Given or Hart?? - can we get a poll going? Poll added.

[Warwickhunt]

Re: Given or Hart?? - can we get a poll going?

given

someone with experience of big games who stays on his line, or someone with no experience of big games and who flaps at crosses? atleast the defence knows what givens going to do.

Hart isn't there yet, he will be, but not at the moment.

 

[desouza10]

Re: Given or Hart?? - can we get a poll going?

Hart has one thing that is key in a goalkeeper - presence. Standing at about 6"4, he's a very big lad. His decision making was the one thing that was concerning, which he has sorted after a good season out at Birmingham. Hart should be no.1, and Given should be looking to help him as much as he can.

 

[Sabster]

Re: Given or Hart?? - can we get a poll going?

given

someone with experience of big games who stays on his line, or someone with no experience of big games and who flaps at crosses? atleast the defence knows what givens going to do.

Hart isn't there yet, he will be, but not at the moment.

Just like to point out Hart had a 98% catch completion rate compared to given's less than 90%

 

[mcfcnorthstand]

Re: Given or Hart?? - can we get a poll going?

Dibble for me

 

[not my fault!]

Re: Given or Hart?? - can we get a poll going?

Hart for me and my old man thinks so too.

 

[DenisLawBackHeel74]

Re: Given or Hart?? - can we get a poll going?

a very very difficult question....

I would have to say Joe Hart in the Prem and Given in Europe...

Joe Hart is up and coming and has proven that he can cut it in the premiership..he has also indicated he doesn't want to sit on the bench and would rather go out on loan than do that. if he did go out on loan and had another stellar season we would have to sell him becasue any self respecting player who was snubbed by their club twice would and should tell them to fuck off...

Given is the finished article but needs some competition for his place to keep him on his toes...i would play him in Europe and for big cup games....

 

[BlueTG]

Re: Given or Hart?? - can we get a poll going?

Given. It's not even close....I don't know what you guys are looking at. Hart will be good but he's not at Given's level right now. We won't win anything with Hart in net next season.

I don't know what you're looking at, Given's never been and is never going to be world class, too many flaws in his game, Joe is at the same level give or take now, and will get better.

 

[darrenwassall]

Re: Given or Hart?? - can we get a poll going?

I know its not possible to do this for every player on the pitch, but could we have a poll on who should be our Keeper this season? As the keeper is quite an important position!

I know that for myself I was really happy when Shay came, but having an objective look at things / watching both of them I feel Joe has proved himself to be a better keeper....

My vote would be for Joe.

ffs,if you get a poll going will that be the end of it or will we continue to have this bollocks every day?

 

[calculated]

Re: Given or Hart?? - can we get a poll going?

one is 'top 5 in the world' according to mancini, one is 3rd in line behind useless green and bristols no.1

I know my choice.

 

[poyntonblueboy]

Re: Given or Hart?? - can we get a poll going?

hart for me, he tends to deal with crosses better than given.