But what have they got to gain by Brentford going above Liverpool in the table?
Surely - as so many on here have been saying for so long that Liverpool are favoured by corruption - the opposite would have happened in that penalty situation in the first half?
This is a fair rebuttal, and comes up from time to time.
I always answer it with a reference to the financial fraud tactics used to cook books (because that is an element of my professional expertise): you fudge in the margins, overtime, where it is the most difficult to both discover and prove, and the most impactful for the desired outcome.
That is to say, you have to be clever with selection and know when one means of manipulation is not functionally available due do outside constraints/factors. You also have to do your best to avoid creating an easily discerned pattern (by that, I mean for the entities that actually have power to investigate and enforce consequences, not for powerless laymen like football fans being suspicious).
In the case of Liverpool this season, they are abjectively bad and it is abnormally difficult to aid them in most (but not all) matches.
In contrast, United are on quite a hot streak as of late, and so are much easier to help along. Same for Arsenal up until recently.
Even better, we’ve have been mediocre this season, which makes it that much easier to tip the scales on the occasion it might lead to a desirable outcome.
It’s also important to note that manipulation of the sort I am personally claiming is likely occurring is not “all or nothing, all the time”. Sometimes there are no opportunities to give a little nudge one way or another. Sometimes you don’t try at all and just let things play out on their own because you don’t really care about that particularly outcome. And some times the attempts to manipulate are unsuccessful. That is also the case with other types of corruption and manipulation.
I think some believe many of us are claiming that there is an all encompassing, ever-present, all-knowing, omnipotent master planner that is carefully orchestrating the outcomes of all league matches. And that is very much not the case.
But we have plenty of examples of manipulation of sport events to attain certain ultimate outcomes in the past (both in England and elsewhere, including in top tier football) to show us not only how it can be done but that it can be successful.
And, furthermore, the most successful schemes tend to come from governing bodies themselves for fairly obvious reasons.