Guidetti

D D

Daz_Blue

Well-Known Member
Joined
16 Jan 2006
Messages
12,481
Location
FLORIDA, USA, FORMALLY OF WOODHOUSE PARK MANCHESTE
What would you do with him ......

Bring him back and play him
Send him out on loan again
Sell him


If we are going to be busy in the transfer market this Summer and bringing in strikers would he want to stay ?
Samaras scored for fun in Holland is Guidetti over rated or do we have a gem on our hands ?
 
Bring him back and then send him out on a short loan to another premier league club, hopefully one that will give him time so that he can acclimate to the pace of the league instead of being forced into playing well with us in a stop start scenario where he won't be given the amount of time he wishes.
 
I just can't see him being good enough unfortunately. With all the will in the world I can't see him being good enough long term for us.
 
adrianr said:
Season long loan to Swansea or Norwich or Wigan if they stay up.
Click to expand...
Think this is the best idea.

If he can cut it and score with any of these (or equivalent) in the English league, it would give us more of an idea of his potential. Not slagging the Dutch league, but there are obvious difference between our leagues.

If I'm honest, I think he could cut it in the prem, as he is a strong lad who isn't scared to put a shift in, and he also knows where the net is. If he has enough to cut it with us time will tell, but the powers that be possibly rate him, else they would have let him go to twente in the summer instead of paying them a £1m in compensation to ward them off.

Hope he gets his chance, as it's always nice to see a graduate of the acadamy come to fruition.
 
I don´t understand how you could compare him to Samaras, he scored 25 in 88 games for like 4 seasons?
Guidetti scored 20 in just 23 games its quite different.

Stupid to compare to ppl who failed since there are alot that succeed aswell, Im sure he will be a great player but maybe not until he is 23 or smth.
 
how can anyone compare him to samaras ????????? loads of great players came out of the dutch league, sneijder, seedorf, van persie, van nisterooy, .................

if we dont give him a chance whats the point in the academy, hes been the best youth player and has proved himself, he cant really do anymore to show he deserves a chance.
 
richards30 said:
I just can't see him being good enough unfortunately. With all the will in the world I can't see him being good enough long term for us.
Click to expand...


Is it just me or are we said to be after vertonghen from ajax because we think he is an improvement on are team? cos as far as i remember Guidetti scored a hat trick against him or is my maths slightly off?
 
g180aj said:
richards30 said:
I just can't see him being good enough unfortunately. With all the will in the world I can't see him being good enough long term for us.
Click to expand...


Is it just me or are we said to be after vertonghen from ajax because we think he is an improvement on are team? cos as far as i remember Guidetti scored a hat trick against him or is my maths slightly off?
Click to expand...

He clumsily gave away an absolutely dreadful pen in that game if I remember rightly.

He's a quality footballer rather than a quality defender imo.
 
alky313 said:
bobmcfc said:
6 month loan to a prem club then bring him back in January.
Click to expand...

Agreed. Top picks for me are as follows:

Swansea
Wigan
Fulham
Bolton
New 3.
Click to expand...

As long as he starts every week. Perhaps Bolton if they stay up? They need a goalscorer
 
A lot to play out beforehand but I could see Newcastle being a realistic option.

They should play in Europe, whether Europa or Champions League so plenty of games and if Ba activates his contract clause then they may be after a new striker. Sure he'd be behind Cisse, while at Swansea he might be the main man, but he'd still get quite a lot of games as he'd come in before Best or Ameobi I'd think.
 
I found this on twitter today:

"Apparently John Guidetti will go to Swansea on loan next season, this is according to John van Zweden (Swansea director) on Dutch TV"

"Interesting that right now in The Hague area, TV West, the message is that # Guidetti goes to Swansea. Have a strong bond that 2 clubs" (in dutch)

So it looks like he will go on loan next season, but probably depends on what strikers City will have next year.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top