Celtic Thread | 2024/25

[Magicpole]

Madden was left 'amazed' by VAR Alan Muir's decision not to recommend a penalty and reckons Rangers were denied a clear spot kick.

He said: "This is 100 per-cent a penalty kick.

"It doesn’t matter when the holding started, when it ended or what direction the players are moving.

"This is clear evidence of holding within the penalty area and I’m amazed this hasn’t been identified by VAR.

"Referee team had been excellent until that point. Difficult live, but that’s why VAR is there."

—————
Speaking on Record Sport’s Hotline Live, ex-grade one whistler Des Roache insisted VAR Alan Muir should have spotted Liam Scales hauling down Vaclav Cerny inside the penalty box. And Roache believes Muir broke with protocol by failing to tell ref John Beaton to take a look at the flashpoint for himself on the pitch side monitor. Roache said: “The laws of the game state that, if you are pulling a player outside the penalty area and it continues inside the penalty area it’s a penalty kick.

—————

It’s a factual decision. It was clear for all to see and no argument for the VAR officials. It’s cheating by Celtic minded officials appointed by the Celtic minded head of refereeing.

It’s simple either Collum goes or the VAR team go but preferably both

Madden, like Brother Cheatin Beaton is a Rangers fan. St Mirren my perfectly formed arse. Never a penalty, even for you cheating cunts. Grasping at straws and excuses. We were lush for our standard, but even then the football that did break out we were better. Had more of the ball, more passes.

The great thing is you will be off and running thinking you are as good, if not better than us. Fucking delusional,

The most successful team in the world just changed. That must hurt. You have fuck all now. Absolutely fuck all and to top it all that Waffling wanker will still be in charge.

Oh the Bluebells are very blue indeed.

 

[No.8]

Madden, like Brother Cheatin Beaton is a Rangers fan. St Mirren my perfectly formed arse. Never a penalty, even for you cheating cunts. Grasping at straws and excuses. We were lush for our standard, but even then the football that did break out we were better. Had more of the ball, more passes.

The great thing is you will be off and running thinking you are as good, if not better than us. Fucking delusional,

The most successful team in the world just changed. That must hurt. You have fuck all now. Absolutely fuck all and to top it all that Waffling wanker will still be in charge.

Oh the Bluebells are very blue indeed.

Beaton the Motherwell fan

Madden is a regular at St Mirren

It was actually Celtic fans Muir and Francis Connor that didn’t give it.

The pictures are there. They cheated. It’s that simple and that’s two cup finals in a row

Not one penalty since Celtic fan Willie Collum took over yet the VAR review board say we should have had 5 (five)

 

[Magicpole]

Beaton the Motherwell fan

Madden is a regular at St Mirren

It was actually Celtic fans Muir and Francis Connor that didn’t give it.

The pictures are there. They cheated. It’s that simple and that’s two cup finals in a row

Not one penalty since Celtic fan Willie Collum took over yet the VAR review board say we should have had 5 (five)

I just saw his school page. Motherwell fuck all. He’s one of your own. Madden is as much a St Mirren fan as I am.

 

[jimharri]

Do either of the old firm lose a game, and it's not the fault of the referee? Neil "Colin" Warnock syndrome.

 

[No.8]

Do either of the old firm lose a game, and it's not the fault of the referee? Neil "Colin" Warnock syndrome.

Have you seen the incidents?????

Every single ex referee. Every single pundit has said it’s a clear penalty!!

It’s not up for debate. It’s a factual decision and two Celtic fans on VAR are the only two who think it’s not a penalty

MP has to be at the wind up

 

[jimharri]

Have you seen the incidents?????

Every single ex referee. Every single pundit has said it’s a clear penalty!!

It’s not up for debate. It’s a factual decision and two Celtic fans on VAR are the only two who think it’s not a penalty

MP has to be at the wind up

No; strangely enough I was watching another game. Wish I hadn't, mind.
Therefore, MP being on the wind up is something I can't agree or disagree with. And, of course, you're never on the wind up?

;-)

 

[No.8]

No; strangely enough I was watching another game. Wish I hadn't, mind.
Therefore, MP being on the wind up is something I can't agree or disagree with. And, of course, you're never on the wind up?

;-)

I watched Rangers cheated out a trophy and switched it straight over to City game just as that tit Fernandes was running away in celebration

I’ve had better Sundays

 

[goatfeeder100]

I watched Rangers cheated out a trophy and switched it straight over to City game just as that tit Fernandes was running away in celebration

I’ve had better Sundays

You and me both. Old firms and manc derbies can't be allowed to happen on the same day again. It only ever ends in tears!

 

[Magicpole]

Evidence is the key. Here we go. Clearly outside the box when foul committed. But, Tye Rangers seem to think if he falls into the box they get awarded a penalty. Bless.

 

[Magicpole]

You and me both. Old firms and manc derbies can't be allowed to happen on the same day again. It only ever ends in tears!

Half tears for me on Sunday.