Hart or Neuer?

[Blue Haze]

Blue tinted specs off, Neuer

He can save penalties, Hart can't

 

[GazC]

Blue tinted specs off, Neuer

He can save penalties, Hart can't

Swansea? Euro u21's semis?

Hart can take penalties, Neur can't. ;)

 

[Skashion]

Hart, incredible shotstopper. Most Conference keepers distribute better though. We need to play it out from the back. Whenever he pumps it long, it's as likely to go out of play as hit a blue shirt and considerably more likely to hit an opposition shirt because chances are they'll have a defence or midfield that could outjump our line of 5'8" and 5'9" midgets.

 

[MCFC BOB]

I would have Hart over anyone because he's ours.

 

[MSP]

It's still to early to judge Neuer, this was his first season within big club where he has one or two saves to make during the game and his concentration went down in fair few matches.

If he manages to up that concentration part of his game like Hart already did, he might be huge, obviously very talented keeper.

 

[Ovo]

Hart all day every day. He's the best in the world in my eyes.

 

[Geo-Ali-David mcfc]

Joe hart 100% England's number 1

 

[pudge]

Blue tinted specs off, Neuer

He can save penalties, Hart can't

You are obviously forgetting the last time he faced a penalty...

 

[standupifyouhatemanu]

Hart cause he's at City and Neuer isnt.

This times 100.

Joe loves us, we love him.

Cut him and he would bleed blue.

Silly question, silly thread.....

 

[Bill]

I'd say Neuer is slightly better than him, only because his distribution is second to none. But Hart every time for me. Such a top bloke to have around the squad, you can tell he loves it here and everyone in the team loves him, so for me, he is irreplaceable.

+1