He's been found out, I've said this previously on here that he has zero credibility now. Anyone can sit in a studio using hind site of what players should or should not be doing, disceting tactics of what managers should not or should be doing.
In the heat of professional football when you have personalities of players you are managing, the outside variables of what the other team is doing and how you react to it, it's a totally different kettle of fish.
All football pundits are lazy leaches, they are either too pussy to put their head on the chopping blocks and go into management, or they have tried it and been chewed up and spat out. You can make a case for every one of them, Souness, Keane, Shearer, Quinn, Mcmananan, Owen, Keegan. Either failed or not good enough to take the steps and be successful.