Good Pundit / Bad Pundit

[Bluefen]

For me the best by a mile is Savage - say's it how it is and is funny with it

Worst has to be -Steve Claridge - how someone with a personality bypass gets on telly and radio so much is beyond me - I'd rather watch/listen to Garth Crooks than that journeyman

 

[citymad]

Best: Savage
Worst: Alan Green followed by Mike Parry

 

[Akira]

Good pundit: Andy Townsend

Bad pundit: 85% of the rest of the pundit population.

 

[bigbadbrad]

Best - Ron Atkinson. Yes i know he was shite but calling Ranieri a WOP and the rest was hilarious

 

[theevilweasel]

Best pundit : Souness

Worst : Townsend

 

[Lythamblue]

Best: Lee Dixon - always sticks up for us and takes no shit from other so called experts

Worst: I fear is yet to come when Ratty starts at sky, but for now it has to be Alan Green, the only guy I have to switch off as soon as I hear his voice

 

[dw7]

Best pundits are on Irish tv they say it as it is no holding back and argue slot amongst themselves

 

[charliebigspuds]

For me the best by a mile is Savage - say's it how it is and is funny with it

Worst has to be -Steve Claridge - how someone with a personality bypass gets on telly and radio so much is beyond me - I'd rather watch/listen to Garth Crooks than that journeyman

best Savage
worst is Alan Green
the soon to be worst will be Ragy Neville, impartial he will never be

I quite like Claridge, I was watching "you're on skysports" a few years ago and someone phoned in and asked Claridge who he would have liked to play for and he said us, I was amazed, he said because our fans are so loyal and always create a great atmosphere, this was back in the Maine Road days BTW

 

[Gaylord du Bois]

Souness the best. Knows the game inside out.(Just pips Buzzer)
That rubber gobbed **** Coleman by far the worst.

 

[stony]

Very few good pundits. Souness and Savage are the best.