Franny Lee's Barrel Chest
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 23 Aug 2005
- Messages
- 4,308
Why is this rule still upheld?
If, say, a player played for Watford against City in the third round of the cup and City then won and went on to sign that Watford player in the January window, why on earth can't he then play for City in subsequent rounds?
Similarly, say Reece Warbara played for Oldham in early rounds, got knocked out, then he's recalled to City who have progressed, why can't he play for City?
I think it's a ridiculous rule personally.
If, say, a player played for Watford against City in the third round of the cup and City then won and went on to sign that Watford player in the January window, why on earth can't he then play for City in subsequent rounds?
Similarly, say Reece Warbara played for Oldham in early rounds, got knocked out, then he's recalled to City who have progressed, why can't he play for City?
I think it's a ridiculous rule personally.