(City Act Now) Some of our fans last night.......

[Ticket For Schalke]

its more of a football song than mocking the dead, what are reasons for singing we're not really here???

I've no idea what the reasons for singing "we're not really here" are, but then again that wasn't written about a specific event that resonated throughout Europe and is still comemorated today. The reason M*nich is sung is because United players died and certain City fans want to get "a rise" out of United fans by singing about it. It's ridiculous.

well why are you asking the question,"why do people sing it?" when its pretty clear you no why?

 

[kippax88]

Guys, i didn't mean for this to turn into a woman fest, but i'd also like to add something else before i leave this thread well alone.

With all these chants whether it M chants or racist chants, the minority that are involved are playing right into UEFA's hands. We all know they are looking for a reason to ban City from Europe, as Platini has stated numerous times in the last transfer window and this 1.

And dont think UEFA cant do it, they can. Do you want to see City banned from European football? I dont.

Jesus its not that bad, its a small minority which judging off this thread are not going to be turned. Your club will either do something about it or it will continue but you're not going to get banned from europe (you need to get there first ;) )

if you banned every club with fans singing songs like these there would be no clubs in europe.

what do u think the italians, german , dutch, spanish, polish ect.... all sing towards their rivals?

 

[Matty]

I've no idea what the reasons for singing "we're not really here" are, but then again that wasn't written about a specific event that resonated throughout Europe and is still comemorated today. The reason M*nich is sung is because United players died and certain City fans want to get "a rise" out of United fans by singing about it. It's ridiculous.

well why are you asking the question,"why do people sing it?" when its pretty clear you no why?

My original question was asking for a "convincing argument" why it should continue to be sung? "Because it gets under United fans skin" isn't convincing. There are numerous ways to do that, and virtually all of them don't involve mocking the dead.

 

[There is a Light]

There will be more sectarian bullshit tomorrow from the small minded idiots in our own crowd who think it makes them look hard to sing 'No Surrender to the IRA', which is more of a far right/ England song and definitely has fuck all to do with City. We all know the type who will be singing this, the wannabe hooligans - the only problem is it makes the rest of us look like a bunch of c*nts.

nothing like stereotyping.

Observe the fuckwits who are singing that facist shite tomorrow and tell me if it's an accurate stereotype or not.

 

[BrightwellsBoot]

nothing like stereotyping.

Observe the fuckwits who are singing that facist shite tomorrow and tell me if it's an accurate stereotype or not.

Also observe the fuckwits singing IRA songs and do the same ! (Listen carfully for "Ooh-Ahh Up The RA")

 

[Ticket For Schalke]

well why are you asking the question,"why do people sing it?" when its pretty clear you no why?

My original question was asking for a "convincing argument" why it should continue to be sung? "Because it gets under United fans skin" isn't convincing. There are numerous ways to do that, and virtually all of them don't involve mocking the dead.

Well if it wasnt for the older generation carrying it on threw the years, the younger lads who do sing it would not.

 

[DTKOAG]

I went to the game on Wednesday and i agree there was a few renditions from both sets of supporters about sectarian shit and all that but nothing over the top and at the end of the game both sets of fans applauded each other.
I enjoyed my day and on Ricster advice had a couple of beers On Albion Street but was a bit disapointed that a couple of the pubs would not serve lads who had football tops on.
I think on a personal basis that this has been blown up a great deal and i am sure that songs and flags may be relevant on Saturday again Celtic.

 

[ssg2]

My original question was asking for a "convincing argument" why it should continue to be sung? "Because it gets under United fans skin" isn't convincing. There are numerous ways to do that, and virtually all of them don't involve mocking the dead.

Well if it wasnt for the older generation carrying it on threw the years, the younger lads who do sing it would not.

Stop blaming the older generation, if you think or know its wrong then don't do it.

If the older generation used to slit people throats for a laugh at games would you carry on doing it?

 

[There is a Light]

Observe the fuckwits who are singing that facist shite tomorrow and tell me if it's an accurate stereotype or not.

Also observe the fuckwits singing IRA songs and do the same ! (Listen carfully for "Ooh-Ahh Up The RA")

I take by your stance on this,you'll be in your element tomorrow.

If Celtic fans sing Ooh ah up the Ra, that is up to them, you shouldn't sink to their level.

And for christs sake, they are Celtic, immersed in that shite for the entire history of their club. What does it have to do with City though - why have us labelled as narrow minded idiots as well?

 

[Ticket For Schalke]

I went to the game on Wednesday and i agree there was a few renditions from both sets of supporters about sectarian shit and all that but nothing over the top and at the end of the game both sets of fans applauded each other.
I enjoyed my day and on Ricster advice had a couple of beers On Albion Street but was a bit disapointed that a couple of the pubs would not serve lads who had football tops on.
I think on a personal basis that this has been blown up a great deal and i am sure that songs and flags may be relevant on Saturday again Celtic.

people on bluemoon blowing things out the water. NEVER.