Petrovs left peg said:A Great topic.
As a 38 year old I never envisaged the Etihad having the same pull as Maine Road did. For me it is not a choice as I will remember good times from them both. This year the Etihad became the venue of my best EVER moment as a city fan. I can comfortably call it home as when I'm older I'll hopefully be telling my grandkids about that day in May (and more) rather the highlight being the Charlton game or the 5-1, although they'll get the full story on them too!
I'm sure for the generation above me that witnessed title and cup winning sides at MR, it may be different.
The Etihad is now the venue if the greatest ever title winning game, AND our home.
Skashion said:It'll never be Maine Road. I'll always love that ground more than the Etihad despite watching many more matches at The Etihad. I was one of the 36,000 who witnessed its birth - with Sun Jihai having Ronaldinho in his back pocket all game. If it should be anyone's baby, it should probably be mine. But it's not because neither the ground nor the surroundings have anything like the character of Maine Road.
However, yes, it's feeling more like home now. It's witnessed trophies now. The birth of new crazes. Legendary matches. Great atmospheres. A pitch invasion. It'll never be Maine Road but it may yet be home.
Robbo. said:Maine Road for me had good memories but the Etihad has beaten it by ten fold. Its my new home and I'm proud of it. I was always a little embarrassed by Maine Rd as it did look tired.
All for me thats missing in the etihad is MCFC on the seating in white like most grounds have.