Carragher without at doubt. Has little footballing knowledge and, even if he did, would have absolutely no interest in applying it with any sense of balance or insight.
How the hell he keeps getting the city games is beyond me. You know he's not going to do a good job, you know he's not going to be respectful, you know he's not going to give any meaningful analysis, he's just going to use the platform to promote Liverpool at every opportunity.
Whilst I don't expect ex pros to put their footballing loyalties completely aside , he's positioned himself as a joke of a supporting actor, with an evident nasty streak, who can't accept anything other than Liverpool first. He's a man child who has somehow won the pundits lottery despite a complete lack of any skill, judgement, fairness or appeal. A no mark player who was consistently the weak link in any side he played in, and he's even worse in his current role.
He's one of this new brigade of "pundits" who is merely waiting for the other party to stop speaking, or pause long enough to allow an interruption, so that they can open their own gobs again as if they think they get paid by the word.
Watch him on any clip, he's more desperate to interrupt a conversation than my wife, and is so full of himself that with the crap he spouts he'd get right into trump's government as chief shit spouter of the shit spouting division of shit spoutery. I actively do not watch things with him on, he turns my stomach.
Should never have held on to his position after spitting at that family in the car either.