GaudinoMotors
Well-Known Member
Who cares? - We'd only miss out on them too.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Florian Writz Alternatives
- Thread starter ojeme
- Start date
Who is your suggestion?
1st tier
Wirtz
Cole palmer
Pedri
Olmo
Doue
2nd tier
Xavi Simmons
Quedrogo
Guler
Mora
Reyna
Some of them are young and we’d be buying potential over ready made but Bowen is the type of signing we’ve been making too many of in recent years.
I think we should hold fire and trust Phil and Bobb to perform next season. Bobb was on the cusp of having his breakthrough season before being hampered by injuries all season. All we need is a couple of players other than Haaland to score and assist 25 goals. Marmoush will certainly provide that, hopefully Foden returns back to form and we’re laughing. Savinho second season and Doku will be wanting to show he can make it at City. Echeverri may also impress Pep. Signing a couple of full backs could also mean we see O’Reilly play further up.
It’s not the end of the world that we aren’t signing Wirtz, but I’m not naive enough to say he won’t improve Liverpool.
It’s not but it feels like should be our transfer window, I would take all 3 players they have.
Wrapped up early, all feel like their first choice.
PL title and a solid transfer window.
I don’t even think Alexander-Arnold leaving will be that bad for them. They renewed the ones that count.
We’re getting what’s left and they have gone and that used to be us.
On the flip side, big money moves don’t always work, be it the pressure etc. The list of them and the success is not great.
I’m unsure where he fits in and I assume a false 9 potentially.
Salah won’t have a season like he did.
I prefer Wirtz to Isak, as I think he would have raised them more of a level.
simon23
Well-Known Member
Depends -if he looked alright is a bit of a large simplification.....So if Wirtz looked alright but only had 3 goals and 2 assists we'd be interested?
I would say we would look to buy a player if he had the highest level of technical ability, fitted into the way we wanted to play and had the right attitude/personality on and off the pitch....and then they would also look at fitness/injury records as well.
Pedro is more of an 8, I would say. Not sure Olmo is top tier.1st tier
Wirtz
Cole palmer
Pedri
Olmo
Doue
2nd tier
Xavi Simmons
Quedrogo
Guler
Mora
Reyna
Some of them are young and we’d be buying potential over ready made but Bowen is the type of signing we’ve been making too many of in recent years.
What was Lampard by the way, as he's the most similar to Phil.
Hoping for Foden to be the creative output is very very risky. We need a 10 but yeah it most likely won’t happen. Maybe Echeverri comes through and it better than we expect at his current ageI’d be looking at Rayan Cherki.
But I agree with what others have said, we’ll probably go for 2 CMs (most likely Reijnders and Gibbs-White) and play Foden in the 10.
The entire 2nd tier you listed is not worth going for, for a mix of issues like injury or attitude problems, or quality not high enough.1st tier
Wirtz
Cole palmer
Pedri
Olmo
Doue
2nd tier
Xavi Simmons
Quedrogo
Guler
Mora
Reyna
Some of them are young and we’d be buying potential over ready made but Bowen is the type of signing we’ve been making too many of in recent years.
Your 1st tier has a brittle Olno, and while the rest would elevate us, none of them are realistic.
Reijnders and MGW are pretty much the best realistic options for us.
And perhaps we can see the success of players like Doue and Yamal, as well as O Reilly, to not be so afraid to supplement the squad with our academy every now and then, there is talent there.
Pedro is more of an 8, I would say. Not sure Olmo is top tier.
What was Lampard by the way, as he's the most similar to Phil.
Pedri can play 8 or 10 which would be perfect for us.
The entire 2nd tier you listed is not worth going for, for a mix of issues like injury or attitude problems, or quality not high enough.
Your 1st tier has a brittle Olno, and while the rest would elevate us, none of them are realistic.
Reijnders and MGW are pretty much the best realistic options for us.
And perhaps we can see the success of players like Doue and Yamal, as well as O Reilly, to not be so afraid to supplement the squad with our academy every now and then, there is talent there.
You might be right but give me an academy player or a brittle Olmo over fucking Bowen.
He's a magnificent player. Sadly no way he'll be going anywhere.Pedri can play 8 or 10 which would be perfect for us.
I dont want Bowen either.You might be right but give me an academy player or a brittle Olmo over fucking Bowen.
For RW, id sooner give McAidoo the odd chance if for some reason both Savio and Bobb cant cut it.
As we should. I’m pleased we are backing Phil whilst he’s having a bad year.We won't buy another 10. We will wait like we did post Kompany and Aguero to get the right man.
I think the club will back Foden to get himself back to his best.
Never get him mate but would love him at city .Arda Guler
Goats left knee
Well-Known Member
Believe in our own Jimmy Grimble.
Philip Walter Foden
Philip Walter Foden
CΛL
Well-Known Member
I’ve yet to see anything from Wirtz to suggest he could even get close to last seasons Phil Foden.
Let’s back him to claim his throne.
Let’s back him to claim his throne.
I hope you watched more than Writz’s highlights. Yes I know Foden 2023/24 was a dynamite but it would be a big risk to go into the season relying on him. You are only as good as your current form. We have seen players that were called “Next Messi” slip into oblivion.Foden! Been watching Wirtz highlights, Foden is better.
Liverpool was by far better than us last season and so was Arsenal and yet both are going hard in the market trying to upgrade. If we are going to go into a new season with a bold face and little substance, then I’m sorry we would likely be chasing too 4 or top 6 by the end of it.
richards30
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 20 May 2009
- Messages
- 31,739
Arda Guler
Would love to see what he could do for us.