City launch legal action against the Premier League | City win APT case (pg901)

[abu13]

Just watched a clip on football insider claiming that the Athletic understand that both the Premier league and ourselves are planning to appeal the decision of the APT hearing.

This sounds very promising to me, if the PL are appealing then they must have had significant knock back on their rules, If we are appealing then maybe we feel confident of what the PL won getting overturned.

I'm struggling to understand how the PL can appeal against a decision of their own chosen panel

 

[laserblue]

Leg 3 Masters tarred and feathered and led around the Etihad while sitting on a Donkey pre match.

Masters sitting on Maguire would be a sight to behold.

 

[manimanc]

Just watched a clip on football insider claiming that the Athletic understand that both the Premier league and ourselves are planning to appeal the decision of the APT hearing.

This sounds very promising to me, if the PL are appealing then they must have had significant knock back on their rules, If we are appealing then maybe we feel confident of what the PL won getting overturned.

I'm struggling to understand how the PL can appeal against a decision of their own chosen panel

I think it probably isn't the truth.
When a publication says " they understand " it usually means they haven't got a scoobies.
Nobody knows anything about this one, even the usual pricks in the media haven't made anything up against us.

 

[blueparrot]

I think it probably isn't the truth.
When a publication says " they understand " it usually means they haven't got a scoobies.
Nobody knows anything about this one, even the usual pricks in the media haven't made anything up against us.

Maybe what they are guessing is,if either side lose the case they will appeal it.

 

[pauls]

I think it probably isn't the truth.
When a publication says " they understand " it usually means they haven't got a scoobies.
Nobody knows anything about this one, even the usual pricks in the media haven't made anything up against us.

If the Football Insider told me today is Thursday I wouldn't believe em.Who s their source, Keith Wyness?

 

[Coatigan]

Maybe what they are guessing is,if either side lose the case they will appeal it.

It would seem odd that the PL could appeal a decision of their own panel. If we lost, and then appealed, and they didn't like the outcome of the appeal, I can see the logic in them being able to appeal That part of it. Same as Uefa could have appealed the Cas decision for example. But surely not whatever their own panel determines?

And even if they could, it would seem overly vindictive and aggressive.

 

[citizen_maine]

It would seem odd that the PL could appeal a decision of their own panel. If we lost, and then appealed, and they didn't like the outcome of the appeal, I can see the logic in them being able to appeal That part of it. Same as Uefa could have appealed the Cas decision for example. But surely not whatever their own panel determines?

And even if they could, it would seem overly vindictive and aggressive.

I thought it was an independent panel?

 

[cheekybids]

It would seem odd that the PL could appeal a decision of their own panel. If we lost, and then appealed, and they didn't like the outcome of the appeal, I can see the logic in them being able to appeal That part of it. Same as Uefa could have appealed the Cas decision for example. But surely not whatever their own panel determines?

And even if they could, it would seem overly vindictive and aggressive.

It would surely be Masters finest fuck up….

Introducing an illegal rule
Ignoring advice it’s illegal from shareholders
Appealing the decision it’s illegal from the panel

 

[Coatigan]

I thought it was an independent panel?

Sorry, confused this thread with the 115 case thread.

It is arbitrators here is it not.

 

[blueparrot]

It would seem odd that the PL could appeal a decision of their own panel. If we lost, and then appealed, and they didn't like the outcome of the appeal, I can see the logic in them being able to appeal That part of it. Same as Uefa could have appealed the Cas decision for example. But surely not whatever their own panel determines?

And even if they could, it would seem overly vindictive and aggressive.

Is it their panel though,as we brought the case aginst them.I assume they are entitled to appeal the independent panel decision,the same as the teams they bring a case against are.