able to establish himself at Man City, though.
Welcome.
 
Yeah I read through various ranking sources after posting and smacked them into ChatGPT to analyze and consensus puts the MLS 10th. But it noted that leagues ranked 6 to 15 are very close in quality. And the MLS has 30 clubs so ranking this high is quite a testamant to the depth.

This was the concensus rankings in order for anybody curious.

Tier 1: Prem, La LIga, Serie A, Bundesliga, Ligue 1

Tier 2: Championship, Belgian Pro League, Brasil Serie A, Portuguese Liga, MLS, Eredivise, Argentina Primera, Liga MX, Turkish Super Lig.

Back in 2010 MLS ranked closer to 30th. Pretty quick rise. I guess this is largely due to money!
One thing many don’t know about MLS is that it has salary cap rules that are similar to other American leagues like the nba or nfl. This means that talent is distributed very differently compared to most of the leagues mentioned there.

For one, there’s a great disparity in what top EPL (or Bundesliga or La Liga, etc) clubs pay and what teams near the relegation zone pay.

Also, most clubs in Europe, regardless of the league or their standing in the table, will have a salary structure that looks something like:

1-3 star players who make X amount

5-7 proven starters/important players who make maybe 80% of that

6-10 part time starters or important bench players who make another 20% less than that.

After that, you’ll have a few fringe players who might make a good bit less.

Obviously, those numbers are just general estimates, but you get the gist of it.

In MLS, however, the rules are different (and complicated). Each team can have up to 3 designated players. As I said, the rules are complicated, but designated players would usually make at least 1.8 million USD, but there is no limit. After that, most team’s starters would likely make 500-800k USD per year, but most of your bench players will be making 100-300k USD per year.

The higher paying spots also tend to go to attacking players, as goals attract more fans. And ambitious teams will use every loophole they can find to pay players more, but the main salary differentiator between big spenders and less ambitious clubs is in what they’re paying designated players, or DPs.

So, while there are some good players and plenty of decent on the pitch in an mls game, there are also some who really aren’t very good at all. Basically all mls teams are going to be affected more by injuries than clubs in other leagues, and are much less likely to have substitutes who can make a big impact.

I tend to think that the better teams in the championship would outclass mls teams, especially over the course of a season, but that mls teams would match up pretty well with teams in the bottom half of the championship.

It’s not an amazing level, but it is pretty impressive for Sullivan to be doing as well he is as a 16 year-old (he turns 17 on September 28).
 
Can he go to Europe in the next window? Like not to us but to another club so that he can start to experience a new league. Seems he has mastered this one already.
He could go to Europe in the winter, as his mother is a German citizen of Bangladeshi descent. As a side note, she played football at the university of Pennsylvania, where she met Cavan’s father. However, none of the city football group clubs seem to over an appropriate situation and step up right now, and I doubt any good clubs in good leagues would be interested in taking him on loan without an option to buy. If Girona were still in La Liga and doing well, that might’ve been a good opportunity for him.

As things stand, I think it makes most sense for him to stay in Philadelphia until January 2028, and go to Manchester City for the second half of the season. There, he could train and hopefully make a few appearances, and the club can get a close look and decide if he’s ready to help the first team, or if a loan would do him better.
 
I actually disagree with you here. The last time the USA hosted the world cup (94'), the MLS did not exist... it was created a few years after I believe. Nowadays some MLS clubs have academies that could rival the PL in quality. They have far more revenue than in the past, and the quality of scouting in North America has skyrocketed in the last 10-15 years.

Canada has gone from a nothing footballing country to narrowly being eliminated in the 2024 Copa America Semi-Finals to Argentina, and by Morocco in the World Cup R16 while missing arguably their three most important players in Alphonso Davies, Ismael Kone, and Moise Bombito.

I know plenty of English clubs (and many others) run camps all over Canada and the United States now. Canada alone has produced Davies, Jonathon David, Kone (one of Serie A best midfielders), Promise David (just signed by Brighton), Alistair Johnson (fixture at Celtic and they love him), Bombito (Lille starting CB when fit), Eustaquio (captained Porto), De Fougerolles (young Fulham talent), Liam Millar (scored in Prem last week), and the three Villareal boys Buchanan, Saliba, and Oluwaseyi who are all off to great starts. May not all be household names, but some proper footballers coming out of North America now.

And youth "soccer" is far from pay to play if you're good enough. Academies will snatch you up now. Most scouts will tell you they can tell by 8 or 9 years old if someone could "make it".

And all sports can be compared in terms of cost, with soccer probably one of the cheapest, most accessible options. Of course travel teams and such cost money, but this is true for all sports in NA. The best players will find a way to be in the best positions to succeed, and this era is the first time I'm comfortable saying this.


Welcome.
Thank you. And I agree with your assessment as well. I don’t think there are enough areas in the US where young players can get access to good coaching and competition, but there are definitely some pockets where it’s happening. All mls clubs didn’t have operational academies until the early 2010s, so we don’t have that many senior-age players who even had access to them throughout their youth. It’s very much a work in progress, but it’s hard not to see the improvement in the league and quality of player that is being produced in America.
 
One thing many don’t know about MLS is that it has salary cap rules that are similar to other American leagues like the nba or nfl. This means that talent is distributed very differently compared to most of the leagues mentioned there.

For one, there’s a great disparity in what top EPL (or Bundesliga or La Liga, etc) clubs pay and what teams near the relegation zone pay.

Also, most clubs in Europe, regardless of the league or their standing in the table, will have a salary structure that looks something like:

1-3 star players who make X amount

5-7 proven starters/important players who make maybe 80% of that

6-10 part time starters or important bench players who make another 20% less than that.

After that, you’ll have a few fringe players who might make a good bit less.

Obviously, those numbers are just general estimates, but you get the gist of it.

In MLS, however, the rules are different (and complicated). Each team can have up to 3 designated players. As I said, the rules are complicated, but designated players would usually make at least 1.8 million USD, but there is no limit. After that, most team’s starters would likely make 500-800k USD per year, but most of your bench players will be making 100-300k USD per year.

The higher paying spots also tend to go to attacking players, as goals attract more fans. And ambitious teams will use every loophole they can find to pay players more, but the main salary differentiator between big spenders and less ambitious clubs is in what they’re paying designated players, or DPs.

So, while there are some good players and plenty of decent on the pitch in an mls game, there are also some who really aren’t very good at all. Basically all mls teams are going to be affected more by injuries than clubs in other leagues, and are much less likely to have substitutes who can make a big impact.

I tend to think that the better teams in the championship would outclass mls teams, especially over the course of a season, but that mls teams would match up pretty well with teams in the bottom half of the championship.

It’s not an amazing level, but it is pretty impressive for Sullivan to be doing as well he is as a 16 year-old (he turns 17 on September 28).
Yeah that makes sense. MLS trying to keep a balance to the squads. I can't help but feel this is largely due to the club owners protecting their assets and ensuring all teams can compete with no promotion system. AKA safer long-term revenue for the rich... The three "designated players" act as a way to nerf the power of the richest clubs I take it.

It is interesting. I do agree it does seem like the MLS has better high end players than these comparable leagues, but also worse bottom level lads as you mentioned. Besides Jarred Bowen this year, it does feel as if any top level player in the Championship is instantly "food-chained" or bought by a "bigger" club. Thanks for clarity.
 
It will be very interesting watching Cavan over the remaining games of the MLS season.

The scale below is a little bit arbitrary - but I made it to tease out a leap he might have made in the past stretch of games that if someone isn’t watching may not be apparent.

Prospect Production Levels (in this case - for a 16 year old prospect)

Level 1 - On bench. Note - most to 16 year old elite prospects - many who go on to wonderful careers (and many who don’t) are here. Getting a coach to trust you with all the attacking and defensive responsibilities against full grown men - when everyone’s careers depend on winning and and losing - is hard!
Level 2 - Some minutes (off bench, cup games, low pressure games like blowouts, etc.)
Level 3 - Starting minutes
Level 4 - Starting minutes + glimpses of actual production (i.e. a goal here, an assist there)
Level 5 - Starting minutes + decent production (at least a few goals + assists for an attacker). Looking like an “Average” team/league player (who’s not 16)
Level 6 - Starting minutes + great production (i.e. objectively one of the best players on the team). Basically a star on the team based on production right now, regardless of age.

Cavan Sullivan has made multiple leaps this year. He started at Level 2 and is now at Level 5 - which is itself very, very good. He's 16.

However - over his past 5/6 games - he might actually be at Level 6. It’s a bit too early to tell - it could be a hot streak. If he keeps this form up then he will clearly be there.

If he is well and truly at Level 6 and one of the best players on his team right now - regardless of age - that is totally unprecedented in MLS for a 16 year old and really wild.

For the record - this is certainly past Freddy Adu (in a *much* worse MLS league - no academies, much lower salary cap, non-existent global scouting, etc - he was never beyond Level 4) and Alphonso Davies (also Level 4 - but if someone wanted to argue level 5 i wouldn’t fight them). Lucas Herrington who went to Hull over the summer was probably Level 5 beginning towards Level 6 - but he’s 19 years old with multiple years of experience under his belt.

Alphonso Davies is a tricky comparison - attacker vs. defender aside - as Davies had attributes (speed, acceleration, strength, power, physical frame along with work ethic) that projected clearly to “worldwide elite” even at 16. He was a very “high floor” prospect. With Cavan - who is smaller and doesn’t have any outstanding purely physical attributes - the range of outcomes is just larger. Will he be a good prem player? I really don’t know - but what he’s doing now is pretty special.
 
Yeah that makes sense. MLS trying to keep a balance to the squads. I can't help but feel this is largely due to the club owners protecting their assets and ensuring all teams can compete with no promotion system. AKA safer long-term revenue for the rich... The three "designated players" act as a way to nerf the power of the richest clubs I take it.

It is interesting. I do agree it does seem like the MLS has better high end players than these comparable leagues, but also worse bottom level lads as you mentioned. Besides Jarred Bowen this year, it does feel as if any top level player in the Championship is instantly "food-chained" or bought by a "bigger" club. Thanks for clarity.
Protecting their investments is definitely a top priority. It’s understandable in many ways, given that the league was started as a business investment.

The DP rule actually originated as a way for LA Galaxy to sign David Beckham in 2007. At that time, they had a miniscule salary cap that wouldn’t have allowed for him to be signed. It grew over time as a way for clubs to sign marketable stars, and for more ambitious clubs to seek out a competitive advantage that wouldn’t end up in them dominating the league. Even as good as Messi is, Miami is still just one of the best teams, and isn’t guaranteed to win every trophy.

But there is a push and pull between the ambitious owners (most of whom are newer), and the ones who are more content with the status quo (who typically have been around longer). The San Diego FC owners paid a 500 million dollar expansion fee just to start the team a few years ago. You don’t do that unless you’re eager to really grow your investment. https://www.espn.com/soccer/story/_/id/49434125/mls-capitalize-world-cup-don-garber-commissioner

This article from August touches on the possible future for the league, and mentions the goal of some owners to implement a 30 million dollar salary cap, which would represent a pretty radical change, and allow clubs to build squads with much better depth while keeping the high end quality.


As for the mls structure vs that of other leagues, I like some aspects of both, and dislike others.

I enjoy the promotion and relegation battles, but understand that they’re not coming to mls any time soon. And while salary caps can suppress player wages, they do provide stability and balanced competition. You’re not going to see and mls team pull a Bolton, for example, and I do think that’s a benefit for the fans.

What I really don’t like about MLS (or the the other American sports leagues is the imbalanced schedules. In leagues where every team plays every other team once at home, and once away, the league title really means a lot, and helps to identify a deserving champion. But the US leagues chase money, and everyone obsesses over the playoffs, which often renders individual league games somewhat meaningless. I love that every game in the premier league holds essentially the same level of importance in determining the champion.
 
It will be very interesting watching Cavan over the remaining games of the MLS season.

The scale below is a little bit arbitrary - but I made it to tease out a leap he might have made in the past stretch of games that if someone isn’t watching may not be apparent.

Prospect Production Levels (in this case - for a 16 year old prospect)

Level 1 - On bench. Note - most to 16 year old elite prospects - many who go on to wonderful careers (and many who don’t) are here. Getting a coach to trust you with all the attacking and defensive responsibilities against full grown men - when everyone’s careers depend on winning and and losing - is hard!
Level 2 - Some minutes (off bench, cup games, low pressure games like blowouts, etc.)
Level 3 - Starting minutes
Level 4 - Starting minutes + glimpses of actual production (i.e. a goal here, an assist there)
Level 5 - Starting minutes + decent production (at least a few goals + assists for an attacker). Looking like an “Average” team/league player (who’s not 16)
Level 6 - Starting minutes + great production (i.e. objectively one of the best players on the team). Basically a star on the team based on production right now, regardless of age.

Cavan Sullivan has made multiple leaps this year. He started at Level 2 and is now at Level 5 - which is itself very, very good. He's 16.

However - over his past 5/6 games - he might actually be at Level 6. It’s a bit too early to tell - it could be a hot streak. If he keeps this form up then he will clearly be there.

If he is well and truly at Level 6 and one of the best players on his team right now - regardless of age - that is totally unprecedented in MLS for a 16 year old and really wild.

For the record - this is certainly past Freddy Adu (in a *much* worse MLS league - no academies, much lower salary cap, non-existent global scouting, etc - he was never beyond Level 4) and Alphonso Davies (also Level 4 - but if someone wanted to argue level 5 i wouldn’t fight them). Lucas Herrington who went to Hull over the summer was probably Level 5 beginning towards Level 6 - but he’s 19 years old with multiple years of experience under his belt.

Alphonso Davies is a tricky comparison - attacker vs. defender aside - as Davies had attributes (speed, acceleration, strength, power, physical frame along with work ethic) that projected clearly to “worldwide elite” even at 16. He was a very “high floor” prospect. With Cavan - who is smaller and doesn’t have any outstanding purely physical attributes - the range of outcomes is just larger. Will he be a good prem player? I really don’t know - but what he’s doing now is pretty special.
I think Cavan is a level six by your standards. He’s 5th in the entire league in goal contributions per 90 for players who’ve played more than 1000 minutes:

Goal contributons per 90 for those who played above 1,000 minutes
Rank Player Club Mins G A G+A G+A/90
1 L. Messi MIA 1910 18 13 31 1.46
2 P. Musa DAL 1621 18 5 23 1.28
3 E. Da Silva FerreiraCIN 1783 13 11 24 1.21
4 L. Suárez MIA 1492 12 8 20 1.21
5 C. Sullivan PHI 1368 6 11 17 1.12
6 S. Surridge NSH 1448 15 1 16 0.99
7 G. Santos HOU 2035 13 8 21 0.93
8 N. Fernández NYC 2134 15 7 22 0.93
9 P. Biel CLT 2192 12 10 22 0.90
10 D. Bouanga LAFC 2114 13 8 21 0.89


It’s also important to understand that his team was dreadful during the first part of the season, earning 10 points in their first 16 games without him playing very much. However, since play resumed after the World Cup, he’s produced 9 goal contributions in 9 games, and the team has 7 wins and 2 draws. He’s not the only reason for that, but he is the main one in my opinion.
 
USA announce their Sep/Oct squad on Thursday. Supposedly it is supposed to be a mix of both WC players and first timers. Would be a great next step in development to see where he’s at talent wise.
 
I know the comments werent the same, I was posting the other article separately.

I'd read the original comments before and I didnt think they were bad, found the video now of him saying it. Still dont think its bad. Appreciate it's embryonic days for the kid:


Oh, this doesn't sound as bad as I was thinking when @domalino mentioned the comments.

It came off a little more like he would have liked to have contributed to that RW as he backs himself to offer something of value there.

Very young and naive to think that perhaps, but it didnt sound overtly arrogant.

I think but I could see how somebody could take it the wrong way.
 
I would say its similar to the Championship/Eredivise/Portuguese League/Turkish lig in terms of average quality... and not many 16 year olds stealing the show in these leagues.
Definitely taken great strides in recent years but all you need to do is put an MLS game on to realise that is not true imo.

Nonetheless this kid is exciting.
 
I have no doubt that if he were in our academy now he would be the star player in his age range but a lot changes between 16-20..kids can stop developing or even go backwards, if he doesn’t that’s a hell of a player we have.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top