David James or Shay Given?

[Bluemoonbaldboy]

I really don't get this Given thing,I think he is a good GK but he has done nothing more
for us than Hart.The defence has been steadier in the second half of the season also.
Joe Hart must feel pissed off having had to play in front of Dunne & Richards having alternative mares and when Hughes sorted it out he gets dropped.

Dunne didn't improve until Shay came in

 

[Colins Bellend]

I really don't get this Given thing,I think he is a good GK but he has done nothing more
for us than Hart.The defence has been steadier in the second half of the season also.
Joe Hart must feel pissed off having had to play in front of Dunne & Richards having alternative mares and when Hughes sorted it out he gets dropped.

Dunne didn't improve until Shay came in

Wrong mate nothing to do with Given it was about the CB partnership