Half-Term Player Rating..

[bananamilksheikh]

ok fair enough its only our opinions but i would suggest Ade has scored only 6 goals and missed 3 games through his own stupidity and as you pointed out he has been shit the last 3-4 games.
Teves has played every game and scored 9 goals; not been suspended and has performed at a high level in every game. He would be my players of the first term.
its hard to compare goalkeeers to outfield players. Given still doesnt command his area and cant kick with any consistency.

 

[citymad]

Bellers 9/10
Tevez, NDJ, Given 8/10
Superman,SWP, Bridge 6/10
Ade, RSC 5/10
Lescott,Toure, Ned, Richards 3/10

 

[Fulop's Reflex]

ok fair enough its only our opinions but i would suggest Ade has scored only 6 goals and missed 3 games through his own stupidity and as you pointed out he has been shit the last 3-4 games.
Teves has played every game and scored 9 goals; not been suspended and has performed at a high level in every game. He would be my players of the first term.
its hard to compare goalkeeers to outfield players. Given still doesnt command his area and cant kick with any consistency.

Tevez was average in many games (first few games), he missed the sitter, he ran, ran and ran with no end product. He has scored 6 goals in the league from 16 appearances while Ade has scored the same amount goals from 13 appearances plus 3 assists. I am sure that Ade isn't that shit.

 

[Revolver]

Bellamy (9) has been the best player this season.

De Jong (8) and Given (8) have been excellent.

Tevez (7) has got better and better.

All Hughes players (from what I have read) who seem to have pride in the City shirt and seemed to rate their manager.

Wright Phillips (6) before the injury was getting better and better.

Disappointments have been Toure (4) Adebayor (4) and Robinho (3).

But I am sure that now that Mr Hughes is no longer with us Adeabyor and Robinho will now show the commitment of Bellamy, De Jong etc

 

[Zickler]

We all seem to agree that Bellamy has been by far our best player so far, Can't wait to see how the lads get on in the second half of the season.

 

[MCFC BOB]

Bellamy, De Jong and Given.

Had Tevez been fit all season, he would be up there with those 3.

 

[DontLookBackInAnger]

Bellamy 9
DeJong 8
Barry, Given, Tevez, SWP 7
Bridge, Ireland, Petrov, Adebayor 6
Richards, Zabalata, Robinho, RSC, Lescott, Kompany, Onuoha 5
Sylvinho, Toure 4