Given not that great after all.

[lee-mcfc]

Not slating him, just glad the whole Given v Hart debate can be put to rest. The second goal was due to him. At this level you want to start for the team you dont make these mistakes in Cup matches, id rather we dropped 3 points than booted out a cup match.
.

by starting this thread, i'd say you were.

 

[manimanc]

what??? with a reserve back four in front of him? have a day off mate,it`s all these doom and gloom comments that make us a laughing stock. we got beat,we played the kids and WE REALLY PLAYED THE KIDS,i`m not losing any sleep about it,can`t wait for saturday...

 

[pee dubya]

Sure, Hart hasn't made any mistakes recently has he?

Dude a mistake that costs you 3 points in the early half of the season vs a mistake that gets your team knocked out the cup very different scenarios.
Tell me you believe 100% Given is commited to the City cause and he deserves to start over Hart?

I prefer Hart over Given, i just find your assertion that this game alone proves it to be ridiculous.

 

[Peter Grant]

Was you at the game or basing your opinion on radio commentary? I personally think Hart should be number 1 but your being very harsh on Given, especially when the players in front of him tonight were far less experienced than those who have been playing in front of Hart all season.

 

[happy]

Dude a mistake that costs you 3 points in the early half of the season vs a mistake that gets your team knocked out the cup very different scenarios.
Tell me you believe 100% Given is commited to the City cause and he deserves to start over Hart?

Are you suggesting that goalkeepers can choose which games they make mistakes in? An error is an error, Hart is our first choice goalie, tonight proved nothing.

 

[didactic]

what??? with a reserve back four in front of him? have a day off mate,it`s all these doom and gloom comments that make us a laughing stock. we got beat,we played the kids and WE REALLY PLAYED THE KIDS,i`m not losing any sleep about it,can`t wait for saturday...

Fair play maybe a reaction to how gutted I am. Im actually more pissed off with a non exsistant Santa Cruz.

 

[lee-mcfc]

[bigimg]http://i195.photobucket.com/albums/z123/Platinumgamer164/th1221020552628.gif[/bigimg]

 

[GStar]

Idiotic OP... Vidal Boyata Mee Cuningham as our defence and you think people have been aswered?

And i've always advocated Hart over Given btw...

 

[MyJeckyllDoesntHyde]

Funny how he questions Given's dedication to the team when it's apparent he didn't even bother listen to the game. Shay was our stand out performer and it's a real shame we're out and he wont get a further run in this cup. This is coming from someone who prefers Hart btw.

 

[didactic]

[bigimg]http://i195.photobucket.com/albums/z123/Platinumgamer164/th1221020552628.gif[/bigimg]

hahaha.