City players overrated by City fans?

[mancitymick]

Kinky

Not really it is all about opinions. Yes he was a cracking player but the way some go on about him is OTT. He was good and stood out in a fooking awful side. Never did it at Ajax. I wonder if he was in a great City side would he stand out, answer no

 

[noely]

At present I'd say Adam johnson

in the past I'm gonna say van buyten sure he played a few decent games for us but he got inured and people made out he was Beckenbauer

 

[KolarovsLeftPeg]

If you know your football don't go near this thread with a bargepole.

There are so many.
A more interesting question is valuation of past players in the current market.

There's always one who says Goater would be worth £35million.

 

[nijinsky's fetlocks]

Kinky

Much as you are entitled to hold your opinion mate,I am equally free to give my opinion that you are talking utter nonsense.
The man was gifted.
I am half expecting someone to suggest Colin Bell next,upon which I shall log off and self-harm.

 

[gingerthai]

Kinky

Not really it is all about opinions. Yes he was a cracking player but the way some go on about him is OTT. He was good and stood out in a fooking awful side. Never did it at Ajax. I wonder if he was in a great City side would he stand out, answer no

He doesnt have to stand out in a great City side to be a good player. They would all be playing on a par. You say he didnt do it at Ajax. The question was overated City players not Ajax players.

 

[carlos tevez is a blue]

Kinky

Much as you are entitled to hold your opinion mate,I am equally free to give my opinion that you are talking utter nonsense.
The man was gifted.
I am half expecting someone to suggest Colin Bell next,upon which I shall log off and self-harm.

*must resist, must resist*

 

[mancitymick]

Kinky

Much as you are entitled to hold your opinion mate,I am equally free to give my opinion that you are talking utter nonsense.
The man was gifted.
I am half expecting someone to suggest Colin Bell next,upon which I shall log off and self-harm.

He was gifted but stood out even more because he was in a awful side. Would he have got in this side ? No,

 

[squirtyflower]

uwe rosler

 

[nijinsky's fetlocks]

uwe rosler

Now you're just being silly...

 

[mancitymick]

I think people are getting confused with great players and those that have become cult heros