four four two; best foreign players

[Damocles]

About which part? Him being foreign or him being our best foreign player? Both are pretty reasonable claims.

edit: I've changed my mind, Trautmann is probably our best ever (though I never saw him play) but I'd still say Dunne is second.

dunne was a great servent but come on, our BEST foreign player I dont think so not even in top 10.

Nobody said most talented, they said best. I'd define a 4 time POTY as our best.

 

[Skashion]

and drived us to 3rd and fa cup..

while i agree he was our hero last season and at times we were a one man team, surely hes not the best foreign player we've ever had?

No he didn't, no he didn't. Tevez probably wasn't even in the top five of players who contributed to that cup run. Wasn't even on the pitch for the most important game.

Nope, he was a douche last season as well. If that man was Silva, yes we were. If Tevez, no.

 

[marl0we]

About which part? Him being foreign or him being our best foreign player? Both are pretty reasonable claims.

edit: I've changed my mind, Trautmann is probably our best ever (though I never saw him play) but I'd still say Dunne is second.

dunne was a great servent but come on, our BEST foreign player I dont think so not even in top 10.

If we're talking about pure talent maybe not, but then would you say George Weah or Robinho are contenders for best ever foreign City player? No, because I think the discussion is about what they've done for the club. No-one has done more than Trautmann or Dunne I wouldn't say.

 

[Cellarite]

Well I think Uwe deserves a mention.

 

[Laurent Charvet]

Arni Arason

 

[pudge]

and drived us to 3rd and fa cup..

while i agree he was our hero last season and at times we were a one man team, surely hes not the best foreign player we've ever had?

No he didn't, no he didn't. Tevez probably wasn't even in the top five of players who contributed to that cup run. Wasn't even on the pitch for the most important game.

Nope, he was a douche last season as well. If that man was Silva, yes we were. If Tevez, no.

Scored in both games against Leicester did he not? I'd say they were important goals

Scored 1 against Notts County too, albeit to make it 3-0.

 

[Wellsblue21]

About which part? Him being foreign or him being our best foreign player? Both are pretty reasonable claims.

edit: I've changed my mind, Trautmann is probably our best ever (though I never saw him play) but I'd still say Dunne is second.

dunne was a great servent but come on, our BEST foreign player I dont think so not even in top 10.

If we're talking about pure talent maybe not, but then would you say George Weah or Robinho are contenders for best ever foreign City player? No, because I think the discussion is about what they've done for the club. No-one has done more than Trautmann or Dunne I wouldn't say.

Reeled in?

 

[Le Havre Oswald]

About which part? Him being foreign or him being our best foreign player? Both are pretty reasonable claims.

edit: I've changed my mind, Trautmann is probably our best ever (though I never saw him play) but I'd still say Dunne is second.

dunne was a great servent but come on, our BEST foreign player I dont think so not even in top 10.

If we're talking about pure talent maybe not, but then would you say George Weah or Robinho are contenders for best ever foreign City player? No, because I think the discussion is about what they've done for the club. No-one has done more than Trautmann or Dunne I wouldn't say.

sorry i thought it ment best in quality

 

[wez99]

Tevez is the best foreign player i have ever seen at City, but YaYa is catching up rapid.

 

[toddluvzgta]

u lot have it somewhat wrong.

surely Robinho has got to be better than Tevez. Elano might be, too, for that matter. Dunnie is up there in the ranks with Benarbia, and Silva es magico.

and I have never seen Trautmann play either, so