Manchester City fans have long wondered whether UEFA’s financial fair play rules are, in any way, fair.
And seeing the latest round of punishments handed out to ten clubs who broke the rules, they might wonder if the European governing body is simply taking the mickey.
City were punished heavily last season after they exceeded the limits imposed on their losses for 2011-12 and 2012-13.
The Blues were hit with a £49m fine, a £49m cap on transfer spending, and a reduction in their Champions League squad size from 25 to 21.
Manuel Pellegrini has referred to the punishment as a factor in City’s poor season, as they were blown out of the water in the transfer market by Chelsea and United.
But the latest round of punishments will fuel the sense of injustice surrounding the whole FFP circus, which has clearly been engineered to preserve the status quo in terms of European power, rather than force clubs into better practices.
Inter, who last summer took out a whopping £165million loan to pay off their existing debts, have been hit hardest in the latest round – they have, like City, had their squad for European competition reduced to 21.
The only problem is that Inter have not qualified for European competition next season, and the squad numbers will rise to 22 the following season, and be back to the normal 25 the season after.
In other words, that “punishment” is unlikely to affect them at all. It is akin to banning a blind man from driving – utterly pointless.
And then there is their fine. Inter have been given a £14m penalty, and they will get £10m of that back if they comply with FFP in the next two seasons.
The fines handed out to Monaco (£9m), Roma (£4.5m), Besiktas (£4m) Lokomotiv Moscow (£3.5m), Krasnodar (£3m) ad Sporting Lisbon (£1.4m) are trifling.
Uefa say the level of fine depends on the scale of the breach – in others words, City’s losses were much higher than the losses of this year’s guilty clubs. They say they cannot discuss the figures involved due to confidentiality.
But it totally ignores the size and direction of debt – City demonstrated last year that their debt had been massively cut and they were heading for profit, which they expect to achieve this year.
Inter are still in enormous debt, as are Manchester United, and yet that is ignored.
The good news for City is that they are expected to have their sanctions lifted for next season after cutting their losses to £23million last year, keeping them within the limits – although neither the club nor Uefa has confirmed that as yet.