Banned Tosspot
Well-Known Member
Re: Given Vs Hart
It's true. Hart comes for crosses and his distribution is better.Robbo. said:
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
hart or given
- Thread starter nevblue
- Start date
Kippax.
Well-Known Member
Re: Given Vs Hart
Last season was his best by far, but 1 i think he doesnt want to come back and 2 needs to come down a peg or two (up his own arse)
Banned Tosspot said:It's true. Hart comes for crosses and his distribution is better.Robbo. said:Never!
Last season was his best by far, but 1 i think he doesnt want to come back and 2 needs to come down a peg or two (up his own arse)
Cobwebcat
Well-Known Member
Re: Given Vs Hart
Hart: Good on crosses OK shot stopper poor distribution
Given: Poor on crosses Excellent shot stopper excellent distribtion
Given wins.
Hart: Good on crosses OK shot stopper poor distribution
Given: Poor on crosses Excellent shot stopper excellent distribtion
Given wins.
Banned Tosspot
Well-Known Member
Re: Given Vs Hart
Anyway, why start another thread when there's already one?
Bollocks.Robbo. said:Banned Tosspot said:It's true. Hart comes for crosses and his distribution is better.
Last season was his best by far, but 1 i think he doesnt want to come back and 2 needs to come down a peg or two (up his own arse)
Anyway, why start another thread when there's already one?
Banned Tosspot
Well-Known Member
Good call.lee-mcfc said:i agreewez99 said:Give them a half each, sorted!
TFC
Well-Known Member
Re: Given Vs Hart
I did this thread months ago, I really am on the cutting edge ;)
I pick Hart. I think they are both class, but Joe could be City's #1 for 15 years, while Shay probably has another 2 or 3 seasons before he hangs it up (hopefully with no recurrence of the shoulder injury).
We are building a squad that can dominate for the foreseeable future, and having a settled back line is paramount.
I did this thread months ago, I really am on the cutting edge ;)
I pick Hart. I think they are both class, but Joe could be City's #1 for 15 years, while Shay probably has another 2 or 3 seasons before he hangs it up (hopefully with no recurrence of the shoulder injury).
We are building a squad that can dominate for the foreseeable future, and having a settled back line is paramount.
King Geedorah
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 9 Jun 2010
- Messages
- 1,413
Re: Given Vs Hart
The fact that no-one else went in for Given at £6 million while Arsenal had Almunia, United had an aging VDS, Spurs with no confidence in Gomes, Villa an aging Friedal speaks volumes.
The fact that no-one else went in for Given at £6 million while Arsenal had Almunia, United had an aging VDS, Spurs with no confidence in Gomes, Villa an aging Friedal speaks volumes.
Bill
Moderator
given..............just.
Chesley Sullenberger
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 17 Jan 2009
- Messages
- 778
Hart can catch crosses and does not celebrate each save as if he had won the world cup....Hart all the way.
Re: Given Vs Hart
Given has excellent distribution? I thought that was the absolute worst part of his game, and one of Hart's strong points. Also Hart is at least a good-great shot stopper.
Cobwebcat said:Hart: Good on crosses OK shot stopper poor distribution
Given: Poor on crosses Excellent shot stopper excellent distribtion
Given wins.
Given has excellent distribution? I thought that was the absolute worst part of his game, and one of Hart's strong points. Also Hart is at least a good-great shot stopper.